3 ms·
There is almost no connection between the CRA and the financial crisis. The crisis was caused by bad loans that were privately securitized and sold as highly-ra
by snowwrestler 11y ago
There is almost no connection between the CRA and the financial crisis. The crisis was caused by bad loans that were privately securitized and sold as highly-rated securities. The bulk of that work was done by investment banks, which were not subject to the CRA. And the bulk of CRA loans were not securitized.
Securitization and rating was the heart of the crisis. Mortgages fail all the time, and banks know how to deal with that. Failing mortgages are not enough to cause a financial crisis.
Investment banks realized that they could package low-quality mortgages into securities, and the securities would be highly rated because of tranching. This created a race to create as many mortgages as possible, in order to reap the profits from the securities sales.
It was this race for mortgages that then drove down underwriting standards among private originators--not the CRA.
The structure was strongly pro-cyclical, because when mortgages started failing, they ate away at both revenue and capital simultaneously. Falling revenue is ok if there is enough capital to cover it. But since the capital was made up of the same bad loans (now packaged as securities), the safety net frayed just as fast as the tightrope did. Result: crisis.
Also: a defining characteristic of "black swans" is that people assert after the fact that they were actually predictable (as you are now).