5 ms·
Two self-driving cars involved in 'near miss' in California
- bartbes 11y agoShould probably resync the title to the article, I'm guessing the guardian realised a "near miss" is a hit.
- eterm 11y agonear miss noun noun: near miss; plural noun: near misses 1. a narrowly avoided collision or other accident. "she had a near miss when her horse was nearly sucked into a dyke" 2. a bomb or shot that just misses its target. "he had escaped more than twenty near misses" In no definition is "near miss" a hit, even taking it "literally" near is adjective for the noun miss, so it is a miss that is near. i.e, a miss where two bodies are close but don't hit.
- slazaro 11y agoIt's one of those expressions that means the opposite of what you'd think if it was the first time you came across it. Like "could care less".
- solaris999 11y ago"could care less" only exists out of misappropriation of the original idiom though, which is "couldn't care less" - a phrase which makes far more sense.
- emilssolmanis 11y agoIn any definition, a near miss is a hit. A "near hit" would be what you're looking for... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDKdvTecYAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDKdvTecYAM
- wlkr 11y agoNot in any definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near_miss_%28safety%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near_miss_%28safety%29
- danparsonson 11y ago"Near miss" isn't "nearly a miss" - it's a miss where both parties were near each other. "Near hit" may actually make more logical sense though.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 11y ago"near miss" just means "that was close", or "we almost didn't miss" -- in other words, "we missed, but we were pretty damn close and could have collided". It doesn't mean "nearly missed, but actually hit" -- check any dictionary.
- mlonkibjuyhv 11y agoBut it's used in the sense "too close and not within acceptable margins". It's not a collision, but one might just as well think of it as a "hit" - someone messed up.
- sjcsjc 11y agoReminds me of a trick question my late father used to ask us as kids: "would you rather be nearly saved or nearly drowned?"
- robogimp 11y agoUgh, this article sounds like the Lexus brand trying to latch on to the google self-driving hype train. Hey guys we are making a cool car too! On a more important note: do we really want all the different tech companies and car manufacturers competing to build separate driverless software and standards? Looking at how well that worked out for online maps, doesn't make me feel safer.
- Crito 11y agoIs it really reasonable to expect any automotive manufacturer who wants to remain relevant to not start working on self-driving cars? You can't seriously expect this to be "just a google thing".
- unfamiliar 11y agoI think they were more implying that the software that makes the decisions should be common to all of them. That way we don't allow individual car manufacturers to make potentially fatal mistakes when cutting corners with their software development. I think at the very least there should be a standardisation, so that there can be some communication between cars to aid in resolving traffic jams and other uses.
- coldtea 11y ago>That way we don't allow individual car manufacturers to make potentially fatal mistakes when cutting corners with their software development. Wouldn't all the cars by any manufacturer have to pass the same very rigorous driving tests in the first place, to be able to be sold in the market?
- unfamiliar 11y agoThen you will have people writing software with the aim of pass the tests, not real world safety. I don't think auto testing can catch the type of bugs that can arise sporadically, which could be fatal in the case of self driving cars.
- Tepix 11y agoThis brings up an interesting topic - who is liable when two self driving cars crash (without outside influence)? The car owners? The car manufacturer?
- lucb1e 11y agoYeah, that's the question everyone has been debating for years now.
- flashfabrixx 11y ago”No collision took place.” ”In all cases, the self-driving prototype was not at fault, according to the California Department of Motor Vehicles and the companies.” Source Article: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/06/26/us-autos-selfdriving-nearmiss-idUSKBN0P601T20150626 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/06/26/us-autos-selfdrivi...
- thescrewdriver 11y agoYou're piecing together two unrelated sentences from the article to tell a different story... "No collision took place" - refers to the two cars in this case. "In all cases, the self-driving prototype was not at fault, according to the California Department of Motor Vehicles and the companies." - refers to previous crashes excluding the one being discussed in the article.
- easytiger 11y ago> although the Delphi car was not actually in self-driving mode at the time, it was still required to report the accident under Californian law. Err..
- eterm 11y agoThat's a different incident to the one in the headline isn't it?
- masklinn 11y agoYes, the one in the headline didn't result in an accident.
- masklinn 11y agoSounds like an excellent idea, otherwise there's the risk of companies not reporting any accident by just tagging them all as "manual driving" whether they were manually driven at the time or not.
- jackgavigan 11y agoThe road this happened on frequently has three lanes on a carriageway. I can easily imagine a situation where the cars in question are in the left-most and right-most lanes, and both want to move into the middle lane. Both "see" that the lane is empty and both make their move at the same time. I wonder if these self-driving cars can "see" a turn signal two lanes away. Of course, we don't know if the Google car was in self-driving mode or was being operated by a person. The article only tells one side of the story.
- TickleSteve 11y agoSo I'm taking it that both cars behaved perfectly? They realised a collision was imminent and took evasive action? Sounds like they got it right to me.
- nothrabannosir 11y agoA self-driving Lexus operated by Google apparently cut off a self-driving Audi run by Delphi Automotive as it was trying to change lanes, causing it to take “appropriate action” to avoid a collision, said a Delphi executive. John Absmeier, who was travelling in his company’s car at the time, said the Audi was forced to abort its lane change in the incident, which happened earlier this week. I'm glad it was a robot, and not me driving that car. Not sure if I would have been able to change lanes that fast without causing an accident. That's the issue: one of the robots forced another car to react quickly to avoid an accident. Had this been a human, it could have ended very differently.
