4 ms·
So is anyone building such a smartphone? And if not, why? My guess is that it would cost too much, without the commodification of our private information. Jus
by mirimir 11y ago
So is anyone building such a smartphone?
And if not, why?
My guess is that it would cost too much, without the commodification of our private information. Just like the web.
- jbigelow76 11y ago>My guess is that it would cost too much, without the commodification of our private information. Ask and ye shall receive. Uber, the darling of both the mobile world and the "sharing" economy is set to start tracking your every location so they can serve up fucking ads[1]. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jun/22/uber-ftc-privacy-customer-location-contacts http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jun/22/uber-ftc-p...
- bernardlunn 11y agoI will treasure my bicycle even more. I hear the birds singing, not some stupid jingle.
- mirimir 11y agoI predict that bicycles will join the IoT. It will be a feature. Like some bastard child of OnStar and medical alert systems ;)
- haxel 11y agoWhat if our information stayed private and we used our "supercomputers" to do all sorts of data-mining, or AI, or data-science on it? Same stuff the big guys are doing, but for ourselves. Smaller, higher quality datasets. If our smartphones worked like this, and we'd benefit more from better information, then we'd also have a pretty good reason to develop advanced information-centric UIs and focus a bit more on security and trust.
- mirimir 11y agoThat would be wonderful. But I doubt that providers would ever bundle them. So most people would consider them to be too expensive. And so they would die, like Blackberry has.
- haxel 11y agoSmartphones and security don't really go hand-in-hand anyway. However, I am encouraged by the fact that people paid many thousands of dollars in the '80's and 90's to purchase PC's. They were much harder to use, much less powerful, and yet because these PC's represented either a competitive advantage or a novelty, the price was paid. No Internet, but a heckuva lot more control and trust than now. If a similar value proposition pops up again, somehow de-commodifying or replacing the standard PC design (smartphone or otherwise), I suspect we'll see a similar willingness to pay a premium.
- AdieuToLogic 11y ago> So is anyone building such a smartphone? Perhaps a more appropriate question is not so much if anyone is building a smartphone (from a hardware definition) so much as is anyone building an operating system which runs on commonly available smartphone devices which does not employ these tactics? > And if not, why? I'm certain there are efforts in motion which seek to establish a viable choice for many smartphone owners in what their devices run. As to "the commodification of our private information", well, I have to ask: why accept this in the first place?
- mirimir 11y ago> Perhaps a more appropriate question is not so much if anyone is building a smartphone (from a hardware definition) ... The baseband is a huge security hole. The provider in large part owns the device, regardless of what software it's running. > ... so much as is anyone building an operating system which runs on commonly available smartphone devices which does not employ these tactics? I can live with Linux ;)
- bratch 11y agoYou may be interested in the Neo900 [1] project, which is building a trustworthy mobile phone and will support a variety of free software operating systems. It will be possible to run with completely FLOSS software (including drivers) and it even solves the problem of the baseband modem having full control over the main CPU/memory. [1] http://neo900.org/ http://neo900.org/
- mirimir 11y agoThanks! Now if they accepted Bitcoins ... But hey, I'll ask.
- AdieuToLogic 11y ago> The baseband is a huge security hole. The provider in large part owns the device, regardless of what software it's running. In the US at least, this is not the case: https://www.fcc.gov/device-unlocking-faq https://www.fcc.gov/device-unlocking-faq The cellular provider no more "owns the device" than the cable company "owns your TV." > I can live with Linux ;) But you are not living with Linux. You are living with Android ;-).
- Arnt 11y agohttps://wiki.debian.org/ChrootOnAndroid https://wiki.debian.org/ChrootOnAndroid may interest you.
- mirimir 11y agoThanks. I've seen that, and plan to test with an old Nexus.
- happyscrappy 11y agoThere is an expensive phone that isn't selling your private info as a commodity.
- minusSeven 11y agothis is one of main reasons I moved to blackberry from android.