4 ms·
Mozilla Bug 77790: Style the scrollbar
- Zekio 11y agopersonally i would rather they made the scroll bar like in IE, Where it doesn't push content, but it is on top of it so whole page doesn't get pushed slightly if it appear dynamically.
- mschuster91 11y agoYeah but that would break backwards compatibility because people do their CSS with this in mind.
- Zekio 11y agoi can't see how it would break backwards compatibility?
- orivej 11y agoThere is a number of user styles (installable with Stylish [1]) that replace default scroll bars with floating ones. I find this [2] particularly nice. [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/stylish/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/stylish/ [2] https://userstyles.org/styles/83431/minimal-floating-scrollbars-for-firefox-windows https://userstyles.org/styles/83431/minimal-floating-scrollb...
- Zekio 11y agoI had no idea people had made that, for that addon, thanks! so downloading that addon
- lewisl9029 11y agoI've been using this for a while in Firefox. These kinds of floating scroll bars really should be the default for all OSes. Presence of scroll bars changing the width of the window contents and causing repaints/reflows is really poor UX in my humble opinion.
- evanm 11y agoA pre-9/11 ticket.
- knodi123 11y agoAh yes, 'twas a simpler time.
- Narretz 11y agoStylable scroll bars are definitely a slippery slope. Once you allow it, you are possibly opening the gate for really bad scroll bars that pervert an essential ui of browsers. On the other hand, lots of people demand custom scroll bars, which leads to shitty scroll experiences because every js implementation is bound to perform badly in one scenario ot another.
- Zekio 11y agothere will always be bad scroll bars or confusing websites, people will just stop using those sites, but that shouldn't prevent people who make a nice scroll bar from doing so.
- nfoz 11y agoPeople don't have much choice over what websites they access. People rely on websites, and basically every webpage provides different utility, so we're all stuck with what the designer published. Very many designers are bad, due in large part to the complexity of the web.
- Zekio 11y agoTrue, but most browsers beside IE already support this, and people should be getting used to different kinds of scroll bars, from various apps to programs which doesn't use the system scroll bar.
- nfoz 11y agoWhy should people be getting used to different UIs for different things? Why shouldn't we consolidate, so that there is a single consistent UI? It's not very easy, for example, for the elderly, and persons with some types of disability, to get used to things changing all the time, and having a different mental context for the controls of one site/application vs another.
- Zekio 11y ago
- jstsch 11y agoNo, you shouldn't style your scrollbars when they are part of the browser chrome and simply scroll a page. Yes, you should be able to style your scrollbars when they're part of your website/application. Those JS solutions out there are quite sucky. Oh, hey, sorry, we just broke scrolling down using your spacebar.
- geonic 11y agoFunny to see how the original bug reporter (Skewer) hung around for about 18 months before other people continued the discussion for the past 13 years. I wonder where Skewer is today and what he thinks about the feature.