10 ms·
The town that banned Wi-Fi
- protomyth 11y ago"She felt the hostility was best explained as a kind of conspiracy between the ill-informed and Big Telephony." or, just maybe, people don't like people who show up and demand everyone change for their sake - see any entertainment venue / farmer that has a new housing development show up in the next property over
- throwaway5420 11y agoSee also, Gamergate.
- anti-shill 11y agoI wonder whether any of these nonprofit organizations that publicize the problems of ‘Electrosensitive’ people are funded by cable and internet companies.
- vidarh 11y agoProbably very few given that pretty much all ISPs these days assume that everyone wants wifi routers.
- anti-shill 11y agoyou are not getting me...back when it looked like cities might be using powerlines to build their own internet infrastructure in combination with wireless, there was a sudden burst of concern about wireless causing health problems. Then for some reason the possibility of such networks went away. And at the same time, the complaints about wireless went away. It seemed to me that such networks were a threat to companies such as comcast, time warner. So, I wondered whether time warner, comcast et al, were funding these complaints via nonprofit foundations.
- kw71 11y agoYou are confused, are misinformed, or misunderstand. BPL did not take hold because it fundamentally caused interference to HF radio. BPL itself has nothing to do with wireless anything. It is not the usual case that cities own powerlines. The cities that do own such utilities have generally preferred to lay fiber instead of experiment with BPL, as they frequently own utilities that deliver telephony and video services.
- anti-shill 11y agothat is a moot point...my statements above stand...
- davepage 11y agoShortwave listeners and amateur radio folks were upset about powerline internet: http://www.arrl.org/broadband-over-powerline-bpl http://www.arrl.org/broadband-over-powerline-bpl From an engineering standpoint, sending broadband over the power infrastructure is seriously ugly, because the SNR is poor, shielding is poor, and spectral distortion is high. Power lines were never designed to be constant impedance, low loss and shielded for broadband frequencies. Due to all the impairments, the transmit power must be relatively high, and coupled with the poor shielding, interference with legitimate radio users is inevitable.
- anti-shill 11y agoShortwave listeners and amateur radio folks compared to comcast and time warner...different league...
- davepage 11y agoWell, maybe. From a regulatory perspective, the radio users have more FCC clout than insouciant interference sources like Comcast and TW, neglecting whatever regulatory capture may exist.
- 1ris 11y agoIn Germany there is connection between electrosmog advocates and the tobacco industry in the person of Franz Adlkofer, Mersch-Sundermann and others. Here is a german-language text that deals with that connection: https://www.psiram.com/ge/index.php/Elektrosmog https://www.psiram.com/ge/index.php/Elektrosmog
- assface 11y ago> "People come here because they say they can hear the electrics" That phrase is straight out of a Deliverance-like horror film.
- javajosh 11y agoI can hear CRTs and some lighting fixtures. It's a super high pitch. Not painful - and is only useful to verify that a CRT is getting power on powerup, before it's display turns on. I hypothesize that if these people had some unusually high metallic content in the skin/bone in/around their inner ear that moves slightly in response to EMR then that might actually do something to them, like trigger complex migraines. You'd need two highly unlikely (and unlucky) problems for this to be real, but it's not exactly the same as Morgellons[1]. Also, tooth fillings + bone conduction can pick up radio signals, so I'm not sure why these people are being dismissed so quickly as psychiatric cases. Diane's demanding nature sounds like it caused more problems for her than her condition. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgellons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgellons
- geon 11y agoI can also hear some CRT TVs. I have never heard any other type of CRT, though. Are you sure they don't simply emit 20+ kHz sound?
- javajosh 11y ago>Are you sure they don't simply emit 20+ kHz sound? They do. Sorry, didn't mean to imply high metal content in the inner was responsible for both phenomena. Was just trying to give the benefit of the doubt to these people's claims; it sort of bothers me when "science" is quick to dismiss people's claims. I'm sure a lot of people would call me (us) crazy for thinking we can hear such a high pitch - but since it's kind of unimportant trivia, like being able to roll your tongue, it doesn't matter. If hearing the high pitch was the cause of great suffering, being called crazy to think that was the cause would hurt a great deal more, I imagine.
