4 ms·
In terms of women and computer science, I've been curious if anyone had followed up on Fran Allen's (the first woman recipient of the Turing Award) claims in "C
by danso 11y ago
In terms of women and computer science, I've been curious if anyone had followed up on Fran Allen's (the first woman recipient of the Turing Award) claims in "Coders at Work" that she personally knew of women colleagues whose work was outright stolen:
http://www.codersatwork.com/fran-allen.html http://www.codersatwork.com/fran-allen.html
Peter Seibel. Coders at Work: Reflections of the Craft of Programming (Kindle Locations 6410-6419). Kindle Edition.
Seibel: You have been the first woman in many categories-first Turing Award winner, first IBM Fellow. Do you feel like there were women before you who were overlooked?
Allen: Oh, yes, absolutely. Seibel: So when you won the Turing, did you think to yourself, "Gee, there's another woman who should have won this a long time ago?"
Allen: Well, the very first thing I thought about was how wonderful it was. And then I started to think about all the many other women who were never recognized at all for their work. In many cases, their work was stolen. I thought about the women who had done some very amazing things that have not been recognized, even by their peers. When I approach them and say, "You need to join some professional organizations-I'll write some recommendations for you," they kind of shy away from that.
Seibel: So you think that part of the problem is they don't get recognized because they're not putting themselves in a place to be recognized as easily.
Allen: Right.
Seibel: Are there any particular folks that you would like to name-to give a little recognition now? Allen: Well, there's Edith Schonberg, who is a great computer scientist. In terms of technical work, it's just one first after another on some of her papers. She's had work stolen-absolutely brutally stolen. She wrote a paper on debugging of parallel code, which is a very hard problem. It was not accepted at a conference and somebody who had been on the program committee made three papers out of it. That kind of thing. It happens in our field and we don't have good ways of dealing with it.
Seibel: And it happens more to women?
Allen: Yes, I think it does. They were often viewed as not going to put up a fight-that they were more isolated and don't have the advocates who will deal with a famous thief. He was a famous thief, known but nobody dared touch it. And there are plenty of others way back from the Stretch days. There was a woman who essentially was the inventor of multiprogramming and credit was taken by somebody who eventually became a Turing Award winner.
- facepalm 11y agoI don't know who has this happen to them more often, but I know a lot of stories about theft among male scientists as well. And think about the whole system of PhD where students to the work and the supervisor gets the fame. Not convinced that this is not just a case of bad framing.
- danso 11y agoThis is absolutely valid; the motives and incentives for intellectual theft cross demographic boundaries (sex, race, age, religion, etc). It's possible (if it were possible to accurately count what is essentially uncountable) that the number of such incidents of men stealing from women is not statistically out of line compared to the overall number of incidents, and the ratio of men-to-women in the field. That said, I think Allen insinuates and believes that the current gender dynamic makes it harder for affected women to push back (which of course is another unquantifiable thing),
- facepalm 11y agoSure it's possible, but the problem is: we are all ready to believe it, in fact, downright jump on it. Because it fits into the general narrative (evil men, angelic women). I think it would be better to back such things up with research, rather than enforce stereotypes.
- facepalm 11y agoAddendum: if it's true that there are vastly more male scientists than female scientists, then it seems extremely likely that more work has been stolen from male scientists than from female scientists (odds per individual are of course unaffected). The same applies to promotions. For every story of a woman who was not promoted in IT, there are probably 20 untold stories of men who were not promoted in IT. Simply because much more men than women work in IT, and only few can be promoted. I just question the whole approach of arguing with anecdotes.
- tajen 11y agoConcerning promotions, we could restore the truth by adjusting the mesurement: Let's measure the "mean time to get promoted", which is the right indicator of the equality of chances. Needless to say that, in my 10-years of experience as a programmer, I've seen an average of 3 years for females and 6 years for males.
- jperras 11y ago> In terms of women and computer science, I've been curious if anyone had followed up on Fran Allen's (the first woman recipient of the Turing Award) claims in "Coders at Work" that she personally knew of women colleagues whose work was outright stolen What motivation would she have to lie about such a thing? Let's just assume that an award-winning brilliant computer scientist is telling the truth about something, especially when she stands to gain nothing and has the chance to lose quite a bit.
- danso 11y agoI wasn't accusing her of lying. I was asking if there was any follow up and/or consequences. She gives more than enough detail to identify the perpetrator, and so has this issue been openly confronted (it might have and I'm just not up to speed) and resolved? Has it been ignored? Or has it just not been publicized enough? Related to that question, and just as important, is the possibility that Allen is not lying -- but is telling what she knows and is pretty sure of (I suspect she doesn't trade on flimsy rumors)...but that doesn't mean that at the time of the interview, she knew everything about what went on. Stealing-of-credit is frequently very messy in the interpretation. And if the accused was publicly called out to defend himself, more facts may have come to light that affirm or contradict the accuser.