3 ms·
Sure, because no hunter/gatherer tribes had a chief, medicine woman or other revered person who both gave direction to their tribe, and to whom the tribe was re
by falcolas 11y ago
Sure, because no hunter/gatherer tribes had a chief, medicine woman or other revered person who both gave direction to their tribe, and to whom the tribe was responsible.
A pretty weak argument against bosses. Humans naturally tend to form hierarchies - the boss is simply one node in that hierarchy.
That some people thrive in such positions doesn't mean it's our natural state.
- astazangasta 11y agoHumans don't naturally form hierarchies. At least I don't always look to an authority figure to tell me what to do. I usually want independence and creative space, along with the advice and aid of knowledgeable colleagues. I chafe under the yoke of arbitrary authority. But maybe I'm not human.
- habitue 11y agoYou're human, but you're not all humans. I think people have a continuum of attitudes on what they're willing to trade autonomy for. I've met a lot of people who are happy to have someone tell them what to do, because it means they don't need to figure it out for themselves. That's not bad, it's sort of a necessary ingredient of working together that some people need to be more willing to follow than to lead.
- astazangasta 11y agoI think people confuse division of labor with hierarchy. The former means other people make decisions I don't care to. The latter means others tell me what to do and are acknowledged as my superiors.
- habitue 11y agoYes, this is true. There's definitely a difference between "this guy is making strategic decisions and interfacing with the rest of the company on my behalf" and "this guy is my superior and should be paid more than me". Unfortunately, the bosses make the salary decisions, so it just sort of falls out of that
- Ologn 11y agoHunter/gatherer tribe is an oxymoron. Hunter gatherers are grouped together in bands, not tribes. By the time a society has a chief, it is always larger than a band, and almost always larger than even a tribe. The great mass of data from anthropological studies of these types of societies contradicts most of what you said.