3 ms·
Not to go all Michael Gove here does the NYT not have subs to correct grammar /meaning it should be "Are Actually Employees" Title as written implies something
by walshemj 11y ago
Not to go all Michael Gove here does the NYT not have subs to correct grammar /meaning it should be "Are Actually Employees"
Title as written implies something totally different - ie the its hard to recruit
- zem 11y agoi first read it as "hard to recruit" too, but it's grammatically correct, just ambiguous. i wonder if the ambiguity was actually deliberate on the headline writer's part.
- SilasX 11y agoIt's not just ambiguous, but wrong. For all X, the best X is is an X. To convey the meaning they want, the title should be "the best (workers|peformers) have employee status." As it stands, it reads like a statement of the fizzbuzz phenomenon: "the best employees are are already employed somewhere else [and not still looking]".
- a3n 11y agoThat's exactly what I thought it meant before I read the article.
- zem 11y agono, it's just a rhetorical device; read it as "the best employees are actually employed [rather than contracted]"
- SilasX 11y agoWell, the rhetorical device conveys the wrong thing, so it's not very good: - Being contracted is a way to be employed. - The contractor can still be an employee of the contracting agency - It can mean "employee vs out-of-work" [1] just as much as "employee vs contractor" To often, journalists fancy themselves novelists and sacrifice clarity for flourish. In this context, that's the wrong choice. [1] What I and the sibling thought.
- eli 11y agoIt's not a great title but changing it to "the best employees are actually employees" is worse