4 ms·
Whether it's the only reason to make it secret or not is not really the point. As long as secrecy allows circumventing the democratic process and create laws th
by shmerl 11y ago
Whether it's the only reason to make it secret or not is not really the point. As long as secrecy allows circumventing the democratic process and create laws through a backdoor it shouldn't be allowed. If you paid attention, these agreements aren't about trade. They are about promoting interests of some businesses through legislative means. Companies can gain or lose, but so is the public. Therefore there is no reason to give companies some preferential treatment here.
- tptacek 11y agoReasonable people also debate whether what's happening here "circumvents the democratic process", since the point of the secret negotiation is to generate a proposal that, in the US at least, requires Congressional authorization. Personally: I think the reason people resort to "undemocratic" and "backdoor" rhetoric is because they realize that once the treaty is put to a "it's this treaty or no treaty" vote, it will inevitably pass. The people who want a more "open" process really want more hooks earlier in the process to hold the whole treaty hostage to their interests. They can do that early in the process because the stakes are very low ("accede to our demands or the negotiation will be delayed"). They can't do that once the treaty is finalized ("accede to our demands or there will be no free trade agreement"). That's not a value judgement. Many of those interests are extremely worthy. But they should be argued on their merits, and not through a misleading appeal to democratic process. Democratic process sometimes seems like what many of TPP's opponents seem to be afraid of. (ducking) (I have no idea if I personally support TPP. I'm a LeVeyan liberal Democrat; "Do What's Best For The Public School System Shalt Be The Whole Of The Law".)
- shmerl 11y ago>I think the reason people resort to "undemocratic" and "backdoor" rhetoric is because they realize that once the treaty is put to a "it's this treaty or no treaty" vote, it will inevitably pass. That's exactly what undemocratic means here. I.e. democratic process reduced to rubberstamping farce. > The people who want a more "open" process really want more hooks earlier in the process to hold the whole treaty hostage to their interests. People want laws to have democratic oversight instead of rubberstamping of shady deals. Saying that there is some formal approval is completely irrelevant when you admit that it can't change anything. > That's not a value judgement. Many of those interests are extremely worthy. But they should be argued on their merits That would be an argument of democracy vs plutocracy.
- tptacek 11y agoYou're using emotional words like "rubber-stamping" and "farcical" to describe the same phenomenon I just did. You're confirming my comment: the appeal to "rubber-stamping" is really just the concession that, put to a Congressional vote, people who oppose some provisions of the TPP would still rather have a flawed TPP than no TPP. One way you can see that's the case: the same rubber-stamping Congress would have been rubber-stamping away had the negotiations been completely open.
- shmerl 11y ago> You're using emotional words like "rubber-stamping" I'm just rephrasing what you said yourself: > they realize that once the treaty is put to a "it's this treaty or no treaty" vote, it will inevitably pass. That's rubberstamping. If you don't like the term, call it a fake democratic process. > One way you can see that's the case: the same rubber-stamping Congress would have been rubber-stamping away had the negotiations been completely open. No, because the amount of public input is significant here. Reducing it is exactly the goal of backroom deals. It's explained here pretty well: http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/ http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/
- tptacek 11y agoDespite the domain name, that comic was not written by an economist; it's a political polemic that repeatedly argues that any argument by an economist must be suspicious (which apart from being false is also incredibly lazy, since there are plenty of economists to source for arguments against TPP). It's also hard to comprehend: * It has an extended segment about the trade deficit between the US and China and its impact on the valuation of the Yuan, despite the fact that China is not a party to the TPP. * It argues that TPP will enable the US to outsource jobs to Asia, but the US already can outsource jobs to Asia, and for the most part has outsourced every job that's economical to outsource. * Something about how the finance industry is a sentient evil robot, and now, to understand how that applies to the TPP, let's replace the robot with a country... let's say China. If this is where you're getting your information on TPP, it's no wonder you're emotional about it. Try Dean Baker at CEPR. Don't worry: he also fiercely opposes TPP.