3 ms·
Point by point - A private passport service that nobody accepts is no more valuable that the group of people that trust the people doing the verification which
by michaelmrose 11y ago
Point by point
- A private passport service that nobody accepts is no more valuable that the group of people that trust the people doing the verification which as of now is zero. In fact since nations are the arbiters of identity within their border there is not much chance of this changing inside this decade.
- She admits she doesn't understand the technology at all just thinks it fits in with her super unrealistic libertarian ideas
- All governments are bad because they are all in debt! Governments and people budget differently you can't reason about a government as if it were a massive version of your family. This is economics 101.
- The blockchain will help us replace the nation state! The blockchain could provide the basis of a currency, distributed dns, identity etc I'm not seeing how distributed identification has anything to do with replacing centralized government or that that's even a good thing paying for just want you personally use and want is in fact an incredibly stupid idea.
The kinds of things you actually WANT government to take over are exactly the kind of things that the free market is bad at and precisely because it is bad at it. How much national defense do you want this year citizen!
- Getting fake married on the internet is so much safer! Of course because its not real. Real marriage implies legal and moral obligations. Those obligations are complex because peoples lives are complicated and include lots of complicating entanglements like money, shared obligations, houses, kids.
In fact if you acquire all those complicating factors you wont find your fake marriage much easier to extricate yourself from.
The more I read the more embarrassed I am for her.
- zabouti 11y agoBlockchain Girl and the HN commenters go on and on about the end of nation states, apparently imagining that they will be replaced by free individuals, being all libertarian and everything!!?? The word "corporation" is not used even once there or here!! At least michaelmrose is spot-on.
- mratzloff 11y agoI don't know what it is, but for some reason if the technology is sound, many technologists will entertain completely delusional, unworkable ideas because they focus on the technology (or the perceived efficiency gains to society, efficiency being something engineers are partial to) over the fact that in real life people are messy, simple solutions are usually naive, and things are frequently the way they are for a reason. Of course, the rest of society does this with things that they are partial to, most notably religion (some religious people overlook unworkable social plans by leaders who they perceive as religious). It's like as long as one part of the plan seems sound, they're willing to believe the rest of the plan, even if it's completely idiotic. There's got to be a psychological term for this.
- zo1 11y agoPerhaps the disconnect is simply not visible to you. You say that these individuals jump at the thought of "ideas" because they're simply linked to certain technological solutions/implementations. Yet, completely disregard the possibility that they may have other motives/reasons behind their beliefs, that you may not be privy to or simply deny as relevant. *Edit, more comments below. And, judging from the overall theme in the comment you're responding to. One of Libertarianism, I'll add: We don't all have the solutions, or all the perfect answers for a wonderful life and organization of the world. But these ideas are not "idiotic" anymore than what we have now, of which we all complain about incessantly. You'll often find that a lot of Libertarians/Anarcho-Capitalist have their beliefs not because of practicality, or technology, but because they believe in the ethical and moral principles that form part of those ideologies.
- darkr 11y ago> There's got to be a psychological term for this. Belief.