6 ms·
>> Previous studies have led researchers to believe that individuals with social anxiety disorder or social phobia have too low levels of the neurotransmitter s
by phkahler 11y ago
>> Previous studies have led researchers to believe that individuals with social anxiety disorder or social phobia have too low levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin. A new study, however, shows that the situation is exactly the opposite.
It's stuff like this that is destroying the reputation of science in general. I know it's one thing to "lead to believe" and another to "show that", and perhaps that's what happened here. But every time the accepted explanation does a 180 science dies a little bit. I don't mean the big changes like relativity, but the blatant reversals. Fatty food is bad - no it's good. Carbs are great - no they're not. Drugs pulled from the market that had been "tested".
I think a lot of cases are not really reversals, but misunderstandings or incorrect interpretations of results that later get clarified. Not sure what the answer is.
- sjtrny 11y agoDrugs are in a totally different category than peer reviewed articles. They go through rigorous testing that works the vast majority of the time to weed out unsuitable drugs. On the other hand peer review (having been through it a few times) is extremely sloppy and reviewers do not do due diligence. Often the reviewers can't even if they wanted to (no raw data released etc) and they have to blindly accept the authors claims. I don't think science dies a little bit each time a dissenting or contradictory result is published. In fact it is a good thing. We need more people to try and reproduce others work. But at the moment we have is a problem of scale. In other words it only looks bad when there are two different conclusions. We need many more reproductions to come to a clear answer.
- TallGuyShort 11y agoThe problem is that things go from being talked about as a statistical correlation with a probability of error, to being a "link", to being the thing people base their diets and other philosophies on. The anti-vaccine movement resulted in a lot of people touting science as the reason you should trust vaccines, conveniently ignoring the fact that it appears to have started from a phony scientific study. The fact that the phrase "a new study ... has found exactly the opposite" can be published by serious researchers is exactly why we shouldn't be going around proposing that people be legally forced to inject themselves with things because they're considered scientifically illiterate. As Scott Adams said in his piece on the subject, "Science isn’t about being right every time, or even most of the time. It is about being more right over time and fixing what it got wrong." [1] That should be kept in mind by people who are publishing, reporting on, and reading these studies. [1] http://blog.dilbert.com/post/109880240641/sciences-biggest-fail#ixzz3dWKWf6k5 http://blog.dilbert.com/post/109880240641/sciences-biggest-f...
- phkahler 11y agoIn the link he brings up the "fatty food makes you fat" thing. My memory is that fatty foods were shown to be bad for your heart back in the 1980's and I always wondered where the "makes you fat" part came from. It's almost like once something is labeled (fatty food = bad) people forget the why and substitute their own reasons. Similar stuff is going on now with saturated vs unsaturated fat. The problem is trans-fat which tends to form in the commercial process for saturating fat, and in the deep fryer. I don't recall any other research, but now there seems to be another "reversal" on saturated fat. Or is it unsaturated? IDK, but the public opinion is getting altered again.
- dragonwriter 11y agoReversals based on further evidence are part of science, inherently. Science shouldn't have a magical reputation, because it's not magic. Like all other means of explaining there material world, it's guesswork. There only difference is that science is guesswork with systematic effort to find holes in the guesses and improve them and reject there ones that don't work, while every other approach to explaining material phenomena had some form of guesswork and some method of closing which guesses to accept that is not based on what demonstrably works or fails.
- jgroszko 11y agoI think a lot of the harm comes from people treating science as some sort of monolithic entity. Science says X! Science says Y! When really it's more like some scientists over here have found some evidence for X, some over here did some work that points to Y. It's neat that mainstream enthusiasm for science has grown so much in the last few years, but it seems like a lot of times this kind of treatment oversimplifies things.
- eivarv 11y agoWhile mainstream enthusiasm for science has grown, scientific literacy and journalism, unfortunately, hasn't.
- platz 11y agoDon't forget the Science community itself is always shouting "Trust us, we're impartial scientists, don't ignore us!". Some scientists over here have found some evidence for X, and the media that cover their story, REALLY want you to believe their story. You can't treat the Science community as impartial here.
