3 ms·
Considering the author (David Hestenes) has spent his whole career since the 60s as a physicist and physics teacher, I suspect he has a pretty good grasp on wha
by jacobolus 11y ago
Considering the author (David Hestenes) has spent his whole career since the 60s as a physicist and physics teacher, I suspect he has a pretty good grasp on what is possible for physicists and helpful for physics students.
If you are a physics teacher too, I highly recommend studying his work on modeling, as well as studying his work on Geometric Algebra. That is, every physicist, especially mechanics teachers at the undergrad level, should try working through New Foundations for Classical Mechanics, and every physics teacher at every level should spend some solid time with http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/html/Modeling.html http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/html/Modeling.html http://modeling.asu.edu/ http://modeling.asu.edu/
As for coordinates: there are many many problems in physics which can be solved in a coordinate-free way, saving huge amounts of error-prone symbol-twiddling bookkeeping while improving clarity and intuition. Even if you want to compute a numerical solution to something, solving it in the abstract case in a coordinate free way often lets you plug your numbers into a much nicer formula at the end.
Coordinates are not an essential part of the world, and not even an essential part of most physical models of particular situations. They are imposed by problem-solvers who have learned to always work with coordinates, without thinking, even for problems where the coordinates complicate problem solving. At the point where coordinates become necessary, they can always be added in with little difficulty. However, ripping the coordinates out of a half-solved problem is basically impossible.
- jessriedel 11y agoNo where do I say that the geometric picture is not supremely useful. It's my day job.
- jacobolus 11y agoI suspect you still aren’t understanding what Hestenes means about coordinate-free approaches to problems and why he calls coordinates a “math virus” (cf. http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/pdf/MathViruses.pdf http://geocalc.clas.asu.edu/pdf/MathViruses.pdf). Again, I’d highly recommend you study his work in detail. Also note: > Let there be no mistake about the nature of the coordinate virus. There is nothing wrong with using coordinates when they are appropriate. It is the insidious idea that coordinates are somehow more fundamental or concrete than other mathematical objects that limit conceptual capacity.
- jessriedel 11y agoAgain you have not actually addressed my comment.
- jacobolus 11y agoBasically, I think you aren’t going to understand what Hestenes is talking about until you engage with his work more directly than just this short summary. Me trying to explain to you all of his ideas about solving physics problems is not going to be a worthwhile use of either of our time. If you want to understand that, you should read his books and papers, try to solve the problems therein, apply those tools and approaches to your own problems, etc. Reading a few paragraphs on an internet forum is not going to make these ideas sink in. You said: > it sure sounds like he's talking about teaching vectors as geometric objects with various manipulation rules and avoiding coordinate descriptions. [...] This is actually the sort of angle that [...] is not [possible] for physicists. [... For] physics, it is absolute essential that you are also able to think about vectors in terms of coordinates if you are to connect them to the real physical world, which has rulers and T-squares and so on. Physicists are trying to understand the world, not the abstraction. The laws of the “real physical world” are absolutely not defined by T-squares or rulers. Those are imperfect measurement devices which we use to help us learn approximate relationships between things in the world and some human-defined standard measurement, but there is nothing fundamental about rulers. The fundamental thing is the structural/spatial relationships between objects which are directly interacting in whatever system we care about, not the tick marks on some stick which were drawn by a machine based on other tick marks drawn on some arbitrary global reference stick. In any event, it is obvious that Hestenes doesn’t want to abolish measurement devices or ban the use of coordinates. You’re basically arguing with a straw man. If you really want to get Hestenes’s answer to your comments, I suggest emailing him directly, instead of trying to get some strangers on Hacker News to stand in as proxies. I suspect he’ll be willing to at least point you at other sources to read, even if he doesn’t answer in detail. > In my teaching experience as a graduate student, students adopt the geometric picture of a vector as soon as they are able to, because it's vastly easier and more pleasant to work with. (That's why the abstraction was originally developed.) The geometric picture of a vector is the vector, and insofar as it’s “an abstraction” it is because the concept of a vector is itself the abstraction in question. The geometrical properties and relations of vectors are the fundamental nature of vectors. If students “struggle to build the proper abstract machinery in their brains”, what that means is they haven’t actually learned or properly been taught what a vector is yet. Many many scientists I have met, and especially many engineers, when confronted with a problem, immediately start reaching for measurement devices and coordinate systems. This is an approach to problem solving which is inherently limiting, sometimes severely limiting.