5 ms·
Women whom science forgot
- facepalm 11y agoI think those articles are silly. If you ask random people on the street, they usually won't be able to name a lot of scientists. So male and female scientists tend to be forgotten. Also, I'm sure Marie Curie would also be in the list of the unforgotten ones - the research they did was a Google search??? Einstein is famous not only for his physics, but also because of the circumstances, overthrowing the whole established world of physics, all the while not even getting tenure in academia but working in the patent office instead. Darwin, Newton - sorry, most female scientists are not Darwins or Newtons, and neither are most male scientists. And a lot of the supposedly forgotten women actually received Nobel prices, had chemical elements named after them, became first female professors in their subject and what not. Edit: I was too lazy this time, but last time that sort of meme spread through the networks I made the effort to go to Wikipedia. I think I remember Lise Meitner - she is the one who has a chemical element named after her. Hardly "forgotten", only few people get that honor. Apparently the decision was made to leave her out of the Nobel prize to protect her against the Nazis. A decision that led to much debate over the years - but hardly the "she was forgotten and deprived of her achievements because she was a woman" that this feminist narrative wants to make out of it. If you read her Wikipedia page, she received all sorts of honors (I couldn't find the reference to the Nobel/Nazi issue, but I only skimmed it right now). Maybe Rosalind Franklin wasn't included in the Nobel prize because only living people get the Nobel?
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI have to agree. All the talk about STEM eating the world in mind, the fact remains that the vast majority of scientists, no matter how well distinguished, are not celebrities.
- hga 11y agoThey are. Like many other people including Robert Oppenheimer, Rosalind Franklin died before she might have gotten a Nobel. Only 5-6 years after the research, 4 years before the prize was given for it; and looking at the details, I think this is particularly silly because by definition she had all the data and nonetheless failed to deduce the structure ... and she had a lot of company, including the 20th Century's preeminent chemist, Linus Pauling, who proposed a bizarre 3 strand structure. The case of Lise Meitner is particularly silly, because she would get at best equal billing with her nephew Otto Frisch; they were together in Sweden on Christmas vacation when Meitner's radiochemistry colleague Otto Hahn sent the startling data to her first, even before any of the physicists in his (Nazi) German chemistry institute (a truly prejudicial action indeed!). Together they figured out the likely mechanism and energetics (how the electrostatic force of all those protons could overpower the strong nuclear force), and Frisch was then was able to do some confirming experiments when he got back to Bohr's lab in Denmark (Meitner was not in a position to do that, her Austrian citizenship allowed her to stay in Germany until the Anschluss 1938, by which time there weren't many physics positions left in the world and she had to settle for a poor one in Sweden). And leaving both these Jewish physicists out of the 1944 Nobel Prize for Chemistry also protected Otto Hahn; Meitner was in potential danger in neutral Sweden, Frisch not so much having gone to work in the US on the Manhattan project. I don't know how many physicists have won Nobel Chemistry prizes for physics, and I suspect Hahn's radiochemisty work was significantly more notable than Meitner and Frisch's. Per Rhodes in The Making of the Atomic Bomb, Hahn was manipulating just a few thousand atoms at a time in his work (!!!), and was of course willing to believe his data, no matter how far out from what everyone believe about the nucleus. Whereas Meitner and Frisch's greatest advantage was being the first physicists to get Hahn's data; but, that said, they did make sense of it, per Rhodes while on a walk out in the snow (Meitner was pretty amazing in having all the needed physical data in her head, then again there's a reason we have so much respect for the physicists of the first half of the 20th Century :-).
- danso 11y agoIn terms of women and computer science, I've been curious if anyone had followed up on Fran Allen's (the first woman recipient of the Turing Award) claims in "Coders at Work" that she personally knew of women colleagues whose work was outright stolen: http://www.codersatwork.com/fran-allen.html http://www.codersatwork.com/fran-allen.html Peter Seibel. Coders at Work: Reflections of the Craft of Programming (Kindle Locations 6410-6419). Kindle Edition. Seibel: You have been the first woman in many categories-first Turing Award winner, first IBM Fellow. Do you feel like there were women before you who were overlooked? Allen: Oh, yes, absolutely. Seibel: So when you won the Turing, did you think to yourself, "Gee, there's another woman who should have won this a long time ago?" Allen: Well, the very first thing I thought about was how wonderful it was. And then I started to think about all the many other women who were never recognized at all for their work. In many cases, their work was stolen. I thought about the women who had done some very amazing things that have not been recognized, even by their peers. When I approach them and say, "You need to join some professional organizations-I'll write some recommendations for you," they kind of shy away from that. Seibel: So you think that part of the problem is they don't get recognized because they're not putting themselves in a place to be recognized as easily. Allen: Right. Seibel: Are there any particular folks that you would like to name-to give a little recognition now? Allen: Well, there's Edith Schonberg, who is a great computer scientist. In terms of technical work, it's just one first after another on some of her papers. She's had work stolen-absolutely brutally stolen. She wrote a paper on debugging of parallel code, which is a very hard problem. It was not accepted at a conference and somebody who had been on the program committee made three papers out of it. That kind of thing. It happens in our field and we don't have good ways of dealing with it. Seibel: And it happens more to women? Allen: Yes, I think it does. They were often viewed as not going to put up a fight-that they were more isolated and don't have the advocates who will deal with a famous thief. He was a famous thief, known but nobody dared touch it. And there are plenty of others way back from the Stretch days. There was a woman who essentially was the inventor of multiprogramming and credit was taken by somebody who eventually became a Turing Award winner.