- biturd 11y agoIs any of this even solvable to the general mainstream public? They need to think in absolutes, as in, this medicine does x to fix, prevent, or repair y. That is how the general public measure things. In reality, an anti depressant for example, probably works out to something like: it works about 50% of the time, with a bit of a lean over 50%, but if we calculate in spontaneous remission, placebo effect, and some other variable, now it looks like it is either a net zero effect, or in many cases, like AA meetings, statistically detrimental. But the general public will need a binary answer. And I consider myself part of this general public, I just know there is more than meets the eye on anything, and in general I feel correlation and causation more often then not don't agree.
- Natsu 11y agoIt's a pretty simple fact that the more people who strongly trust a signal, the more value there is in mimicry of it. Because birds understand that Monarchs are poisonous, there's great value to the Viceroy in being a good mimic of it. So the more strongly people trust science, the more value there will be to con men in passing themselves off as scientists. We can mitigate that to some extent with scientific reputation and whatnot, but I don't think we have trust fully figured out in general, as there's always the bootstrapping problem.
- anthony_romeo 11y agoIt's a good thing that science can change. This is what distinguishes science from dogma. The problem is not these supposed 'reversals', but rather how this information is being reported. Pop-science media reports modest studies as absolute truths to catch eyeballs. When one study merely suggests research in one direction, it's emblazoned as fact on the tabloids. In the example you identified: "Fatty food is bad - no it's good" the issue is not the studies flip-flopping. Rather, it's a problem of regular people taking what are likely modest reports way too far and massively integrating them into their daily lives, without ever reading the study and understanding the context or scope of it. A study indicating that, say, there may be health problems associated with consuming excess saturated fat seems to compel people to follow no-fat diets. So I'd argue that the bigger problem is people reading oversimplified reports of scientific information I mean, I'm not terribly familiar with this field, but the study itself indicates that whether high or low serotonin levels were contributory was "a matter of debate" and that "only a few studies have used molecular neuroimaging to examine serotonin dysfunction in SAD directly."[1] So this doesn't appear to be a reversal at all, but rather a study which helps clarify the role of serotonin in SAD. [1] http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=2319711#yoi150011r5 http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=23197...
- primroot 11y ago> So I'd argue that the bigger problem is people reading oversimplified reports of scientific information. And what about the AHA[1] and other policy makers and shapers? What leads them to make recommendations based on weakly established conclusions? I think the pressure to deliver, and the lack of generalist knowledge are somehow involved here. In the case of food and drugs, I would also blame elitism. [1] http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/GettingHealthy/NutritionCenter/HealthyEating/The-American-Heart-Associations-Diet-and-Lifestyle-Recommendations_UCM_305855_Article.jsp http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/GettingHealthy/NutritionCenter...
- eivarv 11y agoI know nothing of the AHA's methods or qualifications, but in my view bad policies purportedly based upon science usually come from lack of these, in addition to lack of scientific literacy. Alternatively, from a predefined goal, i.e. a political agenda. I'm curious: in what way would you blame elitism in those cases?
- Rainymood 11y ago>But every time the accepted explanation does a 180 science dies a little bit So let's just keep the earth flat then, shall we ;) This is the beauty of science. If a report on memory that claims X and then another scientist is unable to replicate their results X, what can we say about the validity of X?
- primroot 11y agoIt would be the beauty of science if people referred to the weight of the evidence in more accurate language, and if policy makers didn't every now and then find excuses in weakly established conclusions.
- andrewtbham 11y agoI suspect the reason for the reversal is the accessibility of new tools, namely the PET scan. Whereas in the past, the results were probably based on polling people about their anxiety levels while on SSRIs.
- syntheticnature 11y agoEvery time something like this comes up I think of this: http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?n=1174 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?n=1174
- weland 11y agoI see a lot of positive reactions to how happy we should be that science changes. I mean, look how long it took us to get out of the dark ages, right? But no, the liberality of changes like this one is what separates fluff science from actual science. There is a vast chasm of difference between stuff like this one and, say, aether theories. People who came up with aether theories were the brightest of their ages. That is really the best they could come up with -- and the reason why it took us so long to disprove aether-based theories was that they had some bloody solid science behind them -- at least back in those ages. People were unable to come up with anything better because, for a very long time, they lacked both theoretical and experimental tools with which to conclusively prove (or disprove) their hypotheses. We needed significant developments in mathematics, fluid mechanics and optics in order to test these theories, and we needed special relativity to come up with something better. Whereas claims like the one this article refutes need only a correct application of double-blind testing and not falling into well-known (at least to statisticians) traps in order to be tested. The fact that we have 180 degree spins in understanding such matters every six months is not a testament to how modern science cares only about truth. It's a testament of how important it is to publish papers.
