3 ms·
In some cases I think they've gone back up since the downvote crew rolled through. In some cases I've deleted things too. A lot of times as I said, I'll get up
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
In some cases I think they've gone back up since the downvote crew rolled through. In some cases I've deleted things too. A lot of times as I said, I'll get up several votes, and then be pushed down to 0 or negatives, and then perhaps end up back at 1 in time.
(On a discussion about Google, I managed to end up +30 karma for my comments there, then back down to where I was, then back up a bit, before getting -50'd and threatened by a moderator. Anything touching Google is a particularly sensitive topic to the folks who use downvote heavily, I imagine there's quite a few Google employees who participate here.)
I disagree that the comment you linked was off-topic. It was an issue with the link provided, and a discussion of possible solutions that followed it.
- DanBC 11y agoMeta comments about site design are off topic unless the design is what's being shown. And then the comment should be constructive. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9238739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9238739 I'm not sure I understand the rest of your post. Some people upvote your comments; some people downvote your comments. What's the problem? The general trend is up, right?
- dang 11y ago> threatened by a moderator Where did we do that?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoSorry, dang, I wanted to clarify this here, as my word choice was poor. I was not 'threatened' in a reasonable definition of the word. dang responded to me in a thread about Google (linked in this thread) regarding 'personal attacks', when I was responding to a troll. His comment appeared only addressed to me, however, and I felt that in the context of the discussion, it was targeted and unfair. I also simultaneously dropped 50 karma, and got heavily rate-limited, and I felt particularly unwelcomed. I've conversed briefly with dang over email, I wanted to clarify it here, and thank him for letting me respond here.
- dwwoelfel 11y agoAre comments usually heavily downvoted after you caution the commenter? Maybe you could set a lower limit on those comments. Getting downvoted to -50 seems excessive.