- facepalm 11y agoI don't know who has this happen to them more often, but I know a lot of stories about theft among male scientists as well. And think about the whole system of PhD where students to the work and the supervisor gets the fame. Not convinced that this is not just a case of bad framing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yes_or_gnome 11y agoThe Skeptic's Guide podcast has started a segment called 'Forgotten Superheros of Science'. The first episode with the segment is #496 (http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//496 http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//496), the 'superheros' are often female. There's a couple reasons for that, the minor reason being the show's only female host, Rebecca Watson, left the show at the end of last year. But, show host Steven Novella has repeated this same narrative (as is made in the article) over the years. They have covered a few of the women mentioned in this article. Rosalind Franklin: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//498 http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//498 Lise Meitner and ;Ida Tacke: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//510 http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//510 Chien-Shiung Hu: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//518 http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu//518 Full Archive: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu http://www.theskepticsguide.org/podcast/sgu I apologize for the plug, but it feels relevant.
- pimlottc 11y agoA very brief humorous version of Rosalind Franklin's story on "Hark! A Vagrant": http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=240 http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=240
- astazangasta 11y agoLet's add Grace Hopper, who created the first compiler and the first human-readable programming language (COBOL). Doesn't get more huge than that.
- hga 11y agoLet's not get carried away, Autocodes with compilers for the Mark 1 well precede her FLOW-MATIC for the UNIVAC I, which precedes COBOL. A lot of this depended on computer access, this is back in the days before core memory, when a several thousand vacuum tubes were used for the CPU, and before core memory was generally available. The Mark 1 initially had 5120 bits of main memory using CRTs, the UNIVAC I used mercury delay lines, 1,000 words of 12 characters.
- facepalm 11y agoAnd an article about here is being pushed through HN and social media every two weeks. Hardly forgotten.
- hoopd 11y agoLet's just pick one of these at random and peak into it, Ida Tack discovering Technetium. She was one woman on a team with two men who did an unreproducible experiment that "discovered" Technetium[0]. To this day the experiment hasn't been reproduced. Maybe they did find it, but if nobody else could make their experiment work that's just how it goes. Science can't start giving credit to people for unreproducible experiments just because they're women. > It was she who managed to find two new elements, rhenium and masurium, that Dmitri Mendeleev had predicted would form part of the periodic table. She was on a team! The author is doing to Tack's male teammates the exact thing he claims to believe is wrong, which is to leave people out because of their sex. The fact that she was on a team with two men, and that a male was the top author on their paper makes sexism very unlikely. If her co-authors got credit and she didn't that would be one thing, but none of them got credit. The whole article is filled with women who did things that wouldn't have made them famous if they were men. The cases that may have merit, and I'm sure there are some, are more difficult to take seriously because the level of bias of the author. [0] -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technetium#Unreproducible_results https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technetium#Unreproducible_resu...
- arcanus 11y agoI'm saddened to see no mention here of Vera Rubin: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vera_Rubin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vera_Rubin I've heard several male scientists in cosmology suggest that Rubin either discovered or was instrumental in the discovery of dark matter. This was a profound and fascinating experimental result: galaxies contain much more mass than can be accounted for by observable matter. The implication is that the observable (baryonic) matter in the universe is only a small fraction of the actual mass content. This is remains an unsolved problem in cosmology. I know that even today the LHC is running at higher energies in part due to an is interested in explaining dark matter through the generation of WIMPs and other massive particles. So this remains a very interesting question in physics. Despite her thought providing result, she is not a well known scientist.
- hoopd 11y agoYou're saddened? Why? As you say Rubin gets appropriate credit for her work within her field. Plus she doesn't even believe in Dark Matter, she made a very important contribution but now she's working on a competing theory that few care about. Nobody knows who Kent Ford is, he co-authored Rubin's big paper. What about Jan Oort? He came up with the idea of Dark Matter in the 1930's and some say found the first evidence for it. What about Fritz Zwicky? Some say he's the one who found the first evidence and is the one really being left out of history.[0] We're being taught to feel bad for women in science in situations where we don't feel bad for men. Science is full of forgotten men who made massive contributions to the world, this is about picking the woman and figuring out how to mythologize her. [0] - http://discovermagazine.com/2009/jan/30-the-father-of-dark-matter-still-gets-no-respect http://discovermagazine.com/2009/jan/30-the-father-of-dark-m...
- eveningcoffee 11y ago"The Nobel laureate Sir Tim Hunt was heavily criticised for his disparaging remarks about women in science last week, which for some raised the issue of where women stood in the scientific community." I think that this is a welcomed article but this kind of defamation should stop. When bunch of people misinterpret and overreact does not mean that something is actually truth. Anyway, these kind of articles (without quoted part) are a must read list for women who think that "only men have made big discoveries".