- lvs 11y agoThese aren't fully contradictory results. The paper is referring in serotonin in one brain structure, the amygdala. The article was wrong to cast such a broad stroke.
- DigitalJack 11y agoThat assumes the latest info from science is right. Maybe the earlier info was right, and this is the incorrect interpretation. Either way it does get frustrating though.
- astazangasta 11y agoPeople are asserting that these reversals are a normal part of science and therefore good. I think they are a normal part of science but reveal a huge flaw in the method: scientists frequently over extrapolate and end up drawing erroneous conclusions based on limited data. The widespread presence of basic methodological flaws in many scientific papers such as misunderstanding the meaning of p values means a lot of so-called science is built on faulty reasoning. This is worse than merely presenting a model that imperfectly represents the data, it is simply wrong: reaching conclusions that the data do not justify and never could. You see this most often with efforts to reduce complex systems down to the effect of single variables; such efforts are almost guaranteed to miss the point. The serotonin story is a good example. The notion that the complexity of human psychology that led to depression could be reduced to the activity level of a single neurotransmitter should strike us as an absurd exercise on its face. It's not even wrong, it's a basic misreading of the problem space.
- j_baker 11y agoI wouldn't treat this as a complete reversal just yet. These kinds of "paradigm changing" studies get shown to be flawed all the time. It's just that the press rarely reports when that happens.
- OldSchoolJohnny 11y agoMost of those things you mention were not based on any solid science in the first place if you look into them so no conundrum here.
- ta0967 11y ago>> Previous studies have led researchers to believe that individuals with social anxiety disorder or social phobia have too low levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin. A new study, however, shows that the situation is exactly the opposite. > It's stuff like this that is destroying the reputation of science in general. the actual paper contains no such language of course, let me quote the introduction: > Anxiety disorders are debilitating psychiatric conditions that impose a considerable burden on patients1 and society,2 and social anxiety disorder (SAD) is one of the most common of these conditions.3 The neural underpinnings of excessive social anxiety are not fully characterized, although serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine) has been suggested to be involved etiologically.4,5 > However, only a few studies have used molecular neuroimaging to examine serotonin dysfunction in SAD directly. A single-photon emission tomography study6 found increased serotonin transporter availability in the thalamus, but not in the raphe nuclei, in patients with SAD relative to healthy control individuals. Also, a positron emission tomography (PET) study7 showed that SAD is associated with reduced serotonin 1A receptor binding. Somatodendritic serotonin 1A autoreceptors in the raphe nuclei, which inhibit serotonin synthesis and release,8 and postsynaptic serotonin 1A heteroreceptors, which convey inhibitory signals in the amygdala, anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and insula cortex, were downregulated.7 In addition, functional neuroimaging studies of SAD9 have demonstrated heightened, fear-induced neural reactivity in the amygdala, which is densely innervated by serotonin,10 with alterations in the hippocampus, ACC, insula cortex, and striatum.9,11 Moreover, the first line of pharmacologic treatment for SAD consists of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs),12- 14 which reduce excessive amygdala reactivity, restore initially suppressed ventromedial prefrontal cortex response to emotional challenge,15- 18 and attenuate resting brain perfusion in the ACC and insula.19 Thus, findings from molecular and functional neuroimaging and treatment studies indicate that serotonergic neurotransmission in the amygdala, raphe nuclei, striatum, thalamus, hippocampus, insula cortex, and ACC may be compromised in SAD. > Given the inhibitory role of serotonin 1A autoreceptors on serotonin synthesis,8 previous findings of decreased autoreceptor binding in SAD7 may indicate increased serotonin formation and enhanced serotonergic activity. On the other hand, because blocking the serotonin reuptake with SSRIs attenuates social anxiety symptoms12,13 and because posttreatment dietary depletion of the serotonin precursor tryptophan reverses the anxiolytic effects of SSRIs,20 the notion that increased serotonin availability is pivotal for anxiety reduction also has support. Indeed, whether anxiety conditions such as SAD are best characterized by serotonin overactivity or underactivity remains a matter of debate.5