5 ms·
Users Betrayed as Australia Adopts a Copyright Censorship Regime
- PebblesHD 11y agoYet again, and of course as usual, the government of Australia demonstrating how much they value their citizens by totally ignoring them in favour of big business. Good job Tony.
- PebblesHD 11y agoAlso, of interest: http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/computers/gadgets-on-the-go/porn-will-be-next-on-australias-websiteblocking-agenda-20150624-ghw60w.html http://www.smh.com.au/digital-life/computers/gadgets-on-the-... In moves surprising nobody, leaders and party figures have already suggested using these new laws as a stepping stone to blocking other objectionable content such as pornography and who knows what else.
- crdb 11y agoWhilst I agree with your sentiment as a legal permanent resident of Australia, I think it is dangerous (if very seductive) to blame Mr Abbott. He's been the party attack dog for so long that people focus their energy on making it personal with him (much as the Democrats focus on Bush and the Republicans have a thing for Obama). First, from the little I've been tracking this issue, it appears it was the "relatively moderate", friendly, centrist, old guard Turnbull that was behind these moves. Chances are it's done as a favour to someone in Washington who needed something from someone connected to the Hollywood lobbies. Not the strongest of motives and the kind of thing that popular opinion can reverse. Second, legislation doesn't magically happen in a vaccuum when the PM says so. Australians, you MUST get in touch with your local politician, both to let them know (politely) how you feel about certain issues, and to give them arguments to use in Canberra if you want any chance of legislation being passed the way you like it. It's not about Labour vs Liberals. Whoever has been locally elected, is now responsible for listening to you. They also don't do much thinking so it helps to do it for them: "This proposed legislation infringes individual rights like this, this and this; moreover, as per the Constitution, that" goes much further than "I am pissed at you for letting the PM get away with it". This is of course not a personal response to your comment, but a general note that I thought about and that was triggered by your Tony note. I've found Australians relatively politically disengaged, with the general opinion - at least in Sydney - basically being "they're all scumbags anyway, things will work out in the end", followed by some expletives about Gillard, Rudd or Abbott depending on where the Australian leans...
- tacticus 11y agoTurnbull is certainly not centrist nor friendly.
- programmernews3 11y agoTurnbull is a hoop snake in drop bear clothing.
- PebblesHD 11y agoA very good point, and well written. My only observation is this: politics doesn't happen in a vacuum, but the current government has set about ignoring polls and comments from the public on a range of other issues making me less inclined to believe they will shift for this one. That being said Labor isn't innocent of this either. My local member has on several occasions refused to even answer calls or meet me to discuss this, based only on the fact that as a young adult my opinion must not be valid.
- crdb 11y agoThat's pragmatic, he/she made the calculation that you have little political weight. Chances are there are people who contributed to his/her campaign or who are members of the community with more pull, and that you and your family aren't part of that group, and current members of that group disagree with you on the topics you brought up to your member. Or maybe he just did the maths and decided that an hour's meeting would have a higher return on investment with someone else. There's no easy solution: either you earn influence and use it to further your agenda (a la George Soros), or you try and build influence in some other way, such as publishing reasoned arguments in an easily shareable format, which is what the EFF is very good at. It's never been easier to have some impact.
- prawn 11y agoThere have been a number of web campaigns* initiated in Australia that have gained some traction. As you suggested, that's the best bet for the average person with technical skills and a way to get a concept to resonate with people. * This is one example: http://howfastisthenbn.com.au/ http://howfastisthenbn.com.au/
- imron 11y agoUnfortunately, this wasn't just Tony's fault. Labor backed the bill also. sigh why is it only the Greens and Independents who are willing to stand up for what's right.
- vacri 11y agoThe greens aren't really interested in this issue; it just panders to their inner-city elite demographic. Also, I wouldn't clump the independents together - the PUP or the DLP aren't usually up for what's right.
- prawn 11y agoScott Ludlam is always genuinely interested in issues like this. Renai LeMay shut down Delimiter to join his staff, showing Ludlam values our sector IMO.
- vacri 11y agoLudlam is (I saw him panel at a sec conf once), but the Greens in general don't. It's not a very important plank to them - check out their site, and you can find it hidden away somewhere in one corner, behind everything else.
- Joakal 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_australia#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_austral... Look at the history, collectively, it got Labor/Liberal support from Federal and State governments as far back as 1995.
- Jedd 11y agoConveniently there are no laws (currently) that compel people to support or vote only for either of the two big parties. A subtle point that seems to be lost on most of my fellow citizens. Mind, it seems to be a regrettably common misconception elsewhere in the world too.
