5 ms·
Is Gravity Time’s Archer?
- SapphireSun 11y agoIs there a physicist here that can provide a better description of what's going on? How can you have shape "dynamics" without time evolution?
- russdill 11y agoI'm really not that well versed, but disorder and complexity seem to be used interchangeably which is incorrect: "According to this fundamental law, entropy - and with it disorder - should always increase with time. This is manifestly not happening in the universe" I'm completely baffled that they'd put that in their abstract or what they could possibly be thinking. In what way is entropy and disorder not increasing? And I think here is where they are confusing disorder and complexity. For a given system, as entropy initially increases, so does complexity, and then at some point, complexity peaks and falls. A system with very low entropy is not complex. It is very easy to describe. Additionally, a system with really high entropy is also not complex, it is also very easy to describe. http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=762 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=762
- z-cam 11y agoBoth Becker and Aaronson arrive at an interesting puzzle > So the real question is not why the entropy is increasing, but why it was ever low to begin with With regards to SapphireSun's question I am not a physicist either, but this seems to be a good place to start down the shape dynamics rabbit hole: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwqkdvKHTlg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwqkdvKHTlg
- mromanuk 11y ago> Imagine that you could see your life in rewind: You would slide into bed each morning with the ring of your alarm clock. At bedtime, you would gently drift awake. In the evening, you would un-cook your dinner, transforming a plate of Tuesday spaghetti into raw noodles and cold water. Your morning coffee would spontaneously warm in its mug as it sat on the countertop, the steam drawing out of the air and back into your cup. Another day begins, and you’re younger than the day before. Needless to say, this never happens in our universe. Thank you.
- Udo 11y agoThe problem with this view is causality. Since things happening as a result of other things is pretty much the definition of "time moving forward", there is no reasonable definition of time moving backwards that still includes causality. In other words, the "backwards" world he described is exactly the world we live in, since there would be no measurable way to tell the difference. A world where you're getting younger but can only remember the things that happened in the future is pretty much the same as a world where you're getting older but can only remember things that happened in the past.
- meatysnapper 11y agoWe can now enjoy hangovers, because we know it guarantees that a tremendously good evening will ensue!
- cshimmin 11y ago> things happening as a result of other things is pretty much the definition of "time moving forward" No, that's the definition of causality. Just because you are used to thinking of casual relationships in the context of forward-moving time, doesn't mean that time's arrow has anything to do with it. That's kind of a meta correlation/causation argument. In physics causality is more appropriately defined in terms of the propagation of forces/information. E.g. if you are farther than a distance c*t away from me, we cannot be causally connected because no signal moving at the speed of light could propagate (either forwards, or backwards in time) to connect our worldlines.
- Udo 11y ago> No, that's the definition of causality. [...] That's kind of a meta correlation/causation argument. It's more than that. The only way for us to actually tell which way the arrow of time points is by watching causal events. > In physics causality is more appropriately defined in terms of the propagation of forces/information. But that's exactly my point, I'm not sure where the miscommunication happened there. I object to the time-flowing-backwards statement in the article, because anyone who suggests a scenario where you're getting younger while being aware of it has left scientific reality behind. Moving on beyond the article: You can theoretically assert that the propagation of information could just as well happen backwards, but in the real world this becomes just exceedingly unlikely after just a couple of interactions following an event. So yes, this process has everything to do with the direction and the nature of time. Causality is not just another thing that mysteriously happens in one certain direction, it's a process that by its very nature can only happen in one direction. I have a feeling you're going to object to this, but in my opinion an information theoretical view of time is just as valid - if not more so - than to hang it on the direction of gravity. It's a construct that helps illustrate why time flowing backwards can never be a perceptible/measurable thing.
- snowwrestler 11y agoFrom this article: > In this view, gravity drives complexity, and complexity draws the bow on the arrow of time. Or, does complexity cause gravity? http://www.technologyreview.com/view/418192/gravity-emerges-from-quantum-information-say-physicists/ http://www.technologyreview.com/view/418192/gravity-emerges-... > One of the hottest new ideas in physics is that gravity is an emergent phenomena; that it somehow arises from the complex interaction of simpler things.
- trhway 11y agowell, giving that gravity, Lagrangian "minimum action", Schrodinger, etc... all basically describe the evolution of a system exactly along the local gradient of entropy increase one can say that all those are just emergent phenomena :)
- dpflan 11y agoThe article title reminded me of some Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes, so for fun: 1. Time's Arrow: Part 1 - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708828/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708828/ 2. Time's Arrow: Part 2 - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708829/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708829/
- Strilanc 11y ago> But there is a problem with identifying entropy as the driving force behind the arrow of time. For this to be true, the universe must have started out in a very low entropy state. The puzzle is: why? It's interesting that simplicity is the goal everywhere else in science, but it's bad when it comes to the initial state of the universe. After all, having a lot of neg-entropy is just another way of saying "takes very little information to describe". The fact that the initial state is surprisingly simple to us is oxymoronic in a way.