- 11y ago
- cmdrfred 11y agoThis should be an easy condition to prove with a trial. Get two shoe boxes and place them on them in two rooms, get two 'electrosentives' and place one in each room. One of the shoeboxes has a WiFi router in it. Do this a bunch of times and see if its any better than random chance.
- hannob 11y agoSuch studies have been done numerous times. You need to consider proper blinding to get it right, but it's not too hard. But if you have people who will claim that every study contradicting their belief is a conspiracy by the phone industry that doesn't help a lot. It's like homeopathy: You can throw as many studies as you want at the believers. They don't believe in science, therefore it's not working.
- zalzane 11y agoin the article it says they don't want to submit to testing > None of which gets round the core issue: if EHS is real, I asked Diane, then why has it not shown up in formal experiments? “I encourage scientists to go to where we are and measure the environment,” she replied. “Don’t try to pretend that you’re God and expose us to different frequencies in a lab. That’s like taking someone and breaking their legs and asking how much it hurts.”
- emiliobumachar 11y agoTheir should be a signal intensity level high enough to be distinguishable from nothing but still low enough to cause slight annoyance rather than traumatic agony over a short period.
- cwyers 11y agoOne of the people in the story claims the florescent bulbs at the Dollar Store triggered her condition. If that's the case, it should be REALLY easy to verify some of these claims in a laboratory setting.
- tomohawk 11y agoIf 'sensitives' are so impacted by this, perhaps they should buy up a bunch of land in a valley in the boonies somewhere and create their own community? Probably get better results than moving into an existing community and trying to coerce people to change their ways.
- batou 11y agoThey aren't the most logical bunch. My father is allergic to poultry apparently yet chows down on hot dogs made mostly from turkey. Same level of batshit.
- nitrogen 11y agoThere was an episode of some TV show where someone thought they were allergic to poultry but it was actually an allergy to the antibiotics in the poultry. Maybe the parts of turkey or the processing methods used for hot dogs contain less antibiotic residue?
- batou 11y agoHe was brought up on a farm in Switzerland in the 1950s before industrial farming took off, so definitely not that. I suspect it was a psychological thing after having to process chickens by hand.
- danieltillett 11y agoHe may well be allergic to something in their feathers. While I am not a huge fan of hot dogs and what goes into them I suspect that even the worst manufacturers draw the line at letting feathers into the vat.
- jschwartzi 11y agoI think it's less of an actual medical problem and more of an attention-seeking behavior. If you actually try to propose solutions, there's always a reason why they won't work. If something actually did work, then they would lose all of the attention they get for their "illness."
- pbiggar 11y agoIf they decided to do it, is there a (legal) way for Green Bank to prevent electrosensitive people from moving there?
- mistercow 11y ago>He held a meeting with some electrosensitives, and didn’t tell them he had a mobile phone in his pocket. “They noticed at once. After that I was convinced. Ah the good ol' base rate fallacy. I can predict with around 90% accuracy whether a given American adult has a cellphone on their person, simply by always answering "yes". But I doubt you'd be impressed if I pointed at a random stranger and said "That guy has a cell phone".
- daemin 11y agoIt's also likely that the electrosensitives have had this test run on them so many times by ordinary people where "I'll just hide this radio device here somewhere and see if they pick it up", that they get attuned to finding out the hidden object, rather than actual sensitivity. It would have been more amusing if he had the phone switched off already or no phone at all and they asked him to switch it off.
- cwyers 11y ago> None of which gets round the core issue: if EHS is real, I asked Diane, then why has it not shown up in formal experiments? “I encourage scientists to go to where we are and measure the environment,” she replied. “Don’t try to pretend that you’re God and expose us to different frequencies in a lab. That’s like taking someone and breaking their legs and asking how much it hurts.” That would in fact let you determine if breaking someone's leg caused them pain, though.
- SomeStupidPoint 11y agoAlso, we have probably tens of thousands of records of times that we either intentionally or accidentally, but under heavy observation broke someone's leg, and they seem to pretty reliably be disturbed by the incident. (We actually have effectively done controlled experiments on leg breaking during various times we used torture methods to kill people, and as you say, it turns out that it hurt them.) If the EMF people had a fraction of that evidence, everyone would take them much more seriously.
