3 ms·
Very cool, they have outlasted my projections of how long they would be mysterious :-) As I've said before my bet is on water ice but the 5,000 meter "ant hill"
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Very cool, they have outlasted my projections of how long they would be mysterious :-) As I've said before my bet is on water ice but the 5,000 meter "ant hill" is pretty impressive too. I suppose that Ceres is an ice ball with a dusty covering you might be able to generate a water volcano with the right conditions, still that is a lot of material to move around.
On commentator suggested that it could also be crystalline diamond, although how a crystal would cool slowly enough to grow large enough to be visible at this distance beggars the imagination. I consider that a long shot of the longest kind.
But people who object to the ice theory accurately point out that water ice would generally sublimate when exposed to vacuum in the presence of nearly any energy at all. Much like it does on Mars as shown in Opportunity's tire tracks.
Crystallized ice in hard vacuum exposed to sunlight seems an improbable thing. A shiny chunk of Nickel though ...
- tgflynn 11y agoWhat about large quantities of quartz crystals ? That would seem much more probable than diamond and wouldn't have the sublimation problem of water ice in a vacuum.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoCertainly possible, except that quartz crystals grow in hot watery solutions, and those are equally hard to come by in space. It would be interesting to stack up the set of conditions that would need to be true for them to form, perhaps a watery core undergoing tidal heating while silica dust is deposited on the surface and transported by meteor impact into the internals of the asteroid. A lot of steps though. For what its worth its also why the metals idea are statistically unlikely, as the distillation out of various metals would be hard to explain. That also makes the puzzle exciting though, the harder it is to guess what it is, the more interesting the answer in my experience.