3 ms·
> just like tractors made 90% of farmers permanently unemployed and they decided to take early retirement and spend time on the beach Early retirement wasn't a
by falcolas 11y ago
> just like tractors made 90% of farmers permanently unemployed and they decided to take early retirement and spend time on the beach
Early retirement wasn't an option for those farmers - they had to find a way to support themselves or their families. As a result they took up desk jobs (many of which are, in the broader view of things unnecessary) in the city. When those desk jobs go away, where will they go next? Into manual labor? That's pretty ripe for automation as well.
- ekianjo 11y ago> When those desk jobs go away, where will they go next? Into manual labor? That's pretty ripe for automation as well. The service industry is not going to be replaced by robots anytime soon. Many jobs wont even be replaced because robots wont be economical enough to do so (hairdressers robots anyone?). And the more you have robots out there, the more you will need maintenance people, industries to manufacture robots, and the whole lot of engineering that goes with it. Because, like it or not, we have not discovered a way to do super smart robots than can design themselves just yet. And just like farmers got more education in order to do desk jobs, the ones at the lower end who get more educated to do the jobs that are needed, because you know, the job market is dynamic.
- falcolas 11y ago> The service industry is not going to be replaced by robots anytime soon. Funny, the use of iPads instead of servers at many fast food restaurants was one of the examples I was considering using. Hair dresser robots for many people aren't that far out. > we have not discovered a way to do super smart robots than can design themselves just yet. Key word there: yet. What do we do when that yet comes to pass? > the job market is dynamic Do you believe the job market will continue to provide jobs when it's not profitable to? When a company has to make the choice between a machine and a human, why would it ever go with the human, when the net cost of the machine is lower than that of the human? One machine can replace a minimum of three people (working 24 hours on a job your average worker does 8 hours on), and it won't take three people per machine to maintain them. Of course, the human could always offer their services at a cost below that of the robot - but I don't believe that is sustainable for the human. As an example, for me to be more economical than a computer for my employeer, I would have to methodically classify over 2,500 tweets to earn a single dollar. And since my employer wants these classifications done in near real time, they'd have to employ most of the town I live in, just to do this one mostly-clerical task.
- Al-Khwarizmi 11y ago> And the more you have robots out there, the more you will need maintenance people, industries to manufacture robots, and the whole lot of engineering that goes with it. Because, like it or not, we have not discovered a way to do super smart robots than can design themselves just yet. This argument is often made, but the fact is that the amount of jobs created by robot manufacturing and maintenance will always be smaller than the amount of jobs replaced by robots... after all, if this weren't the case, robots wouldn't be used in the first place because they wouldn't be profitable!
- pharke 11y agoYou make it sound so peaceful and orderly and yet it was quite the opposite. Mechanization allowed farms to become more productive with fewer workers and in part led to the industrial revolution by creating a large labour pool that could be exploited by other industries both by eliminating existing jobs as well as by increasing the population. That process resulted in a loss of livelihood for a large portion of the population. The transition was largely to other forms of manual labour, mostly in manufacturing. This didn't happen smoothly, a notable example being the Swing Riots[1] in Britain. To support your point, if we suffer a similar disruption in employment where the largest occupations start an irreversible downward trend, what sector is going to take up this burden? If you look at the statistics for the current largest employers[2] you'll see a list of jobs where automation has already made significant inroads. To name the three largest: * Retail salesperson * Cashiers * Food preparation and service workers I doubt that the other large employers on the list could absorb these workers. We just don't have that other large employer to take up the slack as when manufacturing absorbed and made use of former farm labourers. We also don't have the frontier of a new world to provide a second start for families seeking a better future. We've managed to paint ourselves into a corner with our current system and we can either sit here and suffer or bite the bullet and start over. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swing_Riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swing_Riots [2] http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/area_emp_chart/area_emp_chart.htm http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/area_emp_chart/area_emp_chart...