6 ms·
Exposure isn't necessarily good for an app. Users frequently _cost_ money. Ask anyone who has significantly scaled freemium services. Exposure to lots of use
by busterarm 11y ago
Exposure isn't necessarily good for an app.
Users frequently _cost_ money. Ask anyone who has significantly scaled freemium services.
Exposure to lots of users who might not use your service can kill your business.
If your service is really that good or serves a real need, you would recognize these potential users and market to them _aggressively_. You would even raise significant capital to do so if you did not have it. Seeing the value in your product, VCs would invest in you.
Even if your product has no inherent costs to provide as a service after it is made, you scale the money and time that invested in it based on your expected reach/profit and your profit model has just been thoroughly fked by Apple.
This definitely applies to people who produce music too because the product you're releasing has a profitable shelf-life (except for unicorns, really) and artists release on a schedule that their market (and they personally) can support.
You put a certain amount of money and time into an album based on how many people it will reach and the likelihood and timeframe before you can put out another one. Some artists release every few years, some every year and some release multiple albums per year.
If Apple is giving away your album for 3 months and you release 4 albums a year, they may be giving away 1/4 of your yearly income...(Think of it like Big O and worry about your worst-case performance.)
Using revenue streams that you don't control is hazardous. Relying on them is outright dangerous. Using revenue streams that you don't control AND marketing streams that you don't control? Suicide.
Note: this is not an argument for whether you should pay for music or not...that's a topic too hot for HN.
- w4 11y ago> 4 albums a year And that would be an incredibly productive artist. Most artists release something like 1 album every 1-2 years, at best.
- busterarm 11y agoMaybe in genres of music that you're accustomed to. There are a few where high output is the norm. The output of a lot of producers and (especially) ghost-writers is pretty hard to fathom. I have a great story about Japanese record labels that's pretty long for here though. Many well-known artists have released multiple hit records in the same year before though and many more are releasing their own albums and producing other peoples. In the early 60s popular artists sometimes put out two hit records a year (Bob Dylan, The Beatles '63-'65)...Led Zeppelin did that once in '68. David Bowie put out two hit records AND co-wrote and produced two Iggy Pop records in '77. CCR put out three LPs one year... It happens a lot more than you realize.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoAnother thing to note is that artists often (can) produce far more music than ends up on their albums; they, or their producers / publishers, realize that not everything they produce is good music. Just like code / software. So while you can produce thousands of lines of code a day if you churn out enough, only ten or so will actually be worth keeping.
- busterarm 11y agoAgreed...but I hope my (or anyone's) useful output as a programmer is significantly more than 1%. I really want to drive home the "you're going to work just as hard, but for less money" argument to get people thinking about it the right way. It's no different than music piracy, which actually I don't care about, just don't be dishonest about doing it as a business.
- busterarm 11y agoAs another separate point that I'd like here but isn't part of this comment. I think that all transactions _inevitably_ break down when (at least) one party has no skin in the game or when they misestimate their or the counter-party's stake. (Call it the busterarm theory of economics). The only possible skin in the game that Apple has here is their brand. Their offering here is basically a value statement that Apple's brand and what it brings is worth more than artists will be losing in streaming dollars. I think Apple is significantly misestimating both their risk and their counter-party risk here. _And_ the risk to their brand is effectively zero. It'll be interesting to see what happens. My impression of their music offerings was that their real value was the trust they had with both artists and consumes; they probably don't see it being that way. One cannot operate a paid media streaming music while simultaneously proposing that the value of that media is zero. There's that old business maximum that if you want to know what a company cares about, look what they spend their money on.
- peteretep 11y ago> Exposure isn't necessarily good for an app. Users > frequently _cost_ money. Ask anyone who has > significantly scaled freemium services. Then it's not a business, it's a charity.
- busterarm 11y agoNot necessarily. Cost of users isn't linear with count of users and while it might go down as your userbase grows, you might not have the finances yet to handle that growth. You can't just "be ready to host a 100 million users, tomorrow" in the early stages of your business.
- peteretep 11y agoIf you don't have a contingency plan for how you will handle - operationally, financially, infrastructure-perspective, monetization - user scaling at speed, then not only is your business a charity, it's a hobby, too. If there are credible signs you will acquire 100m users tomorrow, and you can't walk in to a VC and walk out with a big chunk of money for a small amount of equity, it means you don't have a real business plan. Additionally, I would be interested in any examples you have of companies acquiring 100m users overnight, or anything within two orders of magnitude of that.
- busterarm 11y agoThat's the thing about "exposure" though. You have no control over it. You can't plan for it. You are missing the point. 100 million was just a number. The corpses of businesses that scaled past their ability to serve their customers are real. But part of your argument has merit: it's the same reason that "exposure" doesn't create album sales. There's no real chance (really, there isn't) that you have a product that will reach 100m people tomorrow, so you shouldn't be producing music as if you would.
- peteretep 11y ago> You can't plan for it. Sounds like a good way to get sued by your investors. > The corpses of businesses that scaled past their ability > to serve their customers are real. Turns out that a Rails App + someone calling themselves a "Serial Startup CEO" on LinkedIn don't necessarily equate to a business.