3 ms·
> I wonder what the reasoning was behind giving people a supplied point. I guess they wanted to know the shape people guessed, rather than the levels people gue
by alkonaut 11y ago
> I wonder what the reasoning was behind giving people a supplied point. I guess they wanted to know the shape people guessed, rather than the levels people guessed? Or set people's expectations, so that they don't have wild expectations about the percentage of the population that attends college?
Exactly. They essentially fix the "m" in the y = k*x + m equation, and let people guess only k. That is, you factor out a lot of the guesswork about how many actually attend higher education and let the question focus on how it varies with income. When you ask people for a guess it's much easier to average a scalar value than a tuple. Clever, if you ask me.
- logicallee 11y agoYes, but anyone who has information about their immediate percentile-neighbors (but nobody else) now 2 data points (their own income-part of society and the supplied data point) and so unless they're around the 50th percentile themselves you have supplied them with a ton of information. I think it would have been far more instructive not to include that data point: people's guesses also would have been more revealing (the last, aggregate-guesses graph on the results page). (Especially since we can have a good idea about who the guessers are - readers of the NY Times who choose to complete this specific graph exercise.)