3 ms·
We have the same concept in Europe, or at least the country I'm from (Slovenia). You are mandated by law to put a percentage of your monthly income into pension
by Swizec 11y ago
We have the same concept in Europe, or at least the country I'm from (Slovenia). You are mandated by law to put a percentage of your monthly income into pension. If you miss a payment, you are in debt to the state and they will hunt you down for it. They take these things very seriously.
Everyone under 40-ish agrees that we are never going to see that money. We're essentially paying out of pocket for the current retirees and by the time we retire there will be nobody to pay our pension. Or at least there will not be enough somebodies.
- logicchains 11y ago>We're essentially paying out of pocket for the current retirees and by the time we retire there will be nobody to pay our pension. Australia's system is slightly different, in that the pension funds are privately owned and the government (currently) has no way to take money out of them or use it for anything else. People here'd be pretty pissed off if the government started dipping into their super.
- Swizec 11y agoTo be fair, I don't think our government is dipping into anything. They're just using the funds to pay out current pensions because there isn't enough money in the system. Why there isn't enough money in the system I don't know. There are likely to be multiple factors ranging from the fact that the country is just 25 years old, that there's been population decline or stagnation, or that those pension funds weren't growing enough. Hard to say.
- rodgerd 11y ago> Why there isn't enough money in the system I don't know. If it's anything like most countries, because the generation currently drawing a pension never paid in remotely enough in taxes to cover it.
- vetinari 11y agoThe sad thing is, that they probably paid enough, when considering purchase-power-parity over the decades. It is just the inflation that destroyed the savings. It does not matter, whether the government is running the fund or whether it is privately owned, the result will be the same.
- logicchains 11y ago>To be fair, I don't think our government is dipping into anything. They're just using the funds to pay out current pensions because there isn't enough money in the system. That's what I meant by dipping in: they're using the funds. In the Australian system each person's funds are in their own account and the government can't use it for anything else, nor can the super fund, so it's impossible for someone to be paid out of someone else's account.
- pjc50 11y agoOh, there are ways to get at the money via fiddling with tax status: http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/pensions/article-1692321/Has-Labour-really-ransacked-our-pensions.html http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/pensions/article-1692321/...
- rbehrends 11y ago> We're essentially paying out of pocket for the current retirees and by the time we retire there will be nobody to pay our pension. Or at least there will not be enough somebodies. This comes up again and again (not just in Slovenia, but in any country that has an inter-generational pension system). There are two points to make here: One is that as long as a country produces enough goods and services, money is "just" a tool for allocating these goods and services. How money is being saved and spent has already changed massively; countries have a different tax structure, require people to spend vastly more on health insurance than a century ago, families are smaller compared to a century ago and parents are less dependent on their children in old age (and thus the way our retirement works now is already vastly different from back then). There's little reason to think that the system cannot adapt. This is not to say that it "will" (because, well, predictions are hard, especially about the future), but it would also be unrealistic to assume that what we are going to have 30-50 years from now will be like what we have now. Heck, we don't even know if the "lump of labor fallacy" will still be a fallacy in a future of rising automation or whether part-time work will become the norm. At which point all bets are off, anyway. As a simple example, we could just implement a basic level of pensions through taxes (in lieu of existing pension schemes) that people could increase through private pension schemes. This is essentially basic income minus the moral hazard (because you don't have to worry about creating a disincentive to work for people outside the labor force). The second point is that investing privately in your retirement does not fundamentally change anything. When a society ages and has a disproportionate amount of young people, these young people still need to generate enough economic output, regardless of whether the income for those too old to contribute comes out of interest payments, an inter-generational scheme, taxes, or something else.
- crdoconnor 11y agoThis idea is usually promoted as a pretext for privatizing the public pension system. Ironically, that really will ensure that your pension gets raided. The idea is ridiculous of course. People are not going to stop existing when you retire, and judging by the last hundred years of progress, they'll be richer and more productive, if less numerous.