9 ms·
Military's 15-year quest for perfect radio is a blueprint for failing big (2012)
- AceJohnny2 11y ago(2012)
- jackgavigan 11y agoThe British Army's Bowman radio system suffered from similar troubles: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowman_(communications_system)#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowman_(communications_system)... I think credit should be given for the standards-based, open architecture approach. I believe that is the right approach for a procurement project like this. The problem appears to be with the manner in which the requirements and delivery were managed. It's easy to scoff at such failures but three-person startups and MVPs are a world apart in terms of the scale, time horizons and practical challenges faced by military hardware. It's a pity the armed forces don't make better use of commercial talent when they're undertaking this kind of procurement project. They may be at the cutting edge when it comes to the technology they're looking to reply but the management techniques they're using are about 60 years out of date.
- akira2501 11y ago> I think credit should be given for the standards-based, open architecture approach. True, but then the decision to expose FPGAs as part of the programming interface was absolutely wacky. FPGAs are some of the most proprietary devices on the market, usually requiring a vendor toolchain to even produce working bitstreams for the devices. They defined the interface at the wrong level. They should have developed something like an MII interface and focused on open framing and message protocol formats rather than on open source waveform generators.
- arethuza 11y agoIt seems to be a fundamental principle of the British military to have world class personnel and training and then give them some awful equipment.
- jackgavigan 11y agoBuilds character! ;-)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe project might have simply been the result of the "revolving door:" military people ensuring big profits for defense contractors who pay them high salaries as "advisors" later. Most of these projects that appear to be failures are actually successes of theft from taxpayer. Article on this below with examples: http://www.counterpunch.org/2014/02/11/the-best-government-money-can-buy/ http://www.counterpunch.org/2014/02/11/the-best-government-m... On the technology front, I was about to suggest they use Field Programmable RF to help solve this and then look what I find: http://finance.yahoo.com/news/altera-lime-microsystems-demonstrate-completely-120000955.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/altera-lime-microsystems-demon...
- rsync 11y agoHow precious and naive to refer to this as a "failure". $6 billion and counting in the hands of government contractors, lobbyists and freshly minted industry experts retired out of the service. Sounds like mission accomplished to me.
- rayiner 11y agoFlashbacks! My first job involved JTRS. We were working on an unrelated DARPA project: XG. The purpose of which was to develop the opportunistic spectrum use capability described in the article. Early on, they saddled us with the requirement of implementing our technology as an SCA component, even in simulation. I glued some open source reference implementation together with our code, but we ended up hiring a consultant to write a whole SCA implementation in house. Which we then ended up throwing away because it was pointless to do that in a technology development platform. That said, I don't think CORBA is the worst thing ever. It was slow as shit back for the day, but in this age of HTTP based RPC services it seems lightweight and efficient. Memory management in the C++ binding was broken by design, however.
- hydrogen18 11y agoI worked on this project. It's a project filled with realizable goals and impossible mandates. SCA is the most useless thing I've ever encountered. The requirement to use CORBA is simply impossible, there is no way you can make a real-time system using CORBA. The project I worked on recently changed its goal from being the high bandwidth backbone of the Army to >"The program will demonstrate the HNW version 3.0 waveform (supports the JC4ISR radio) and then store the waveform in the DOD Waveform Repository" From: http://www.dote.osd.mil/pub/reports/FY2014/pdf/army/2014win-t.pdf http://www.dote.osd.mil/pub/reports/FY2014/pdf/army/2014win-... The technology is there, the need is there, the funding has been there, but the overall management of it by the military is awful. You can't really fault the contractors either, they are just doing what they are told.
- platz 11y ago> there is no way you can make a real-time system using CORBA It seems the military uses CORBA frequently for such systems. "the Navy has specified the use of the Common Object Request Broker Architecture (CORBA)—the military's favorite mission-critical middleware model." http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/10/the-navys-newest-warship-is-powered-by-linux/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/10/the-na... and http://www.ois.com/Markets/military-and-aerospace.html http://www.ois.com/Markets/military-and-aerospace.html The military has control of the allowed CORBA implementations so they don't suffer from different runtimes that plauged it's usage in Internet scenarios, and get all the typed benefits and speed benefits. Not that I think CORBA is necessarily a great protocol in general, but then again I don't have any idea what tradeoffs are appropriate for the military either.
- hydrogen18 11y agoUsing CORBA in a system and building a system entirely using CORBA are two different things. All of the branches wind up granting individual projects some degree of leeway over these types of mandates. Mostly because the military needs the products to actually work.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's a common problem. I griped about their mandating CORBA for use with separation kernels. I figured we could do something simpler like Sun's XDR, a stronger ASN.1, or JSON. Make a tool to autogen import or export code. Not happening. Meanwhile, Galois built a high assurance version of ASN.1 and ZeroMQ has shown CORBA for the outdated garbage it is. Had mandates not existed, the contractors would've probably been able to pick these right up to get their benefits and do certified implementations. But it's the military...
- digikata 11y agoAny military project with a 'J' in the acronym increases the likelihood of the program going over-budget...
