4 ms·
> women who are not actually technical (Adrianna Richards, Shanley, FemFreak for example) [citation needed]. If you're going to call them non-technical, we nee
by geofft 11y ago
> women who are not actually technical (Adrianna Richards, Shanley, FemFreak for example)
[citation needed]. If you're going to call them non-technical, we need to apply that same label to people like ESR, whose biggest contribution to the community -- like Shanley -- is writing/editing books about hacker/open-source culture. Both of them happen to write code, but it's not what they're famous for.
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoYou'd really call the guy who wrote this[1] non-technical? [1]: http://www.catb.org/~esr/software.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/software.html
- geofft 11y agoAnything in particular there? A lot of that is software that other people have written that he maintains, which is perfectly fine, but that's no more technical than running a one-person online and print media house. Much of the rest is small scripts that he's written and released, which again, is great, but everyone writes small scripts. If our standard for "non-technical" encompasses people like Adria (not Adrianna) and Shanley, I don't see how ESR avoids that. (To be clear, my own opinion is that we should call all of them "technical".) If you `git log --author='Eric S. Raymond' -p` on gpsd, you'll find that the majority of it is documentation, comments, style, etc. The code, by and large, is from other people.
- hoopd 11y agohttps://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/CREDITS https://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/CREDITS crtl-f "raymond"
- geofft 11y agoD: ncurses library co-maintainer D: terminfo master file maintainer D: Distributions HOWTO editor D: Instigator, FHS standard D: Keeper of the Jargon File and curator of the Retrocomputing Museum D: Author, Emacs VC and GUD modes Why is any of that in the kernel credits???? None of those things are in the kernel sources or even kernel-related projects. `git log --author='Eric S. Raymond'` turns up nothing. In any case, at least half of that is non-coding community-maintenance and prose editing work, which is great, but that's also what Shanley does.
- hoopd 11y agoI don't follow the kernel enough to know why things are the way they are. > `git log --author='Eric S. Raymond'` On which repo? The current one only goes back to 2005. ESR is common name, this is the first I've heard of Shanley. I'm really hoping you're not talking about the twitter personality. If you're putting that person and ESR on the same level I don't know what to say.
- geofft 11y agoI think none of them are deserving of the name "non-technical;" that's all I'm saying about them. Bill Gates, Hans Reiser, Jonathan Coulton, and Dread Pirate Roberts are all on the same "level". I would suggest, though, that you think about why ESR is such a common name to you. He's a genius at self-marketing, and he's managed to set himself up as the arbiter of hacker culture while mostly just writing things about other people's code. Shanley is also a genius at self-marketing: although her goals are very different, it's useful for her political goals for you to think of her the way you do. If all you think of either of them is their online personas, you're being played, and they're winning.
- hoopd 11y agoI'm having trouble telling if you're trolling or not, a musician and a convicted murderer are on the same level as Bill Gates? You dismiss ESR because he doesn't show up in git history that only goes back to 2005? I've never heard of Shanley until today and glancing through what she does it's inflammatory political theater. > it's useful for her political goals for you to think of her the way you do I dislike her because people who are that combative make me uncomfortable, not because I can't handle what she says. It's a shame people like her have degraded our culture to a point where having people dislike you is a sign that you're saying something worthwhile. Really, a recent post is: > i hate when people make shitty acoustic covers of pop songs just fucking stop you suck at guitar and singing That's just abusive. But if I don't like her it's a good thing? I'm at a loss, this is like junior high all over again. Like I said earlier, I can't tell if you're trolling or not.