4 ms·
IIRC, despite the criticsim, the 'hockey stick' study and its author were proven right. Lots of criticism doesn't make it wrong, especially in politicized debat
by hackuser 11y ago
IIRC, despite the criticsim, the 'hockey stick' study and its author were proven right. Lots of criticism doesn't make it wrong, especially in politicized debates.
- triangleman 11y agoHow do you mean? Did you read the paper I linked to? In what way were Mann et al. "proven" right?
- janlin1999 11y agoIf read in isolation, the paper seems pretty convincing that something is amiss. However, it looks like some other scientists have generally confirmed the findings from Mann et al.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy#Further_reconstructions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_controversy#Furth... I haven't read those other papers.