5 ms·
It's nonsensical to compare to brick-and-mortar stores. We didn't go from brick-and-mortar to the App Store. We went from direct internet sales, where we got to
by mikeash 11y ago
It's nonsensical to compare to brick-and-mortar stores. We didn't go from brick-and-mortar to the App Store. We went from direct internet sales, where we got to build whatever we wanted, ship updates instantaneously, and keep 98% of the revenue, to the App Store.
- adambratt 11y agoYou're forgetting all the money that we had to spend on marketing.
- mikeash 11y agoThe marketing picture hasn't changed for 99.999% of developers. Unless you're fortunate to get featured by Apple, you still have to do all the work yourself.
- WorldWideWayne 11y agoSo nobody who has an app in an app store has to advertise anymore? I see advertisements for Wix all day long on Bloomberg TV, perhaps someone should tell them that they should have just put an app in Apple's store.
- tfinniga 11y agoOne nice advantage of the iOS ecosystem is that installing a new app is risk free. I have a relative that uses an iPad as their primary computing device. They install new apps all the time, as opposed to their laptop, which they are afraid that they will mess up. Apple made a new market, and is charging for access to it. I believe that you're still free to sell your apps on Android or jailbroken iOS devices, direct over the internet.
- yellowapple 11y ago> I believe that you're still free to sell your apps on Android or jailbroken iOS devices, direct over the internet. Trying to compare jailbroken iOS devices to the pre-iOS days is nonsensical. You're limiting your userbase to those with both the technical know-how and the motivation to continually re-jailbreak their devices as Apple fights tooth and nail to prevent said jailbreaking. Your argument re: jailbroken devices would be more relevant if iOS followed the Android model of "here's an app store, but you can check this box here if you're fine with the risks of installing things from outside of our app store". Until that happens, it's pure nonsense, as I'm sure you're already fully aware of.
- tfinniga 11y agoAs I said earlier, apple made a new market, and is charging for access to it. There is value in the marketplace they've created. They've collected a lot of users and given them an easy way to pay. Their market is expensive to maintain - their rules mean that applications are safe enough to install without thinking twice. There is essentially no iOS malware. It's somewhat like complaining about the right of console manufacturers to limit and profit from the software that runs on their platform. If you want different rules, use a different platform. Is it ridiculous to limit your potential userbase to android users, or users savvy enough to jailbreak devices? That is not apple's problem, that is your problem. One might wish for iOS policies to be different, but there is no intrinsic right for them to be different.
- mikeash 11y agoIt's really irritating to make a complaint about someone's behavior and get the inevitable response that "it's their right to do so." Yes, it is. So what? It's still crappy behavior and I can still complain about it. To paraphrase xkcd, this is almost the ultimate concession, where the best thing you can say about what they're doing is that it's not literally illegal.
- tfinniga 11y agoI think it's entirely reasonable behavior. It doesn't favor you as much as you might like. Why should you get to take advantage of their work for free? You don't get to ship other closed-ecosystem software for free, like console games.
- mikeash 11y agoI object to it as a user as much as I do as a developer. Historically, a third-party software ecosystem benefits everyone. Apple is trying to suppress that to the detriment of both their developers and their users, for their own gain. The comparison with game consoles is ridiculous. I mean, it's accurate, but why would you bring that up? It's not like I approve of how they do it either.