8 ms·
Harvard-Stanford admissions hoax becomes international scandal
- Pilfer 11y agoThis scandal blew up because one of her classmates posted a lengthy rant about her lies on a /r/askreddit thread. The post was widely shared on Korean media and was eventually picked up in the states, as you can see from the original link. For closure, it appears school officials met with her and her parents and decided on expelling her. The classmate deleted the post shortly afterward, but you can read a copy of it below. [Archived Post] - https://archive.is/pYQeg https://archive.is/pYQeg [Original Post] - http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/395g6c/what_is_the_current_drama_going_on_with_your/cs0nm9t http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/395g6c/what_is_th... [Korean coverage, including forged admission letters] - http://english.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2015/06/12/2015061201525.html http://english.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2015/06/12/2015...
- TheGunner 11y agoI found the original post entirely depressing and sad. I could never imagine putting my own children through the level of stress that would cause them to do this. I am glad to read the fathers reaction in that last link "In a press release later on Friday morning, Sara's father, an executive at global online gaming company Nexon, apologized for causing a stir with the fabrication. "I'm responsible for all the mistakes and sorry not to have taken better care of this poor kid," he said. He promised to look after her better since she apparently suffered from extreme stress due to academic pressures. He allegedly had no idea that the story was false."
- argumentum 11y agoIt's often the kids who put themselves through this pressure. I can't speak for all families, but I went to a Whitney HS, a southern california version of TJ, and the peer pressure is quite a lot stronger than what most parents say or do. This isn't helped by an admissions process that seems to penalize Asian Americans due to their ethnicity.
- hatmatrix 11y agoFrom the development documented by her classmate, it seems like it started with a small lie about an extracurricular math activity that spiraled out of control when she tacked on one lie after another to convince others that she was accomplished. If people didn't call her out on the first lie and just ignored it, I wonder if she would have gone as far.
- beedogs 11y ago> “We celebrate the accomplishment of students who get into all eight Ivies,” said Brandon Kosatka, TJ’s director of student services. “That’s the bar, and our kids are shooting for that. They don’t like to be the second-best. If that’s the bar, then, yes, that creates anxiety for them.” Jesus. That's borderline child abuse. These people understand their children can only go to one of those eight schools at a time, right?
- andreyf 11y agoFunny - I came to the comments with this exact same quote in my clipboard. I don't think it's child abuse, though, as both the parents and children are part of this world view which uses socially accepted norms for success as their primary metrics of worth. It's an extreme form of absolute submission to external motivation. I think this comes from a culture of insecurity, addiction to simple success metrics, and maybe even a little intellectual laziness. Doing well in school isn't worthless, but it's perpendicular to learning to decide for yourself what your values are and in what direction you want to pull the world as you interact with it. At least in my experience, the latter is a lot more intellectually difficult (and satisfying) than learning a particular set of skills to solve a particular set of problems.
- bsder 11y ago> Jesus. That's borderline child abuse. These people understand their children can only go to one of those eight schools at a time, right? It's precisely the opposite. It's an acknowledgement that the Ivy League admissions process is completely broken, and it is a proper, rational response. If I assume that my probability of admission is randomly 25% (probably not unreasonable), then I have a 10% probability of not being admitted to any of the 8 schools even if I am qualified. As an admission process requires money and time, it's yet one more way that the poor are disadvantaged.
- ghaff 11y ago>admissions process is completely broken Broken implies "should be fixed." I'm not sure how you fix an inherently competitive admissions process whether it's getting into Harvard or getting a job offer from $HOT_TECH_CO. You're always going to have an element of randomness unless you purely/primarily go the testing route, e.g. the civil service examination system of imperial China. Which has its own set of problems. (BTW, to be clear, expectations that one must attend one of these schools or one's life is ruined are certainly misplaced. But given such expectations, I'm not sure what reasonable admissions system is going to do away with randomness. I think it's a good thing that admissions aren't purely based on SAT scores.)
- maaaats 11y agoUS university admission is so weird, I think. Where I'm from, the only thing that counts is your grades. No subjective letter, having to know important people for letter of recommendation, no need to force yourself to play an instrument, do charity work, play a sport etc. without actually wanting to do it. What are the pro's of doing it this way?
- dagw 11y agoI'm guessing it's because they feel that grades are a poor indicator as to how well you will do at University, so they're fishing around for better things to go by.
