3 ms·
Of course yes, it gives distinction between the good or bad comments. But also its has controversial existence and this is a dilemma we can't answer unless th
by iknewit 11y ago
Of course yes, it gives distinction between the good or bad comments.
But also its has controversial existence
and this is a dilemma we can't answer
unless there is voting system on HN policy
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIf that's what it was used for, I would have less of an issue, but often it really just seems to filter popular/unpopular views. Creating an echo chamber, where only the views shared by moderators and high karma users are allowed to exist.
- sjs382 11y agoCan you show us examples of this echo chamber in action? In my experience, low-quality posts and comments get downvoted, high- (or even okay-) quality posts and comments get upvoted. Also, why is there all of this focus on votes? Don't get worked up over magic internet points that people give/take without a second thought.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoMy particular issue with extreme downvoting, is it seems (at least from my observation) to be tied to rate-limiting your ability to comment on posts. I was unable to comment on this thread, for example, for a fairly decent period of time. The other contention is that it sucks to be downvoted (a system I dislike in general) while being unable to downvote comments you believe are low quality yourself. The actual magic internet points, as you say, aren't really a big deal.
- DanBC 11y agoYou call it an echo chamber, but there are plenty of people with different opinions with high karma. HN is diverse enough to provide corrective upvotes - which is something you've described.