3 ms·
> Jesus. That's borderline child abuse. These people understand their children can only go to one of those eight schools at a time, right? It's precisely the o
by bsder 11y ago
> Jesus. That's borderline child abuse. These people understand their children can only go to one of those eight schools at a time, right?
It's precisely the opposite. It's an acknowledgement that the Ivy League admissions process is completely broken, and it is a proper, rational response.
If I assume that my probability of admission is randomly 25% (probably not unreasonable), then I have a 10% probability of not being admitted to any of the 8 schools even if I am qualified.
As an admission process requires money and time, it's yet one more way that the poor are disadvantaged.
- ghaff 11y ago>admissions process is completely broken Broken implies "should be fixed." I'm not sure how you fix an inherently competitive admissions process whether it's getting into Harvard or getting a job offer from $HOT_TECH_CO. You're always going to have an element of randomness unless you purely/primarily go the testing route, e.g. the civil service examination system of imperial China. Which has its own set of problems. (BTW, to be clear, expectations that one must attend one of these schools or one's life is ruined are certainly misplaced. But given such expectations, I'm not sure what reasonable admissions system is going to do away with randomness. I think it's a good thing that admissions aren't purely based on SAT scores.)