4 ms·
Only issue with this is that the German taxpayers might grow wary of Americans performing these drive-by educations at their expense. The entire system is based
by Havoc 11y ago
Only issue with this is that the German taxpayers might grow wary of Americans performing these drive-by educations at their expense. The entire system is based on the assumption that a reasonable portion will stay in Germany & contribute towards society.
The whole article & the mindset behind it is a little sad in my opinion. To borrow a reddit phrase "this is why we can't have nice things".
- bruceb 11y agoSeems this could be solved partially with a rebate system. You stay you get $X back (or in this case euros).
- Havoc 11y agoThat would be one option. The current system is working as is though - no enforcement & almost honour based. It would be nice to keep it that way. I get why Americans would do this given their crushing education costs, but at the end of the day the German education isn't "free" either...the taxpayer foots the bill & in the long run said taxpayer wants to receive some benefit for that money.
- barry-cotter 11y agoThe number of US students doing a degree and out in Germany is and will continue to be fairly low. While German is by any realistic standard fairly easy for an English speaker that's at least three months of full-time work if you're starting from nothing, if you work real hard. And after three to five years studying in Germany lots of people will have friends and relationships. Social ties matter. Loads of Africans, Russians, etc. have been doing this before.
- ma2rten 11y agoUnless Americans come in masses, I think, Germans are actually happy to have the cultural and language exchange with them. The marginal cost for adding a couple of students is not going to be very much.
- x5n1 11y agoGermans are not stupid people. They will adapt. Take advantage of this while it lasts. Not to mention it is not easy to get into German schools either. But if you are at the top of your class you should not have a problem.
- ma2rten 11y agoActually in Germany admission into public schools is guaranteed by law. There are lawyers that specialize on suing people's way in. It should cost about 1000 euro. The following link has more information [in German]: http://jetzt.sueddeutsche.de/texte/anzeigen/585532/Wie-kann-ich-mich-an-der-Uni-einklagen http://jetzt.sueddeutsche.de/texte/anzeigen/585532/Wie-kann-...
- reagency 11y agoDoes German law guarantee non-Germans a public education?
- ma2rten 11y agoI think so. I am not a lawyer and I don't even live in Germany, but I did a quick Google search in German. It seems the German constitution explicitly prohibits discrimination based on "national origin".
- detaro 11y agoThat doesn't work on that level. I mean, you need visa to enter, too, which also would be "discrimination based on origin" by that argument (and is a requirement for getting education) The often quoted right to choose place of work/education freely (which the article you linked starts with) clearly says "All Germans have the right...".
- detaro 11y agoThe suing people in is kind of a loophole. A university has to take as many students as it can "service". People then sue and say that the number they accepted was wrong and they actually have capacity left over, and of course in many cases you can find an argument that yes, they could support a few people more if someone in some department would do less research and more teaching, ... So universities often give in and "admit" that they can take some random number more instead of trying to fight a complex lawsuit with unknown results. And possibly add a safety margin in the future, because letting some more people in is easier than proving that their capacity planning was perfect.
- 0x5f3759df-i 11y agoI think you are missing out on the key paragraph here: >Of course, the precondition to this even working is that Anna knows fluent German – sadly something like the The Everything Learning German Book won’t do. She would have to at the very least start studying German in high school in the 9th grade, then go through immersion before matriculating, which requires a bit of foresight for any 14 year old.