3 ms·
We're about five weeks from public launch. It should be close to finished. If they are planning on making big changes to the install process then it's a little
by andrewstuart 11y ago
We're about five weeks from public launch. It should be close to finished. If they are planning on making big changes to the install process then it's a little late to be doing that. It's not a good idea to have a very technical beta version and say at the last second "righto we're switching to something easy top use at the last second!".
- viraptor 11y agoWhy wouldn't they? This is one part which is not related to the system itself. If they're scheduling changes, then core system stuff definitely goes in before installers. Who knows, they may even have a better installer ready and just don't care enough to give it to early access - good way to filter out non-technical testers. Basically what I'm saying is - it's closed development with closed invisible schedule and unknown list of final features and changes. If you're an insider and think installer can be improved, report a bug. I believe the insider program exists exactly for that reason. Also, no "normal person" will install this from an ISO. People will get 10 either preinstalled or as an upgrade. The recovery disks will be more important for them.
- andrewstuart 11y agoI don't agree that a clean Windows installation is a process for experts and can therefore withstand being overly technical. If anything it should be the complete opposite - a clean install should be so incredibly smooth that the most basic of users can do it. I'm also not convinced that ordinary people will never do a clean Windows install - unless of course it's so damn hard that they can't. You also don't have me convinced that five weeks out from release that the very first step of the installation process should not be finalised - it should be. If anything this first point of user contact should almost be the first thing finalised when an operating system like Windows is developed. This is the point that my blog posts make - Microsoft just doesn't understand what matters, which in my opinion, is the user experience from step one. What the heck is being testing in a gigantic public beta test if not the users first point of contact with the OS?
- DrScump 11y ago"a clean install should be so incredibly smooth that the most basic of users can do it." That's ridiculous. A "clean" install (at least one intended for any end-user population) has a very complex path to traverse. First, it has to check for existing partitioning, O/S content and version, and the presence of any user data files so that the installing party has the option of 1) aborting the install, in case he wasn't aware of legacy content on the drive(s), and 2) whether to do an update-install (preserving user data files) or a destructive install. If this install is going on a bare, never-formatted drive, then I think that hardly applies to the "ordinary (non-computer-savvy) people" case... as I think such a user would be daunted by having to decide partitioning, boot record placement, reservations for recovery or other proprietary partitions, swap space, etc. Now, an intelligent install can give suggested configurations based on available space and scope of features being installed, as any good Linux distro does... but I think a total beginner will be given pause by the prompt to confirm that they are destroying all existing data... and rightfully so.