5 ms·
> I'd encourage you to consider the hypothetical I posted in the last thread about Apple Music's 3 month trial. To make the analogy a little more accurate: >
by kstrauser 11y ago
> I'd encourage you to consider the hypothetical I posted in the last thread about Apple Music's 3 month trial.
To make the analogy a little more accurate:
> Tomorrow, Apple announces that it will be introducing an "App Store Subscription." For $9.99/month users will be allowed to use one App Store app at a time. When an app is running, it will present a button allowing a user to purchase that app so that they may use it any time they want, whether or not their phone is connected to the Internet, and concurrently with other apps. During the 3 month free trial, Apple will not pay royalties for streaming apps but will pay normal royalties for any apps purchased.
This would suck for the Omni Groups and Mojangs, but absolutely awesome for tiny shops who currently make almost nothing and would now have much greater exposure. Likewise Taylor Swift doesn't need more exposure to sell her music, but Joe Garage might actually pick up a few listeners and fans. You see this is a money grab. I see this is as a necessary (and label approved!) bootstrapping for long term gain.
And in the mean time, even major artists will continue to get their current revenue stream from radio stations, Spotify, iTMS, etc. unless we really believe that Apple Music is going to gain a 100% market share immediately. Long term, even that would probably be a huge benefit to artists because it's almost certainly a better deal than they're getting from anyone else today.
- buro9 11y agoUnless you happen to be this Summer's big record... in which case your one profitable window for your track will have has just been obliterated.
- latj 11y agoLets say you are that artist. You have practiced, trained, studied. You have worked hard and have a rare natural talent. You sang the songs and played guitar. Now you have "this summer's big record". Two million children want to listen to your song (without paying any additional costs) 50-100 times over the next 3 months, and then never again. How much is that worth to society? How much money should you make from that? Consider an elementary teacher tasked with teaching 28 children to read and guiding them to becoming active participants in democracy rather than repeat offenders. $50k/yr. Compare a state university computer science professor who will teach dozens of new jacks this year how to measure and optimize algorithms-- setting them up for a life of full time employment while all their friends tread in the sea of shit and unemployment around them. $90k/yr. Consider a bus driver, a construction worker, a civil engineer, anyone who didnt have a chance to finish high school or College and still goes to work every day. Or those who went to ivy league colleges and resisted the urge to go into finance. Productive people. We are all productive and we all add value, and we are underpaid. Our kids will have varying access to good education. We have less access to inferior healthcare. We spend too much time at work and not enough time with our kids. The lowest of us live in poverty and violence, relegated to feeding our children less healthy, life shortening diets. And thats just in the U.S., one of the wealthiest states on the planet. Now how much is that song you sang worth? Artists should be about art. If you dont like the fact that Apple wants you to be their slave, then distribute your music yourself. If people dont want to pay for your music, then keep doing what you want to do and starve or start doing what they want you to do and make money. But dont try to be about the art and say the faceless evil corporation should pay you more. It is disrespectful to the productive workers of the world.
- nosideeffects 11y agoI think you completely missed the point. Using your own analogies of teachers, this would sort of be like a local government letting all the teachers know that they will be teaching kids without pay for the next 3 months. If this ever happened, any teachers that could would get the hell out of dodge.
- kstrauser 11y agoIt's really not like that at all. The teacher scenario has an opportunity cost: if they're busy teaching kids for free, then they're not available for teaching other kids for pay. In the Apple Music situation, there's likely very little opportunity cost unless we believe that it's going to be so amazingly and instantly successful that it will cannibalize all current revenue streams.
- braythwayt 11y agoIn the Apple Music situation, there's likely very little opportunity cost unless we believe that it's going to be so amazingly and instantly successful that it will cannibalize all current revenue streams. You or I may believe whatever we like, but I’ll bet big money that Apple believes that it will be amazingly and instantly successful and further that their entire business plan consists of cannibalizing all current revenue streams. I don’t think they’d be in this business at all if they didn’t think they had a shot at rendering the competition irrelevant.
- thadd 11y agoTake a look at The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith
- jlarocco 11y agoThat's a funny way of looking at it. The reality is that most of the people you're talking about will "waste" their meagre salaries on trivial stuff like streaming music services and satellite TV. Taylor Swift didn't sell millions of albums to nobody. Music is entertainment, and it makes people's crappy lives more enjoyable, and that's a pretty valuable service, which is why it can be so lucrative for some people.
- sgk284 11y agoThat assumes every Apple Music user is on their 3 month free trial at the same time. This 3 month trial won't even be a consideration in a year, as the majority of users will be past theirs. In reality, at any given moment a small percentage of users will be in the free trial period (excluding the first 3 months of the service being generally available).
- busterarm 11y agoWell, 100% of users will be on a 3 month trial the first year that they use a service, so it doesn't matter when it happens. For any successful service, the number of those users should grow YoY, at least for a while. (We're growing so fast, the number of people listening to your album for free has an exponential growth curve! SEE? WE'RE CRUSHING IT!) Most artists aren't successful (if even) for more than a few years at best. The lifespan of their albums even less so. (Some old data: http://frumin.net/ation/2008/05/climb_the_charts_schmimb_the_charts.html http://frumin.net/ation/2008/05/climb_the_charts_schmimb_the... ) Okay, it might matter when it happens: It might be really catastrophic to release your album right when the service starts (actually it sounds like Ms. Swift is pretty smart now, eh?). Though then you might want to hold off for a whole year entirely. Hold on now, why is Apple dictating the release schedule of my albums? I thought they weren't a record label... ...oh wait.
- busterarm 11y agoExposure isn't necessarily good for an app. Users frequently _cost_ money. Ask anyone who has significantly scaled freemium services. Exposure to lots of users who might not use your service can kill your business. If your service is really that good or serves a real need, you would recognize these potential users and market to them _aggressively_. You would even raise significant capital to do so if you did not have it. Seeing the value in your product, VCs would invest in you. Even if your product has no inherent costs to provide as a service after it is made, you scale the money and time that invested in it based on your expected reach/profit and your profit model has just been thoroughly fked by Apple. This definitely applies to people who produce music too because the product you're releasing has a profitable shelf-life (except for unicorns, really) and artists release on a schedule that their market (and they personally) can support. You put a certain amount of money and time into an album based on how many people it will reach and the likelihood and timeframe before you can put out another one. Some artists release every few years, some every year and some release multiple albums per year. If Apple is giving away your album for 3 months and you release 4 albums a year, they may be giving away 1/4 of your yearly income...(Think of it like Big O and worry about your worst-case performance.) Using revenue streams that you don't control is hazardous. Relying on them is outright dangerous. Using revenue streams that you don't control AND marketing streams that you don't control? Suicide. Note: this is not an argument for whether you should pay for music or not...that's a topic too hot for HN.
- w4 11y ago> 4 albums a year And that would be an incredibly productive artist. Most artists release something like 1 album every 1-2 years, at best.
- busterarm 11y agoMaybe in genres of music that you're accustomed to. There are a few where high output is the norm. The output of a lot of producers and (especially) ghost-writers is pretty hard to fathom. I have a great story about Japanese record labels that's pretty long for here though. Many well-known artists have released multiple hit records in the same year before though and many more are releasing their own albums and producing other peoples. In the early 60s popular artists sometimes put out two hit records a year (Bob Dylan, The Beatles '63-'65)...Led Zeppelin did that once in '68. David Bowie put out two hit records AND co-wrote and produced two Iggy Pop records in '77. CCR put out three LPs one year... It happens a lot more than you realize.