3 ms·
> unacceptable risk of them falling on someone's head Same could be said about airplanes 100 years ago, but now I have planes flying over my head about 20 time
by golergka 11y ago
> unacceptable risk of them falling on someone's head
Same could be said about airplanes 100 years ago, but now I have planes flying over my head about 20 times a day. Even in the post-9/11 world.
The safety of drones will only increase, and with such a great financial incentive as the whole delivery industry, it will do so rapidly.
- cstross 11y agoThe safety of airliners comes at a cost -- operating expenses (a lot of which is for maintenance) running so high that they're uneconomical except for bulk/public transport or the hyper-rich. Private flying cars they aren't. Small delivery drones, almost by definition, are your "flying car" paradigm, downsized to just the cargo compartment because they don't need to carry 70-300kg of shaved apes. Maintenance and QA is going to be a big issue, and will drive up prices.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoSmall private planes do tend to crash into houses and golf courses and IRS buildings semi-regularly tho.
- icebraining 11y agoWhich due to pilot error, though, not technical problems. The kind of delivery drones we're discussing will most likely be auto-piloted.
- falcolas 11y ago> The safety of drones will only increase I hate to be a negative Nancy about this, but [citation needed]. I fly a multi-rotor coptor now, and when the battery hits a certain point it just drops out of the sky, wherever it might happen to be. This is just a toy model, so it doesn't have some of the fancier electronics a delivery drone might - but there's nothing inherently stable about a multirotor like there is with a plane. Even the best motor failure "recovery" I've seen so far is still a multirotor going into a barely-controlled death spiral - something which would still cause a lot of damage to whatever it hit. Imagine it for a moment: a 20-30 pound object falling in an unpredictable (to humans) spiral at speeds faster than you can run, with between three and seven 10 inch props moving at near supersonic speeds at their tips. I love 'em, but they're dangerous machines with lots of fast-moving parts, and need to be treated as such.
- kenrikm 11y agoI fly and build a great many multi rotors and planes myself. And with current tech you can have it land itself when it gets to a certain voltage. No reason to have it falling out of the sky due to a dead battery.
- icebraining 11y agoWhile not exactly inherent, there's plenty that can be done to further secure their falls. Firstly, is to have automatic auto-landing when the battery is getting low (with a good safety margin, of course). The other is what DJI is already exploring with their "DropSafe", ie., parachute. A simple software tweak (when accelerometer detects falling, shut down motors and deploy parachute) could make most falls reasonably safe (and less costly to the owner). With cameras, they could also try to avoid flying over humans. Finally, in cities, they could fly most of their way over the roofs of building, rendering a fall unlikely to hit anyone.
- agumonkey 11y agoEven without motor failure, if control is jammed, your toy goes rogue. A frenchman showed a video were his drone would get lose contact, get confused, and start to seek for it's charging base where there was none, flying over a motorway full of cars. It could have landed there. It went further, almost crashed into a skycraper (wind dynamics pushed it away IIUC) then landed on the curb.