- ghaff 11y agoI haven't looked at recent studies, but actually (normalized) grades and standard test scores are a pretty good indication of academic performance in university. If that was your only metric, you'd probably lean pretty heavily on those indicators. However, elite schools are--for better or worse--aiming for a mix of student backgrounds, interests, and experiences on the theory that this creates a richer learning environment than one that's solely optimized for conventional academic prowess. It's probably also true to say that the Ivies and other top-flight, especially Eastern, liberal arts schools were historically more concerned with admitting "the right sort of people" than the most studious. So there never really was a history of an exclusively examination-based approach--though one can find Harvard admissions tests from the 1800s--e.g. http://www.businessinsider.com/harvard-entry-exam-2011-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/harvard-entry-exam-2011-7
- golergka 11y agoHow hard it is to cheat or bribe to get these good grades?
- nicolapede 11y agoHow hard is to cheat or bribe to get the other requirements, too (recommendation letter, charity, etc.)? I come from a country where grades are the main variable, so I'd like to have a view on how these additional requirements make the whole process more robust. Is it just for a quantitative reason (cheating on N > 1 requirements is more difficult than cheating on 1) or are they necessary to correctly identify good candidates?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danso 11y agoYou missed this paragraph: > That stress appeared to be too much for at least one young woman at TJ, who goes by her nickname, Sara. "Sara" is not her real name. That nickname, which helps the story from devolving into a mess of pronouns, is only decipherable to people at the school...and probably not even that, since there's likely to be more than one "Sara" there.
- aaron695 11y agoUnderage high School girl lies <==> international scandal. Seriously people. At best this is, stupid media gets fooled by a troubled girl at a time many teens are at a tough time in their lives. Classmates not as stupid.
- dagw 11y agoTechnically this is stupid media gets temporarily fooled by a troubled girl respected parents. The girl wasn't doing this on her own.
- ble 11y agoHah. I went to TJ and, at a gathering with a few other high school classmates, I bemoaned how unhealthy I thought the atmosphere was there. I'm not saying it was disastrous when we went there, but it was a divorced-from-reality, barely-visible-high-pressure environment. Going to a prestigious, competitive state school was seen by several of my classmates as "failing" because it wasn't as good as going to an Ivy or another high profile institution. An environment made up entirely of kids who are accustomed to being the smartest student in the class is going to produce some very unpleasant results under high pressure. I wonder how the counseling team approaches the problem.
- rayiner 11y agoWhen were you there? I attended from 1998-2002, and it was a pretty collegial place back then. Very little competitive pressure from the teachers or administration, no class ranking, etc. Lots of self-imposed consternation about getting into top colleges, but that usually didn't bubble up into the social interactions.
- hga 11y agoHmmm, this helps me better understand a former college who went to MIT, would have been class of '97, and before that decided not to attend TJ because he wanted a more normal high school experience. Struck me as strange at the time, but if TJ is this aberrant, much more than any of the other schools in its class you hear about like Stuyvesant and the other NYC high schools that puts lots of graduated into MIT.
- mrcactu5 11y agoGetting into all 8 Ivies -- what a shallow way to measure intelligence.
- walshemj 11y agoIts how they market them selves to parents
- chrisBob 11y agoThe article quotes a student complaining about the pressure for extracurricular activities, but I think this is a good case in favor of sports: Do you know a runner? They have experienced failure and lost races. This is an important lesson that a lot of kids seem to be missing, especially at these elite high schools. Furthermore, each Ivy will only accept so many students each year from TJ or Andover Academy, so a lot of high school students would be better off if they worked hard at a public school, especially one in an underrepresented area.
- walshemj 11y agoIn the uk there are reports of kids from public schools going to a good state 6th form for the last two years of school to help game the admissions process.
- option_greek 11y ago"Another senior, who designed the electronics system for a 6-foot, 120-pound robot capable of lifting crates" Would be very interested to see some video of this in action. Couldn't seem to find it any where.
- andars 11y agoThat would be this years FRC challenge. I'm sure there are videos of th competitions online.
- akhilcacharya 11y agoThese sorts of attitudes are so alien to me. At my high school it was impressive to get into UNC (we were in state)
- peter303 11y agoUpper class families in some Asian countries are fanatical about getting into the worlds best colleges. Anyone who has attended such a college would immediately recognize this story as a hoax. But there are some extreme things such families do that are not that far off from this.