- saalweachter 11y agoWe do break people's bones pretty regularly as part of a medical intervention. The simplest case is just resetting a bone that healed crooked, but there are countless other ways, like in open-heart surgery or an orthodontic procedure that involves breaking the upper or lower jaw.
- __z 11y agoRemoval of impacted wisdom teeth (a common procedure) often involves removal of bone.
- girvo 11y agoI have a bit of bone right above my two front teeth that was removed -- right in the middle of it was a random tooth. I like to think it was my egg-tooth, but regardless, I was in rather a lot of pain after the operation; turns out removing and breaking bone hurts quite a lot.
- beloch 11y ago"None of which gets round the core issue: if EHS is real, I asked Diane, then why has it not shown up in formal experiments? “I encourage scientists to go to where we are and measure the environment,” she replied. “Don’t try to pretend that you’re God and expose us to different frequencies in a lab. That’s like taking someone and breaking their legs and asking how much it hurts.”" Right, so we can't actually test your crippling sensitivity to EMF in a lab even though, if it's as bad as you say it is, a double blind test to see if you could reliably tell when a radio in a shoe-box is switched on ought to be good enough. --- "the lack of proof from major studies is merely evidence of a conspiracy between interested parties. “Conventional government-funded science isn’t a reliable indicator of health defects,” she told me. “There’s a vested interest in keeping the truth out of circulation." So, beyond the fact that willing test subjects are hard to find, there's a conspiracy to cover up evidence showing people really are "sensitives". --- "Like Meckna, Dacre felt that there were people claiming to be electrosensitive who were nothing of the sort, who were queering the pitch for the others: “You can tell at once who is just pretending,” she said. " Even better, the test subjects we can round up are likely fakers! --- "“See those?” he asked. “Aeroplane trails?” “Not contrails – chemtrails,” he said. “The government sprays the air – it gets in the atmosphere.” He paused and looked me in the eye. “The world needs to know what’s happening here.” " My suspicions about what's really going on here are beginning to coalesce...
- reamworks 11y agoThese people are almost as bad as the "Healthy at Any Size" folks who deny that Obesity leads to serious health problems. Sadly, "Fat Acceptance" is the only point of view that's allowed on reddit, and in Y Combinator News, despite the fact that it's just as unscientific as believing in EHS.
- scholia 11y agoGiven that hundreds of millions of people live in cities like London, New York, Tokyo etc that are completely covered with thousands of mobile phone towers and thousands more Wi-Fi networks -- not to mention radio controlled cars, baby monitors and all the other things that use the same frequencies as Wi-Fi -- EHS is remarkably rare. Really, Starbucks baristas should be dropping like flies. However, the reality is that Wi-Fi sickness or EHS is not caused by Wi-Fi, it is caused by stories about Wi-Fi. It is a Mass psychogenic illness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness It's like a placebo effect, where fake pills can actually cure sick people (if they believe that they will). However, because it's the opposite effect to a placebo, it's called a nocebo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nocebo People really do get sick, even though there is no biological reason for them to get sick. Fortunately, most EHS victims just get the symptoms that are common to all mass psychogenic illnesses, regardless of the imagined cause: headaches (67%), dizziness or light-headedness (46%), nausea (41%) and so on. However. some nocebo's can be fatal, eg witch-doctors. Journalist training should really include information about nocebos because writing or broadcasting about psychogenic illnesses can cause psychogenic illnesses. As it is, however, almost all today's EHS sickness is most likely caused by the people who are campaigning about EHS.
- reillyse 11y agoFrom reading the article. Turns out they didn't actually ban wifi. It's just not very prevalent in the town. It's not illegal but the observatory might ask you to stop.
- rdc12 11y agoThe more intersting part is the cause and effect. A perfectly sane and techincal reason for the restriction of wifi, and the effect being people turning up for that reason. From the headline I was expecting some woo people, had managed to ban wifi in a town. (reversed cause and effect)
- kalleboo 11y agoWiFi iZ banned in the area by law, and the FCC can fine violators, it's just there's nobody nearby with the authority to enforce the ban https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio_Quiet_Zone https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Radio...
