3 ms·
But you're one example in a sea of mobile users. The presentation was using real data and citing sources.
by prawn 11y ago
But you're one example in a sea of mobile users. The presentation was using real data and citing sources.
- graycat 11y agoBut the data and sources, as good as they were, and interesting, even astounding, didn't rationally support their claim that "Mobile changes everything". Moreover, their frequent comparisons with PCs flop: So far mobile just will not do much to replace PCs. The world has a lot of tacos, too, and they won't replace PCs either. Broadly mobile is mostly just a new product (collection of new products, new product category), does replace PCs for some relatively light work formerly done on PCs, has some new functionality and uses from being mobile, having GPS and a camera, etc., but, still, just does not yet replace PCs, and the data and sources do not so establish. For any good theory, need some examples, and I offered mine. Basically, for any really heavy PC user, mobile is not a replacement.
- prawn 11y agoBut mobile is changing everything. I don't have a fixed phone in my house, I use my mobile phone. I don't use one of the two expensive DSLRs in my house, I use my phone. In two months recently in the US, I never hailed a cab, but used an app to hail and track a car. I read books on my phone, I edit photos on my phone, I track site analytics and app sales on my phone, I play games on my phone, I navigate using maps on my phone, I record notes on my phone. I switched from a desktop to a laptop three machines and 10+ years ago. Never considered buying a desktop since. Modern mobile devices (Surface-style tablet/laptop hybrids) are very capable these days and not far away from the MBP I use. Once phone-form-factor devices are more powerful and we have virtual displays and a keyboard replacement, the needle will shift further. That level of capability will cover almost everyone who uses a computer for work. Don't get me wrong, I don't work on my phone. I feel cramped with less than three monitors. I like to spread out. But I also like to scrawl notes pencil on paper, and that doesn't mean that computers haven't taken over the offices of decades past. And there's no denying that the mobile form factor - a computer that you carry around with you easily - is dominating and will go further. Someone who doesn't have a use one will be a blip.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoMaybe all those are possible mobile; but just not very good. Edit a photo? For real? With one finger? Books one paragraph at a time? That's gotta be slow. Games - not immersive 3d ones, maybe dumb puzzle games or side-scrollers with a tiny part of the screen visible at one time. And navigation is very hard on a phone - turn-by-turn is the norm, which totally blows any global awareness and turns you into a cog. I can't see enough map on a phone to even begin to plan a route. I'm heavily biased - I can't exist without 2 large screens, mouse and keyboard for what I use a computer for. But from my point of view every attempt to use a mobile device ends in frustration and despair - they are so slow, such a tiny bandwidth for interaction, information comes in droplets. I'm unwilling to dumb myself down to their level.
- nekopa 11y ago> Edit a photo? For real? With one finger? Do you use 2 mice to edit your photos? Most computer graphics people I know edit photos with a pen (also a singular digit). The main thing I miss when editing photos on my laptop is the ability to reach out and touch it, and normally with 1, 2 or more fingers. The main problem is the damn iPad and its 'fat finger' syndrome, but I have a pen based 8 inch tablet that I wish had more capable photo editing software, because it turns editing photos into a dream (I am not a professional, and could never get the hang of digitizing pads, I like to see what I am editing directly under the pen)
- prawn 11y agoThis isn't about productive work for a narrow grouping of people but about life. For 99% of people (the huge growth in mobile the slides talked about), editing a photo is applying filters and tweaking some sliders. It's not Aperture and Lightroom or Photoshop. My Garmin has about the same screen size as my phone. I've used both successfully for navigation many, many times. Took a DSLR on a recent two-month trip and outside of Yellowstone (zoom lens...), I barely touched it. My phone takes excellent photos, takes slo-mo videos, auto-stitches panoramic photos instantly, has timelapse options, HDR apps. And it has more storage, built-in sharing/social options and it's far, far smaller.
- 11y ago