4 ms·
Most interesting possibility: there will be an inflection point in the way we do production & distribution. The capital costs and inefficiencies of distributed
by jjoonathan 11y ago
Most interesting possibility: there will be an inflection point in the way we do production & distribution. The capital costs and inefficiencies of distributed production fall every day (internet to distribute knowledge, ever-advancing low-N fabrication technology) while the disadvantages of centralized production increase (capital is becoming more important, labor less important, meaning the average split of the proceeds is ever more extractive). At some point people on the bottom rungs will find it advantageous to work for "communes" instead of employers. Scare quotes because there's a lot of back-to-nature & peacenik baggage associated with the word "commune" that doesn't necessarily apply here -- it's just a different structure for production and employment that avoids the deleveraging effects of forcing people to compete for a spot in a shrinking global pool of jobs. The communes I'm picturing would make heavy use of industrial technology and compete against one another for people by advertising the benefits they offer vs the labor required for membership.
Less disruptive: mandatory reduction in workweek to restore supply/demand balance in unskilled labor market.
Costly but traditional: Basic/minimum income. Expansion of traditional welfare programs. Society creaks along having found the minimum handout required to keep people from doing something about the problem.
Cynical: civic unrest, police crackdown, rinse, repeat, spiral out of control. We've all seen the movies.
- bsbechtel 11y agoThere are lots of unknowns left in this world, and lots of exploring left to do. Space, curing disease, and finding additional sources of clean water and energy are all areas that require lots of work and human ingenuity. The challenge is getting people educated to do work in these fields and allocating capital properly. The unskilled labor market was known as the illiterate labor market 100 years ago, and we overcame that challenge, lifting those people up and educating them on how to read. The same can be done again, we just need to figure out how to do so.
- jjoonathan 11y agoYes, there are undiscovered future uses for labor and the capital/labor imbalance could be alleviated (or exacerbated) by discovering them. It is still utterly absurd to bind the wellbeing of our society to a gamble on the rate of discovery and the extent of these untapped resources.
- bsbechtel 11y agoMy point was more we should look to re-allocate resources, financial and human, to discovery producing activities in the future, i.e. R&D, thus employing, educating, and empowering people, regardless of the actual rate of discovery per person/dollar invested in R&D.
- jjoonathan 11y agoI completely agree that this would be the best approach in terms of long-term value generation. If I were emperor for a day it's how I would tackle the problem. I just don't see any realistic way to make this vision a reality (other than conquering the world, of course) so I don't focus on it.
- SixSigma 11y agoWe have a similar idea to those communes already, they are called "businesses".
- jjoonathan 11y agoDoes the business you work for produce the goods and services you consume, or at least the goods and services you need to survive? Does the business you work for have a recipe for turning unskilled labor into the goods & services required for those people to lead a similarly comfortable life? If so, that's good news, because it means that your business is in a position to alleviate the economic nightmare scenario we are all worrying about. FWIW I agree that the "communes of the future" will be businesses, but I disagree that the businesses of the present are the same as the proposed communes of the future. Current businesses are specialized and have customers different from their employees. "Commune" businesses would be relatively generalized and have employees as their primary customers. It's a substantially different structure and, I believe, one that provides considerably fewer opportunities to reliably deleverage large chunks of the human population.
- SixSigma 11y agoOnce you've re-run history, you'll discover trade.
- jjoonathan 11y agoYou haven't put as much thought into this as you seem to think you have; you are still retracing the first 5% of my thought process on this topic. The point isn't to eliminate trade, markets, capitalism, or even jobs. Just the opposite, I would imagine. The point is that a hypothetical "extremistan" future in which most people struggle to eek out a living presents a business opportunity which has historically failed to take off due to the limits of manufacturing technology. If someone can make this business opportunity work, it will act as a relief valve to alleviate extreme poverty.
- alphapapa 11y ago> "Commune" businesses would be relatively generalized and have employees as their primary customers. Aren't those called "communities", i.e. towns and cities? More specifically, ones before the advent of railroads and cars, where trade was geographically limited to the immediate surroundings. Except in your "commune" version, everyone in the town works for the mayor, and they have to apply for membership before they can move in. Sounds like some form of distributed communism.