3 ms·
The big issue i have with this whole WHOIS privacy thing is that it does absolutely squat to prevent governments and corporations from getting the details but i
by dogma1138 11y ago
The big issue i have with this whole WHOIS privacy thing is that it does absolutely squat to prevent governments and corporations from getting the details but it makes it impossible for regular individuals to get the details when needed.
I've seen multiple cases of activities raging from purely illegal activities like phishing to simple griefing, and normally you can't do shit about it.
You can have phishing domains which are registered trough even basic privacy shields operating with impunity and you can't do anything about it.
The police doesn't care, the privacy protection is structured in such a manner that you need to get a court order in like 3 different jurisdictions which is impossible even if you are a decent size business unless you have a lot of money not to mention a small business or an individual.
If they are also running something nasty on that domain you might be lucky and you can get their hosting company to cooperate the site will go down but taking control over the domain name it self is nearly impossible.
Edit:
Here is an actual case from personal exprience
UK Company with a mycompany.com domain with 1-1.5M GBP a year in revenue and they can't get the mycompany.co.uk domain which is used for spam and phishing taken off.
The co.uk domain is used for some annoying stuff and was registered by "socialshop" and technically ENOM/Rightside but the NS servers and the actual domain registration is handled by privacyprotect.org.
This whole thing was structured in such way that for anyone to talk to you you had to file criminal and civil suits in Hong Kong, Australia, UK/EU and maybe the US to deal with Rightside.
This isn't something that even most SMB's could handle unless it's a huge drain on their business since this ordeal will probably cost more than a yearly revenue for most small and medium businesses.
Luckily they hosted in France of all places and the hosting companies shutdown the website without asking for anythig as soon as the abuse notice was sent.
It seemed like this was just a run of the mill automated phishing/spam campaign so once the website was taken down all traffic from that domain stopped, but they can revive it at any given time.
The whole deal was a bit odd and sad, ENOM did the domain registration and then transferred all the control over the domain to the privacy service which was used to register the domain in the 1st place. Heck they can't even take it off since they can't touch the name servers of that domain since they don't run it. The privacy service won't speak to you and will send you on a legal wild-goose chase around the globe.
This isn't even a privacy/WHOIS issue honestly, the whole registration system is designed to be abused because it's profitable that way.