3 ms·
This happens all the time. At reddit we would get requests from law enforcement asking for email addresses and other private information. Luckily in our case
by jedberg 11y ago
This happens all the time. At reddit we would get requests from law enforcement asking for email addresses and other private information. Luckily in our case we could simply reply that we didn't know, since we didn't require any personal information to sign up and didn't keep IP address logs that long.
But having been on the other side of the coin, investigating computer crime, I can tell you why it happens. It's really easy to make a request for information, and in most cases, the person you're asking will just willingly give it up even though they don't legally have to, either because they want to be helpful or because they don't know about their legal rights. Even if the evidence can't be used to build a case against the person in court, it can still be used to lead down a path towards finding the person and gathering evidence that is admissible.
- dimino 11y ago> Even if the evidence can't be used to build a case against the person in court, it can still be used to lead down a path towards finding the person and gathering evidence that is admissible. It makes sense to do this, but I can already hear the cries of parallel construction from my bunker 20 floors below sea level.
- mseebach 11y agoThat's great, but the government has 50 ways of fucking up your life (and that's just before breakfast) without getting anywhere near a court room.
- jellicle 11y agoWhy would it not be admissible?
- lisper 11y agoBecause it was acquired without probable cause or a warrant.
- slapshot 11y agoBut under the (still hotly contested in the Digital Age) "third party doctrine", information held by a service provider (an ISP, a website, a hotel, a cell phone company, etc) law enforcement can request data with just a subpoena. A court may issue the subpoena if the law enforcement agency shows that the information is "relevant to an investigation" and the recipient must comply or show why the data isn't available. There doesn't have to be probable cause. Anything found can be part of the investigation -- there's no parallel construction required. [1] Today (literally, today), the Supreme Court took a first shot at narrowing the third party doctrine with respect to hotel room records in Los Angeles. [2] The ruling was largely about the procedure a hotel may use to quash (ask a court to reject) the subpoena, but it shows a willingness to cut back on the third party doctrine. The GPS tracker case also had some commentary suggesting a limit to the third party doctrine, but it was ultimately decided based on the physical intrusion of the device. [1] Alternet's very negative take on the issue: http://www.alternet.org/8-ways-police-can-spy-you-without-warrant http://www.alternet.org/8-ways-police-can-spy-you-without-wa... [2] http://www.politico.com/story/2015/06/hotel-guest-list-privacy-supreme-court-ruling-119280.html http://www.politico.com/story/2015/06/hotel-guest-list-priva...
- _delirium 11y agoThe third-party doctrine "proper" is about third parties voluntarily giving information to the government, which the government would otherwise have needed a warrant to get. For example, the government could effectively conduct dragnet surveillance of cell-phone records without a warrant if a mobile-phone company chooses to enter into a commercial data-selling agreement with the government: for $x/record, we'll send you all the call data. This has historically been held to just be a voluntary transaction between parties, so doesn't implicate the 4th amendment. The hotel case you mentioned doesn't seem to involve that; in this case, the hotel is opposing the request, so there's an adversarial posture between the third-party data holder and the government over handing over the data.
- schoen 11y agoIt's true that in Smith v. Maryland "[t]he police did not get a warrant or court order before having the pen register installed", so the original case was a voluntary disclosure in that sense. But installing pen registers isn't voluntary at all these days: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen_register#Pen_Register_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen_register#Pen_Register_Act So it's reasonable to speak of the third party doctrine being applied to compelled data disclosures, not just voluntary ones.
- tptacek 11y agoHe wasn't saying it wouldn't be. He was saying that even in an abusive fishing expedition in which prosecutors believed that the evidence generated would be excluded by a semi-competent defense attorney, the prosecution still profits by generating information that helps the rest of the investigation. It was a point about game theory, not about law.
- themeek 11y agoCan you speak more about your experiences at Reddit, as much as you can? Was bulk information ever requested and what types of issues did it seem like requests came in for? Is other private information just IP addresses or is it passwords and other records (posting history/times/subscriptions) too?
- jedberg 11y agoI never saw a bulk request. Usually they were just asking for email address and IP address/access times. The types of issues were usually people who had "admitted" to a crime, and sometimes threats against the President.
- themeek 11y agoThank you. :)
- mason240 11y agoIf they did have bulk data requests from the US Federal government, would be even be allowed to say they have?
- timdorr 11y agoBut did you ever get an accompanying gag order to prevent you from talking about those requests?
- jedberg 11y agoNot that I'm aware of.
- dalke 11y agoThen it's not really something that 'happens all the time.' It's the gag order which is the primary issue here, not request for more details.
- GauntletWizard 11y agoThe results for more details was in and of itself a problem; The prosecutors were fishing for details on people whom were guilty only of hyperbole. "I would love to see you thrown off a roof" or "That prosecutor should be taken out and shot" are not threats, not even close. They are the very definition of political speech, in grandiose hyperbole. The chilling effects of prosecutors even asking for that information is very real, and very much undermines the cornerstones of american democracy. The gag order escalated it from prosecutorial overreach to something worthy of repeated headlines, but even the request was unwarranted and wrong.
- dalke 11y agoAgreed. But my comment was in regards to the lead comment "This happens all the time. At reddit we would get requests from law enforcement asking for email addresses and other private information. .." Those details have nothing to do with the issue at hand, and hence my objection to the comparison.
- RickHull 11y ago> Those details have nothing to do with the issue at hand, and hence my objection to the comparison. Huh? Reason.com got requests from law enforcement asking for email addresses and other private information. Reddit.com got requests from law enforcement asking for email addresses and other private information. Do you really not see the parallel, even if the Reason.com case is much more egregious for the fact of the gag order?
- arca_vorago 11y ago"didn't keep IP address logs that long" Keeping signup IP's forever and IP's for 90 days seems like a pretty long time to me.
- jedberg 11y agoAll of the requests came long after 90 days.
- arca_vorago 11y agoInteresting, that changes some of my thinking on the matter, I appreciate the response.
- ihuman 11y agoDo you respond with the user's email address if they have on associated with the account?