- kuschku 11y agoSo that’s why Google’s cars get rear-ended so often
- arpa 11y agomy thoughts exactly: AI drives like an asshole with inhuman reflexes :)
- Oletros 11y agoIt seems that there was no cut-off From Ars Technica [0] It wasn’t a 'near miss' as described in the Reuters story." Instead, she explained how this was a normal scenario, and the Delphi car performed admirably. "Our car did exactly what it was supposed to," she wrote. "Our car saw the Google car move into the same lane as our car was planning to move into, but upon detecting that the lane was no longer open it decided to terminate the move and wait until it was clear again." [0] http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/06/no-2-self-driving-cars-didnt-have-a-close-call-on-silicon-valley-streets/ http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/06/no-2-self-driving-cars-d...
- noonespecial 11y ago"Near" for the robot cars... or their human observers? Zero-point-six-eight seconds, sir. For an android, that is nearly an eternity. --Data
- nthState 11y agoI was thinking the same thing
- Shivetya 11y agoSo I guess the real issue is, we need a Federal standard with regards to self driving cars that they must talk to similar cars within a set radius. Should be far easier that just driving down a crowded road. Effectively each car has the equivalent of a mac address and simply broadcasts its actions and any car listening within range responds appropriately.
- cfallin 11y agoAn Ethernet segment per road, interesting -- gives a whole new meaning to the phrase "collision domain"!
- anticon 11y agoIt's going to be great when these cars are around a bit more. You could have some pretty good fun trying to get one of the self driving cars to crash into you. Won't be that hard to do I'm sure.
- calciphus 11y agoExcept that it'll have a mountain of sensors on it and will be able to show you were at fault.
- connor4312 11y agoNot to be cynical, but this is perfect publicity for Delphi Automotive. There appears to be no third-party confirmation of the incident, solely the say-so of the Delphi executive. It would seem to me (given the low density of self-driving cars and their excellent track record) that the odds of Delphi wanting get in the news and bash a competitor at the same time is greater than the odds of two self-driving cars happening to cross paths and causing a "near-miss".
- thescrewdriver 11y agoBoth vehicles would be doing a ton of data collection, so it's hard to imagine a situation where false claims wouldn't easily be debunked with data/footage from the vehicles themselves.
- connor4312 11y agoIt isn't possible for Google to provide footage showing it _not_ happening, and the release of footage from Delphi would be entirely on their own prerogative.
- codeshaman 11y agoI wouldn't mind living in a world were all news stories are like this - "Something bad almost happened, but it didn't, because the algorithms took care of it". Back to the story, the article doesn't mention if the human drivers had to interfere to avoid collision. It would be quite pointless to have a self-driving car which you cannot trust and be always on the lookout to take over if it does something stupid.
- viraptor 11y agoAlgorithms preventing bad things? That was the whole premise of Minority Report, wasn't it?
- maxerickson 11y agoNo, Minority Report had psychics (the title comes from having 3 of them, so when one of them sees something different than the other 2, there is a "Minority Report").
- viraptor 11y agoIs 3 psychics really different than 3 algorithms? Safety critical software does get implemented sometimes in 2 different ways to cross-check sanity at runtime. Which does of course come up with issues like which side to trust and what to do if they disagree.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- venomsnake 11y agoSo the safety tech worked as expected. That is a great news. There are way more "near misses" everyday from human drivers. Also seeing the "near miss" in the editorialized title - this Carlin quote is mandatory “Here's a phrase that apparently the airlines simply made up: near miss. They say that if 2 planes almost collide, it's a near miss. Bullshit, my friend. It's a near hit! A collision is a near miss. [WHAM! CRUNCH!] "Look, they nearly missed!" "Yes, but not quite.”
- johnbaptiste 11y agoCarlin is ignorant. The OED lists usage of 'near miss' going back to 1940 in a maritime context. It was not made up by the airlines. Even if it was, the phrase still makes sense. It's not 'nearly missed', it's 'a miss where the objects were near'. Have you ever heard the phrase 'it's funny because it's true'? Well this isn't true, so I don't see Carlin as funny. He's just ignorant and angry.
- arpa 11y agoI respectfully disagree. But that is just, like, my opinion, man.
- venomsnake 11y agoThe definition of miss implies that is was near. So to a point Carlin is right.
- glaberficken 11y agoWhat if one of the automated cars has to pick between swerving into another obstacle or keeping the collision course? (not even considering the moral implications of what that second obstacle might be...)
- sangnoir 11y agoClick-bait headline by Reuters (and Guardian). The Delphi spokesperson repudiated[1] the "near-miss" description. "I was there for the discussion with Reuters about automated vehicles," she told Ars by e-mail. "The story was taken completely out of context when describing a type of complex driving scenario that can occur in the real world. Our expert provided an example of a lane change scenario that our car recently experienced which, coincidentally, was with one of the Google cars also on the road at that time. It wasn’t a 'near miss' as described in the Reuters story." 1. http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/06/no-2-self-driving-cars-didnt-have-a-close-call-on-silicon-valley-streets/ http://arstechnica.com/cars/2015/06/no-2-self-driving-cars-d...
- jnevill 11y agoFurther, form that article: "Our car did exactly what it was supposed to," she wrote. "Our car saw the Google car move into the same lane as our car was planning to move into, but upon detecting that the lane was no longer open it decided to terminate the move and wait until it was clear again."