- sxcurry 11y agoI live near a town (Ashland OR) full of wingnuts who are worried about EMF, chem trails, and vaccinations. My question: with so many real things to worry about, why focus on false ones?
- girvo 11y agoIt helps them feel special, and that they know things that everyone doesn't.
- danmaz74 11y ago> US Cellular was the brand – I didn’t react to AT&T, Spring or Cellular One towers ...
- busterarm 11y agoI thought when NAS came around we were gonna get cool, drug-addict symptoms like the black shakes...but headaches and skin-rashes? Lame.
- bitwize 11y agoFun fact: Gibson got the idea for NAS from Pana Wave, a Japanese cult whose members believe that ordinary radio waves are harmful and go around in white sheets or something.
- morgante 11y ago> US Cellular was the brand – I didn’t react to AT&T, Spring or Cellular One towers. That's where I stopped reading. Shame on the Guardian for giving these anti-science reactionaries the platform for seeking the attention they so desperately crave.
- wiredfool 11y agoIt was the underground tower for me.
- kw71 11y agoI think the article is pretty good because they didn't filter out any of the silliness on the part of some of these people. It really shines through to us rational types and this piece gave me the biggest laughs I had today. Also I don't know the details (the year and more details about the location would help) but there is the chance that that one carrier used different frequencies to the others. People, their dental works and medical implants will all resonate at different frequencies. However if it turns out she was reacting to only one carrier's AMPS towers (all US AMPS ran on 806-896 MHz) it's total BS.
- jpatokal 11y agoKeep reading. The article doesn't even come close to endorsing the people interviewed, and if you read between the lines it's pretty clear the author thinks they're all nuts.
- sean-duffy 11y agoA pretty good treatment of the whole idea of 'EHS' in a fictional context can be seen in the Breaking Bad spin-off Better Caul Saul, where the main character has to care to his brother, who claims to have EHS.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoEHS always reminds me of the town in South Africa whose residents swore that a broadband internet tower was causing headaches, skin rashes, tinnitus, and all manner of maladies. They claimed it would take hours after they left the town for their symptoms to subside, sometimes up to a couple days. While they were continuing to complain at a town meeting, they did not know that the tower had already been off weeks ago and yet they continued to complain about it causing EHS symptoms. Even after learning they were wrong, they just kept fighting. http://mybroadband.co.za/news/wireless/11099-massive-revelation-in-iburst-tower-battle.html http://mybroadband.co.za/news/wireless/11099-massive-revelat...
- bane 11y agoIgnoring the crazy people in the article, I've driven through Greenbank a number of times on the way to-from skiing in the region. There's not much of a town there, it really is out in the middle of nowhere, down in a valley. You'll be driving along not having passed another car in the last hour and suddenly there's a massive massive radio telescope sitting out in the middle of what would probably be a farmer's field. The town is more like a few houses dotted along a major road and a couple of turn-offs with a few bunched up houses. My wife and I usually comment while driving through something about how it must suck to be an engineer working on the telescope and living there. I always wondered what sort of folks live there and now I know. This is the area if anybody's interested https://www.google.com/maps/place/Green+Bank+Telescope/@38.432155,-79.839803,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x884b6ecff9104eb9:0x3091683ec4a98833 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Green+Bank+Telescope/@38.4... You can get tours https://public.nrao.edu/tours/visitgbt https://public.nrao.edu/tours/visitgbt
- jimminy 11y agoI'm from the area, a little town about 35 miles away, but living in the Bay Area. The article doesn't really tell a good story about the folks living there. Just the ecentric people that have started showing up relatively recently. Maybe growing up there, but I actually prefer the solitude. The interesting thing about those few small houses is that you end up getting to know the people in your area and around you pretty well. Nearly everyone. So I wouldn't make the assumption that "it must suck". I could make the same assumption about any over populated area, like the Bay Area, because it's nearly impossible to really know your community and traffic is horrible. Ugh, it must suck to be an engineer working on some startup and living there.
- bane 11y agoYeah that's true. I guess I should qualify my comment. I mean "it must suck" being in a technical field, but in a real sense quite cut off from interaction with your peers. It's actually a beautiful area, but I can't help but feel that people could very easily feel out of their milieu there.
- unsignedint 11y ago