3 ms·
Excuse me, but your dichotomy of two possibilities is facepalm-worthy. A few broad points: A) Consciousness, as in subjective experience, has very little to d
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
Excuse me, but your dichotomy of two possibilities is facepalm-worthy. A few broad points:
A) Consciousness, as in subjective experience, has very little to do with "artificial intelligence", in our current understanding. Only philosophers of mind continue to be obsessed with consciousness qua consciousness, as if a program needs qualia to drive an automated car or solve a math problem.
B) We will damn well understand human consciousness and cognition, in terms of neurally-implemented statistical learning mechanisms. This will just require that one or two more generations of cognitive scientists and philosophers of mind who refuse to believe in statistical learning retire. The best current literature in neuroscience and cognitive science is all computational and statistical in nature.
C) We will not build "AI products" based on a One True Theory of Cognition. We will find that human cognition works as a singular, highly effective example of general, broad principles. This is why we already have lots and lots of highly functional statistical learning and inference systems, albeit not ones that can be directed at a keystroke to perform any inference a human being can perform. Of course, this is also what makes them useful: by restricting their hypothesis space, and thus the problems they can solve, we vastly reduce their need for training data compared to a generally-intelligent human, and thus make otherwise difficult inference problems tractable.
D) Those who understand the principles of cognition will notice and understand perfectly well when near-human or human-level "artificial intelligence" (inference engines) is/are built.
>Wouldn't it be so perfectly human of us (as a society on the whole) to overlook the emergence of true AI while we ponder our navel?
You're already doing it.
>We have the capacity for rationality, but we're not 100% rational. That's what makes us human.
I demand a definition of humanity that doesn't define my entire species as crippled, and necessarily exclude all non-crippled life forms from humanity ;-).