4 ms·
1. It wasn’t a description of IMAX, it was a description of something else by comparing it with IMAX. It was not describing IMAX. 2. It was someone else who w
by teddyh 11y ago
1. It wasn’t a description of IMAX, it was a description of something else by comparing it with IMAX. It was not describing IMAX.
2. It was someone else who was describing something and likened this other thing to IMAX. Ars was quoting this person, not writing it themselves.
Don’t drag out the “confusion with consumers” thing – absolutely no-one would think that this thing actually was an IMAX™ – it was a comparison. Would I be sued by Coca-Cola if I said that “Pepsi is kind of like Coca-Cola”? Would I cause “confusion with consumers”? No. Trademark law does not mean that trademark owners can control every use of the word, despite what they (and apparently you) would wish for.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoThe point, of course, isn't that they would think it was literally an IMAX. I'm not sure why you're arguing against that, frankly. But that consumers could think it was IMAX certified or some such. That sort of thing is worth defending.
- Bud 11y agoConsumers could also think it was certified by the Mayo Clinic and made of unicorns. This is approximately as likely. Making the leap from what was written in the article to "IMAX certified" is a hilariously wide leap. It's about two orders of magnitude too wide to justify the threat letter from IMAX.