5 ms·
I didn't call anything flawed, fundamentally or otherwise; but I take your point. I think that there is an important distinction between 'almost-there' solutio
by JadeNB 11y ago
I didn't call anything flawed, fundamentally or otherwise; but I take your point.
I think that there is an important distinction between 'almost-there' solutions.
Suppose that you have a piece of code that is specified to work in a certain way. Because code, and the hardware on which it runs, is made (at least indirectly) by humans, it will fail under some conditions; it only satisfies its specification. I think that we are all comfortable with this kind of "works most of the time".
By contrast, consider 'smart' products—for example, the auto-complete on your phone. This also, after a bit of training, works most of the time, and can make some brilliant inferences. However, I think that most people can agree that the "most of the time" for auto-completion is qualitatively different from the "most of the time" for specified software: it is reasonable to rely on the latter, but not, or at least not nearly as much, on the former (http://www.damnyouautocorrect.com http://www.damnyouautocorrect.com).
- Skinney 11y agoI know you didn't, but if you have a language have a core semantic that only works "most of time," and "most of the time" is worse than "never," then you have a language that is worse than not having a language at all, which means that it is fundamentally flawed. Yes, I probably did enjoy my logic courses at the university too much.
- JadeNB 11y agoOops, I an important word out: > Because code, and the hardware on which it runs, is made (at least indirectly) by humans, it will fail under some conditions; it only satisfies its specification. This sentence was supposed to end "it only satisfies its specification some of the time." I was not going for Knuth-ian irony about proving vs testing (https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Donald_Knuth#Sourced https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Donald_Knuth#Sourced).