3 ms·
I submitted this because I personally think the situation is more complicated than that. I tend to agree with the notion that people shouldn't be run out of pr
by smacktoward 11y ago
I submitted this because I personally think the situation is more complicated than that.
I tend to agree with the notion that people shouldn't be run out of projects (or organizations, or jobs) just because of their private beliefs, even when those beliefs offend me. It's too easy to imagine the mechanism that ran them out of town being turned around to run me out of town, should my beliefs fall out of fashion.
But as you note, there is a line where private beliefs stop being private and start being public. You put the line here:
> as long as he doesn't try to advertise that from within the project code, forums etc.
... but the developer in question was publishing the opinions in question on Twitter, which isn't exactly a private space. If you say something on Twitter, you are saying it in public. If you are a high-profile member of a project, the fact that the space doesn't have the project logo on it doesn't necessarily mean people aren't going to look at what you say and connect it back to the project. And it doesn't strike me as implausible that, if you're one of those developers and what you're saying is offensive to a group of people, those people are going to assume that the project you're the face of isn't a space where their contributions would be welcome. And that's going to hurt contribution to the project.
So I'm of two minds on this particular case, I guess. Which isn't very helpful, but does make it a question that I think could benefit from wider discussion. We as a culture have to hash out exactly where in these new online spaces we've created these new lines are appropriately drawn.
- coldtea 11y ago>... but the developer in question was publishing the opinions in question on Twitter, which isn't exactly a private space. That's still OK with me. Twitter might not be a private space, but his opinion is his own to broadcast in his Twitter stream. As long as he doesn't attribute this opinion to the project or anything. >If you are a high-profile member of a project, the fact that the space doesn't have the project logo on it doesn't necessarily mean people aren't going to look at what you say and connect it back to the project. Even if it means that, they shouldn't (connect what one person says with the project). What if it was his political or religious opinions? Shouldn't he be able to say he is an atheist / democract / devout / republican whatever in his Twitter stream? Post jokes about Obama or Bush, etc? Pro or against the death penalty? Etc. If that's allowed, then why wouldn't be having an opinion about sexuality (which is another topic people see as political/religious/moral/whatever). I find that the reason some people ask (and get) people fired from their jobs or thrown out of projects because of their view on such issues, is not because such issues are more clean cut than the others mentioned, but because they can get away with it. In conservative places they hurt people with progressive opinions, in progresive places they hurt people with conservative opinions. And that's what I dislike the most, people seeing so that active harm happens to others they disagree with (as opposed to those others just stating their opinion). For me that's worse than being a bigot -- it's being a bad human.
- comrh 11y agoHis twitter bio has "@opalrb core" in it, making him a representative of the project though.
- coldtea 11y agoYeah, that sounds like it should be a project twitter account. That would be in violation of a project's public image even if he just posted cat pictures...
- duncan_bayne 11y agoIt seems like splitting Twitter accounts - one for Opal-related stuff, the other for personal - would be the right thing to do. I've asked for clarification here: https://github.com/CoralineAda/contributor_covenant/issues/59 https://github.com/CoralineAda/contributor_covenant/issues/5...
- rewqfdsa 11y agoWhy shouldn't I be able to mention biographical details in a personal account? I should be able to mention being from Milwaukee, liking hot dogs, or working on Redis if I want to.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoIndeed. That's my take on it too, which is why I've asked Coraline (or any other contributors) for clarification.
- coldtea 11y agoYou should. You just shouldn't name that account with the name of a project that's not yours and you're just one of the people that work on it, giving a false sense that yours is some kind of project account.
- 11y ago
- chazu 11y agoI understand your perspective on this and have a similar one, however I definitely think a double-standard is applied to these sorts of issues due to the fashionability of certain political stances. For example, Steve Klabnik has tweeted crassly about how capitalists should be killed, but I don't see anyone clamoring to remove him from projects. Those offended by his quasi-threatening political posturing (and there are many) simply aren't interested in publicly silencing him for his opinions, while its become a common tactic for those on the other side of many issues. That disparity is a cause for concern for me, personally.