6 ms·
Ask HN: Is the downvoting feature valuable?
I've been a casual browser of HN for a few months now, and while I tend to find value in some of the stories (I particularly like browsing Show HNs), I find the community rather toxic. I've sworn off commenting here a couple of times, because of the behavior here, and then returned to it because I felt I could contribute a thought or two of value.
If your view is unpopular, even if well-stated, it will be downvoted into oblivion. Often, a post of mine will actually get 3-4 upvotes, before a certain crowd roves through hours later and sends it to -4.
One of the "50 Lies Programmers Believe"[1], featured on HN a bit ago, is that "The tech industry is a meritocracy."
It's not, but unfortunately, HN's downvote feature is extremely restrictive, only users with a high karma score get access to it, meaning it tends to be a way for popular users with popular views to suppress uncommon views. I suppose if this was only used to mitigate spam, marketing, foul behavior, and more, this would be okay, but it's often used to simply express disagreement.
Social networks like Facebook and Google+ have long understood that "Dislike" or "-1" buttons lead to an unpleasant experience, which is why most social networks tend to go without them.[2][3]
Hacker News, in fact, recently announced a ban on "gratuitous negativity"[4], yet the downvote is heavily used on a regular basis.
While I won't be surprised to see this downvoted or flagged, or labelled gratuitously negative in itself, I ask you to consider the value of the downvote button, and whether it deserves to exist. Or even, perhaps, if you should show more hesitation before the next time you push it.
[1] https://tommorris.org/posts/9317
[2] http://www.quora.com/Why-is-there-no-Dislike-button-on-Facebook
[3] http://thenextweb.com/socialmedia/2010/10/10/facebook-dislike-button-why-it-will-never-happen/
[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9317916
- brudgers 11y agoWriting better comments correlates with better comment scores. HN comnents appear before an audience who can vote. If the voting presentss a problem, blog your thoughts and submit a link, Otherwise treat downvotes as editorial feedback on the quality of your writing. Perhaps your point was not made clear, your reasoning was specious, or your audience was not taken adequately into your account. I find complaints about downvotes detrimental to HN.
- iknewit 11y agoOf course yes, it gives distinction between the good or bad comments. But also its has controversial existence and this is a dilemma we can't answer unless there is voting system on HN policy
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIf that's what it was used for, I would have less of an issue, but often it really just seems to filter popular/unpopular views. Creating an echo chamber, where only the views shared by moderators and high karma users are allowed to exist.
- sjs382 11y agoCan you show us examples of this echo chamber in action? In my experience, low-quality posts and comments get downvoted, high- (or even okay-) quality posts and comments get upvoted. Also, why is there all of this focus on votes? Don't get worked up over magic internet points that people give/take without a second thought.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoMy particular issue with extreme downvoting, is it seems (at least from my observation) to be tied to rate-limiting your ability to comment on posts. I was unable to comment on this thread, for example, for a fairly decent period of time. The other contention is that it sucks to be downvoted (a system I dislike in general) while being unable to downvote comments you believe are low quality yourself. The actual magic internet points, as you say, aren't really a big deal.
- DanBC 11y agoYou call it an echo chamber, but there are plenty of people with different opinions with high karma. HN is diverse enough to provide corrective upvotes - which is something you've described.
- minimaxir 11y agoEr, I checked your recent comment history and only found one comment from you which was downvoted (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9760439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9760439) which is the correct response since it's off topic. What other examples you have of unwarranted down voting?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIn some cases I think they've gone back up since the downvote crew rolled through. In some cases I've deleted things too. A lot of times as I said, I'll get up several votes, and then be pushed down to 0 or negatives, and then perhaps end up back at 1 in time. (On a discussion about Google, I managed to end up +30 karma for my comments there, then back down to where I was, then back up a bit, before getting -50'd and threatened by a moderator. Anything touching Google is a particularly sensitive topic to the folks who use downvote heavily, I imagine there's quite a few Google employees who participate here.) I disagree that the comment you linked was off-topic. It was an issue with the link provided, and a discussion of possible solutions that followed it.
- DanBC 11y agoMeta comments about site design are off topic unless the design is what's being shown. And then the comment should be constructive. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9238739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9238739 I'm not sure I understand the rest of your post. Some people upvote your comments; some people downvote your comments. What's the problem? The general trend is up, right?
- dang 11y ago> threatened by a moderator Where did we do that?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoSorry, dang, I wanted to clarify this here, as my word choice was poor. I was not 'threatened' in a reasonable definition of the word. dang responded to me in a thread about Google (linked in this thread) regarding 'personal attacks', when I was responding to a troll. His comment appeared only addressed to me, however, and I felt that in the context of the discussion, it was targeted and unfair. I also simultaneously dropped 50 karma, and got heavily rate-limited, and I felt particularly unwelcomed. I've conversed briefly with dang over email, I wanted to clarify it here, and thank him for letting me respond here.
- DanBC 11y agoSome people can downvote. Everyone with a logged in account can upvote. So your problem is not just that a few people downvote your posts, but that other people do not upvote your posts. To go from +4 to -4 is not normal. You have to try hard to craft a post that has that vote pattern. Have you considered just avoiding those types of threads? (Apple, Google, or MS threads have that kind of voting. Or if you say anything critical and also wrong about OpenBSD). Do you have any examples?
- krapp 11y agoUsing downvotes to express disagreement is, unfortunately, not against site policy. So what you observe is the system working as intended. It is valuable to users who want to preserve that system, and who believe there is a strong correlation between karma and content quality (which is an assumption baked into all such ranking systems, and fundamental to HN's own culture.)
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If your view is unpopular, even if well-stated, it will be downvoted into oblivion. This is not my observation; I have not seen well-stated posts making substantive contributions without excessive irrelevant meta-commentary (e.g., on downvotes when that's not the subject) or abuse frequently downvoted (except transiently -- a few early downvotes that are soon offset by upvotes isn't uncommon), regardless of popularity. I do often see well-stated points that are not relevant to the context in which they are offered downvoted, and that does seem likely to be somewhat influenced by popularity. But it seems a lot more that otherwise bad comments that happen to express a popular opinion sometimes avoid downvoting than that otherwise good comments that express an unpopular opinion tend to be downvoted.