6 ms·
James Grant: Requiem for the Dollar
- mark_l_watson 17y agoIt seems to me that many (most?) people I know just can not cope with the truth about our economy, but there is some real nervousness. I have had friends who have lost over 50% of their retirement funds in the last two years - they tend to be more realists than other friends and family members who get (or will get) government pensions. The pensioners tend to have faith in the US and local governments that seems to me to be outside the bounds of clear thought and common sense. I may be over simplifying this, but I think that in addition to the obvious greed and avarice of the elites, that we have a basic problem with fear. Fear can keep a society from making sacrifices now rather than postponing the pain and making the future more difficult. I think that the next ten years will be interesting to live through (in negative and in positive ways) but facing problems head on seems like a better approach to what our leaders are doing now.
- trebor 17y agoI must say, the value of the dollar is depressing. Take a gander at this comparison I did of the Yen and Yuan compared to the dollar (btw, falling is a bad thing in this chart!)... > http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=CNY=X#chart3:symbol=cny=x;range=my;compare=jpy=x;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=CNY=X#chart3:symbol=cny=x... In my opinion as a US citizen, we need to enforce the currency law and enact the death sentence upon all who have perpetrated this upon our country and our fellow citizens. These persons have committed mass fraud, manipulated financial markets, and have almost irrevocably destroyed our prosperity. Off with their heads: we must make an example of them! It's high time we return to the gold/silver standard.
- jonknee 17y agoChina's got a lot more to lose with a strong Yuan that we do. They'll price themselves out of their entire manufacturing chain.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- gsaines 17y agoInteresting article, but not terribly useful or pragmatic. I was also hoping for a little more self-awareness. The author is essentially railing against the US policy of printing money to get out of crisis (which is a valid point) by advocating a solution that would send the entire world economy into a recession that would make this one look like the 2001 dip. Because it's the WSJ, I guess I should have expected at least some conservative rhetoric, but I found it a little too naive. What would have been a more interesting question to consider is what can be done to address the trade deficit and inflation problems with our current monetary system. Although it's valid to suggest that minimum viable product wouldn't work for macro and international economics, it has a lot less practical application.
- jakarta 17y agoI think the article serves as a call for urgency for the approaching inflation. One of Grant's biggest followers is Seth Klarman. Klarman runs the Baupost Group, which is a hedge fund comprised mostly of endowment fund money. His fund is using interest rate caps and swaptions to hedge inflation instead of using TIPS. I don't know if calling Grant naive is correct. He has been ahead of the curve on spotting bubbles in the past and runs a well reputed magazine ($850/year subscription)
- zaphar 17y agocan you back up your statement that his proposed solution would send the entire world into a recession? I always find it interesting that people say this and yet don't give any reasons why. I'm not financial genius myself but surely just collateralizing the dollar with something automatically cause a recession. What exactly is the mechanism you think would cause this? Asking cause i genuinely don't understand myself.
- jakarta 17y agoit comes down to your economic philosophy. a keynesian will say that if you need to stimulate the economy, government spending will help get us out of crises. the problem that arises with a collateralizing program, like the gold standard is that the monetary supply would be inherently confined by physical discoveries and captures of gold. If it is the Great Depression and you cannot find any more gold, you'd be pretty screwed.
- rg 17y agoA much deeper article by software entrepreneur "Mencius Moldbug": http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/12/gold-and-central-banks-game-theory.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/12/gold-an... "If gold will eventually be remonetized, gold is insanely cheap. If gold will never be remonetized, gold is insanely expensive. It's one or the other. Therefore, if you guess right about this question, you will make huge profits, and if you guess wrong take huge losses." "The reason I still expect gold remonetization to happen - in the long term, not tomorrow! - is that there's simply no other viable alternative. Everyone knows that the global economy needs a new currency. Most can see that the dollar cannot be saved or replaced by any other sovereign currency or basket thereof - because no central bank could tolerate the economic effects of the upward revaluation that would result if its currency replaced the dollar in C[entral] B[ank] portfolios"
- jordanb 17y agoGold isn't a viable reserve currency. The supply of gold is dictated by mining operations, not by the liquidity needs of the world economy. And there is a viable alternative reserve currency: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Drawing_Rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Drawing_Rights
- kingkongreveng_ 17y agoThe supply of gold is irrelevant as long as the above ground gold stores dwarf what is mined every year. A single ounce of gold is theoretically sufficient to run the entire economy. The value of that ounce would just shoot up as the economy grew more productive. What exactly do you mean by "liquidity needs"? If people need cash they earn it or save it. That cash is supposed to represent real wealth someone saved. If it's printed out of thin air it just represents a theft from people who have actually produced and saved.
- ubernostrum 17y agoThe value of that ounce would just shoot up as the economy grew more productive. Which is a coy way of saying "there would be massive, uncontrollable price swings". With a gold standard and modern economies you don't get wild inflation, but you do get wild deflation, with effects just as bad (since inflation and deflation are isomorphic to each other).
- billswift 17y agoOne thing I haven't seen mentioned recently, though some of the comments here reminded me of it, is the effect of fairly steady deflation, the kind enforced by a gold standard, on savings rates. Deflation boosts savings and depresses borrowing, because the value of the dollar will be higher in the future, so you are getting higher interest (ie, benefit more) from savings and losing more in interest (ie, paying more) on loans.