4 ms·
Leopards (or jaguars) are complex 3-dimensional shapes with quite a lot of degrees of freedom (considering all the body parts that can move independently). Thes
by Mz 11y ago
Leopards (or jaguars) are complex 3-dimensional shapes with quite a lot of degrees of freedom (considering all the body parts that can move independently). These shapes can produce a lot of different 2d contours
My son keeps telling me that infants are fine with, say, a truck transforming into a clown (when it emerges from the other side of a visual barrier) but not with it transforming into TWO of something. Apparently, babies subjectively experience this (visual transformation) all the time -- mom moves a plate and what seemed like a big circle is now a flat line or whatever.
So humans apparently get tons and tons of experience with visually mapping 3d reality to mere 2d imagery. I have been thinking somewhat about this of late, in terms of physical attractiveness or "image" -- that pictures of a woman posted on a blog capture a 2d version of her but people interacting with her are interacting with a 3d living, moving creature who also has smell and a voice and her movements may be elegant or may be not elegant. Which is a thought process relevant to a project of mine, something people here surely will have no interest in. But where it is relevant to this article is that we are doing this wrong: Humans have thousands of hours of practice of looking at 3d reality and figuring out how it to interpret 2d images as representative of that 3d reality. Image recognition software is just dealing with 2d images. I don't see how it can hope to compete. Humans don't come preinstalled with the software to make that distinction. We acquire it with enormous repetition.
When do we make a robot and give it some baseline parameters and a learning algorithm (and set it loose in 3d reality and have to learn)? That is when we can get scared about human like AI that can compete on image recognition.
- etangent 11y agoIndeed, arguments like "My mother didn't have to purchase 30,000 mugs to teach me what one looks like" miss the fact that we humans spent so much time (almost all of our waking time in fact) interpreting 3D reality, an endless stream of repetitive tasks.
- hayd 11y ago> but not with it transforming into TWO of something I suppose that's why Banach–Tarski is considered a paradox.