2 ms·
A major point is being missed here, and it is fundamental to how F1 cars evolve - rules lawyering. It's fairly easy to design a car that is safe, fast and look
by jdietrich 11y ago
A major point is being missed here, and it is fundamental to how F1 cars evolve - rules lawyering.
It's fairly easy to design a car that is safe, fast and looks good. It is fiendishly difficult to create a set of rules that enforce those outcomes on designers. Unless F1 becomes a one-design formula, it is always going to have to deal with the cat-and-mouse game between the governing body and creative designers.
The obvious recent example is that of the ugly noses of 2014[1]. The nose height of F1 cars had been gradually increasing over the years, as teams realised that there was an aerodynamic advantage in channelling air under the nose. The FIA became concerned about the safety of these noses, and the risk that in a side impact they might over-ride the cockpit and hit a driver in the helmet.
The rule introduced to address this issue stated that an area of the nose no less than 90cm² must be centred no higher than 185mm above the car floor. Designers immediately realised that this rule could be exploited by simply having a 90cm² protuberance hanging below the main nose, minimising the constriction of airflow. These droopy proboscises weren't anticipated or desired, but they were an inevitable consequence of a rule that wasn't absolutely watertight and the competitive pressures or racing.
The modern era of F1 is practically defined by these creative interpretations of the rules - F- and S-ducts, exhaust blown and double diffusers, blown starter holes, tuned mass dampers. No matter what rule the FIA draws up, some very smart people will figure out a way around it. Adrian Newey, the greatest designer in the history of the sport, is fond of saying that "there is no such thing as the spirit of the rules". To many, that buccaneering spirit is an integral part of Formula 1.
[1]http://www.sanantoniof1club.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/2014-F1-race-car-nose-review-proboscis-ugly.jpg http://www.sanantoniof1club.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/2...