3 ms·
I was employee #4,256 (sequential badge numbers!) at a major Japanese megacorp and didn't get a contract until well after I had passed the point of no return on
by patio11 17y ago
I was employee #4,256 (sequential badge numbers!) at a major Japanese megacorp and didn't get a contract until well after I had passed the point of no return on the job offer. Not having a contract yet is bad only to the extent that you believe it to bad. (Americans are taught that paper is magic, but it is merely one dispute resolution tool among many, including exercising persuasion, social ties, and reputational capital.)
Run the math on whether the difference between the bonus and the equity matters to you. If it does, time to negotiate. Simply say "I took this job in consideration of the fact that you offered me a package with X, Y, Z, and 1% equity. Your letter indicates that 1% equity may be infeasible for legal reasons. I think we can come to a mutually beneficial resolution which compensates me adequately and addresses your concerns. The sale bonus you have proposed doesn't quite get us there. What else can you offer me?" (Feel free to give suggestions, but talk topics, not numbers. First rule of negotiation: the first guy to give a number loses. Which is good news for you, because you have already heard one number. I can guarantee you, you won't get any worse than that!)
- wlievens 17y ago"First rule of negotiation: the first guy to give a number loses" It is not possible to stress this enough. People should print this out in 72pt font size and hang it over their bed.
- dmfdmf 17y agoIts a good rule but not always true. It depends on what price is being negotiated, e.g. salary, car price, etc. If someone throws out a number that is clearly too high (seller) or obviously too low (buyer) just to get the ball rolling there is no loss in negotiating strength from that, both parties know they are still far apart so nothing has changed. Also, vague numbers like "around $60K" are less committal, express common ground and more likely to be attempts to get the ball rolling. Another important rule is do not negotiate with your self. In other words, if you made an offer don't raise it until the other guy makes a counter offer. This is negotiation 101 but its very easy to get pressured to raise your offer without a counter offer. As for salary negotiations, I read an article once that a company's first solid offer (which is their low starting point) is somewhere around %20 below what the company is actually willing to pay you. So add 25% to the company's first offer and if that number is not near what you think you are worth you need to find someone else to work for or reevaluate the market value of your skills.
- deyan 17y agoAs a matter of fact this is incorrect. There is a ton of research to suggest that whoever makes the first step and proposes and initial scenario, comes out with a better outcome. That is because the first number thrown out frames the discussion. Of course, it doesn't have to be a number, it could be a negotiation for something else, but the rule and research apply just as well.
- patio11 17y agoThere is some research by behavioral economists about price anchoring. Like most research in behavioral economics, it is very useful at predicting the behavior of college students in novel circumstances. Many of the rest of us will have considered our likely market value prior to arriving at the salary negotiation, perhaps via extensive research or receiving competing offers, and thus not be unduly influenced by the first number we hear. ("$20,000? Holy cow! That's more money than I've ever had in my whole life! I'll take it!" -- not what I said in response to what my professor thought I would consider a very tempting offer.)
- run4yourlives 17y agoNegotiation with people like you is easy. Because you are so fixed on that first number, I simply pad my desired number and throw out that right away. Now you feel like you won because you talked me down from my already inflated number, and I feel the same because I knew it was inflated anyway. Reality is I got exactly what I wanted.
- wlievens 17y agoMaybe you're right, in which case I still have a lot to learn.
- dmfdmf 17y agoThe strategy of "what else can you offer me?" is a good one. Present the problem and let them answer the question. Be ready in your mind with what you are willing to accept but you might be surprised when their offer is a high multiple of what you were thinking. Just keep quiet and nod when that happens.
- patio11 17y agoJust keep quiet and nod when that happens. I would take a second of silence, mentally repeat to myself "We are all businessmen here. What I am about to do is morally and socially acceptable. I need feel no shame about it.", and ask for more $WHATEVER. What is the worst thing that happens? They say no, we suffer 2 seconds of awkwardness, and I get the offer they just made me. Or they say yes, and I probably just bought myself a month's salary (and 3~5% compounding on it for every year of employment) for 5 seconds of work.
- dmfdmf 17y agoAgree. I was thinking more along the lines of don't tip your hand and let the guy lay it all out. If company rep is laying out plan A,B,C and you get all excited at B, he might drop and never mention C. Also, as you say you could even press for more and should consider that your estimate of your value to the company needs to be revised.