- Joakal 11y ago"The Coalition has never supported mandatory internet filtering. Indeed, we have a long record of opposing it," the statement said. "The policy which was issued today was poorly worded and incorrectly indicated that the Coalition supported an 'opt-out' system of internet filtering for both mobile and fixed-line services. That is not our policy and never has been. "The correct position is that the Coalition will encourage mobile phone and internet service providers to make available software which parents can choose to install on their own devices to protect their children from inappropriate material." http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-says-turnbull/4939156 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-say... That's a second backflip. But I think it is a complete 360 turn.
- robbiep 11y ago... So they're back where they started?
- empressplay 11y agoApparently the ISPs are just going to use DNS poisoning, which anyone will be able to circumvent by using an overseas public DNS server, like Google's 8.8.8.8
- programmernews3 11y agoOr run a private DNS server on their laptop.
- supercoder 11y agoUnless Google is liable for 'facilitating' piracy with their DNS server and have to block it for Australians.
- mkj 11y ago8.8.8.8 is 54ms away, must be in Australia
- prawn 11y agoI get the impression that most ISPs are not really interested in disrupting personal piracy habits if that's what their customers want.
- toothbrush 11y agoThat's not really the point though. The fact that a minority of tech-savvy users will be able to get around it doesn't change the fact that it's a very effective measure against Joe Sixpack and his family having unfettered access to information. More generally, this is why i'm very sceptical of technical solutions to political problems. Years from now, you might find yourself along with your technically proficient minority of friends being the only people able to still access the Internet freely—most of it might have already become a corporate-controlled walled garden. I for one don't want to have to end up living in digital almost-exile just because we were too lazy to Do Something™ now, when there is still hope. I admit that this is at once probably rather tinfoil-hatty but also almost reality (how many people would be able to find whatever they're looking for if something like Google Search were blocked? 5%? Never mind if DNS poisoning was added to that). We on HN would be fine, but this would seriously impede democracy, given how the other 95% would be stuck without access to information.
- 5id 11y agoIt's sad to think that with these laws being passed, regardless of what position you take, that we still don't have any Fair Use provisions in Australia. There was even a discussion paper [http://www.alrc.gov.au/publications/4-case-fair-use-australia/summary http://www.alrc.gov.au/publications/4-case-fair-use-australi...] put forward by our Law Reform Commission suggesting this. I would have though the productivity benefits associated with education and innovation alone would make this a no brainer
- PebblesHD 11y agoI believe one of the only amendments to this bill that got through was a requirement that Tony Abbott provide a formal response to that paper.
- tux1968 11y agoDon't really think people from any other county should be looking down on Australia. This is the progression in every country, just at varying degrees currently. People will look back on the first few decades of the Internet as the wild-west era. Kids will be born knowing nothing but draconian rules and enforcement for the Internet. And the powerful elite will once again have squelched anything that challenges their dominance. Business as usual.
- fapjacks 11y agoI truly believe it is a core duty of technical people to subvert this control mechanism in whatever way we can. For example by inventing and writing freeing software like Tor, FreeNet, encryption, et cetera, and educating nontechnical voters, and calling and writing our elected officials.
- vacri 11y agoIt's also worth noting that this kind of legislation flows from the US entertainment industry. The US leans heavily on Australia to toughen up IP laws, and there really is no grassroots movement here that's interested in them. Some would say that Murdoch is involved as well, but we do get infected with US law via treaties.
- SturgeonsLaw 11y agoI'm glad there are others in the information war who don't share that defeatist attitude. SOPA and PIPA were defeated and the exposure of the NSA phone metadata program has spurred an unprecedented movement to encrypt the web. The fight isn't over by any means.
- belorn 11y agoA big problem I have with every law like this is how inherently inconstant and big business favored its enforcement is. Say for example that you are a content developer and finds that illegal copies are sold on ebay. You ask them to take down one seller only to find new ones every day, and thus you go to the police and ask them to block ebay. I doubt the person will ever get a day in court. There could be thousands of illegal copies listed each day and yet the political nature of blocking laws means that enforcement is depended on who does the accusation and whom the accused is.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoOr, say a large game publisher pirates your content. Guess whose site will go down. Hint: not yours.
- paulhauggis 11y agoAt this point in our society, does this even matter? If you go against the status quo, you will be silenced by special interest groups and other users online for only expressing your opinion. They did it to themselves. When you create a system where anyone and everyone can be silenced for their opinions, this is the result. Bravo!