3 ms·
> They argue that TPP itself doesn't. So who cares if it doesn't de jure, if it has a very major potential to do it de facto. It's all about the risk and impac
by shmerl 11y ago
> They argue that TPP itself doesn't.
So who cares if it doesn't de jure, if it has a very major potential to do it de facto. It's all about the risk and impact, not about what it formally declares.
It's like saying, hey, we have a label that it's safe. Don't mind if it actually injures anyone.
- tptacek 11y agoNo, I wasn't making a "de facto" vs "de jure" argument. I was saying that it does not appear that there is any provision of the TPP that will change US laws. As I've said repeatedly in this thread: the point of the IPR provisions in TPP are to export US law to other countries. The TPP does not appear to involve us importing anyone else's law. It's perfectly reasonable to be opposed to exporting our laws to other countries. But that's not what you said: you said you were concerned that the TPP will change US law, which is why you cited that weird Techdirt article, why you brought up the DMCA, and why you're trying to distinguish between "de facto" and "de jure" changes.
- shmerl 11y ago> I was saying that it does not appear that there is any provision of the TPP that will change US laws. Aren't there SOPA like provisions in TPP? SOPA was rejected in US. Now if TPP is passed, its supporters can backport SOPA in US law claiming it's an "international obligation" and the law "has to be harmonized". Why is it unlikely? That's exactly what happened with DMCA in the past. It was imported after being initially rejected, under pretense that it's an "international obligation".
- tptacek 11y agoNo, as far as we know, it does not. That's confusion that FFTF caused when it wrote an advocacy piece based on a 2-year-old version of TPP that is no longer current and is not supported by the recent "leaked" version of TPP.
- shmerl 11y ago> 2-year-old version of TPP that is no longer current. But since it's secret, you can't claim it changed either. So leaked version is a good base for sinking the whole thing into oblivion. And it only highlights the point that it's necessary for such things to be transparent to begin with. Next time they'll keep it open if they don't want opposition based on invalid assumptions.
- tptacek 11y agoYou've misread me again. The recent leaked version does not contain SOPA-like provisions. There is no evidence that TPP is SOPA-like, and there is strong evidence to the contrary.
- shmerl 11y agoDo we get those leaks on the constant basis? How can you guarantee anything in it next day after the leak? That just highlights what I said above. You can't trust such agreement to be for the benefit of the public, because they already contained something obviously against it. So it has to be completely dropped until there can be trust, which is only possible with transparent negotiations.