- tlrobinson 11y agoI was thinking the same thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Strike_Fighter_program#Cost_overruns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Strike_Fighter_program#C... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Tactical_Radio_System#Problems_and_restructuring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Tactical_Radio_System#Pr... Any others?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- digikata 11y agoOff hand: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-169_Joint_Common_Missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-169_Joint_Common_Missile - cancelled https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Air-to-Ground_Missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Air-to-Ground_Missile - follow on to the JCM (not sure about it's status - they may have gotten the planning right by putting in for a long dev period up front) Really though it's a tongue-in-cheek observation with a basis in the reality that a 'Joint' program implies multiple service branches sourcing requirements. In turn, that increases requirements count and complexity, which in turn has a non-linear and negative effect of program efficiency. It also often moves program decisions from technical tradeoffs made by engineers into political space between branches.
- gte525u 11y agoJoint Cargo Aircraft - awarded then retired https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alenia_C-27J_Spartan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alenia_C-27J_Spartan
- conover 11y ago> "The project's SCA architecture allowed software to manipulate field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) in the radio hardware to reconfigure how its electronics functioned, exposing those FPGAs as CORBA objects." That sounds like a recipe for slow torture.
- Kenji 11y agoYeah they could make Guantanamo prisoners work on it, that's probably better than waterboarding.
- superuser2 11y agoYou joke, but many terrorists and terrorism suspects are engineers...
- blackguardx 11y agoI've never heard of CORBA but this is how some of the demodulation options on Agilent (Keysight) spectrum analyzers are implemented. Care was taken to ensure that new measurement schemes could be loaded in tens of milliseconds, which makes it appear instantaneous to a person.
- jschwartzi 11y agoSOAP was created because CORBA was slow and had interoperability problems. I'll let that sink in.
- coldcode 11y agoAny significantly large government technology project is indistinguishable from fantasy.
- jfoutz 11y agoEh, it varies. The apollo program was pretty good. There was some stuff with networking that seemed to take off a few years ago. The human genome project was pretty spiffy. The win rate isn't real good though.
- hga 11y agoThe Human Genome Project wasn't exactly a marvel of government big science: https://en.wikipedia.org/?title=Craig_Venter#Human_Genome_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/?title=Craig_Venter#Human_Genome_Pr... On the other hand, the Manhattan Project beats all of these aside from that obscure networking stuff, Apollo and the HGP were more taking existing working stuff and doing it on a more ambitious scale. I've been studying the Manhattan Project as of late, and it's for example amazing how much the plutonium path was pushed before they understood really important details about it, like fast neutron cross section, average number of neutrons from fast neutron fission (needs to be > 1), how to chemically isolate it after transmutation in a natural uranium reactor, and how to do that with that fantastically radioactive irradiated stuff. Or the faith that they'd be able to develop a good enough membrane for the Oak Ridge gaseous diffusion plant (high pressure + fiercely corrosive UF6). Or how they got all this in motion before having good bomb designs, and how the Pu240 contamination of reactor brewed vs. cyclotron created plutonium required getting the most difficult bomb design to work ... and it worked the first time! Or how they set to making multiple reactors before they really knew they'd work, and if the size they'd chosen would work in the face of the neutron poisons it would likely generate. And in such short time; study of the people and their methods of management (e.g. Groves and Oppenheimer) is very worthwhile for many HN readers.
- noir_lord 11y agoAny good sources to start from?
- oldpond 11y agoCorba. LOL.
- kzhahou 11y agoHere's the Software Communications Architecture (SCA) spec. Knock yourself out. http://jpeojtrs.mil/sca/Documents/SCAv4_1_DRAFT/SCA_4.1_DRAFT_ScaSpecification.pdf http://jpeojtrs.mil/sca/Documents/SCAv4_1_DRAFT/SCA_4.1_DRAF...
- revelation 11y agoThat's funny, it looks like they are building an operating system. And by that I mean theres nothing in there that gets you any closer to, you know, actual communication hardware.
- nostromo 11y agoI love how deeply nested the requirements are. > Could everyone on the call turn to section 3.1.3.4.1.7.5.1.1 titled "Brief Rationale"
- JonathonW 11y agoMeh. That one's only 139 pages... that's short and straightforward compared to some of the military specs I've had the pleasure of dealing with.
- Aloha 11y agoI question why they couldn't buy COTS P25 radios for tactical communication in a hardened form factor - I'm sure Motorola (or whomever else) would have gladly whipped up a extra durable version of an XTS3000 or XTS5000 - P25 by its nature supports pluggable encryption, so you can use just about anything with it. For Lower than 30mhz - there are many COTS solutions using well proven technology, even supporting digital encrypted audio available.
- rayiner 11y agoWhat do you do when the enemy deploys a jammer? One part of the military's broader cognitive radio strategy is/was radios that could avoid jamming by hopping to different parts of the spectrum.
- Aloha 11y agoBuilding a simple durable FHSS system isn't hard either, you could then effectively send a P25 data stream on top of it - the radio access channel and data stream are reasonably divorced in P25. Even then, its hard to build an effective broadband jammer - you simple move to another part in a say ~120MHz band.
- elithrar 11y agoNo doubt part of it was trying to "have it all". They wanted radios that could act as VSAT terminals (for field to base comms), data terminals (for which P25 is poorly suited) and for operational voice with fallback (UHF, VHF, HF). Otherwise yes, you can buy (today) hardened P25 handsets with IP66+ rated fist microphones and all that. (my opinion is that the project was madness on a hardware level: all of those filters and FPGAs were competing with size, battery life, cost and complexity)
- Aloha 11y agoOh agreed - and P25 can do packet data sorta anyhow, as you said, not well suited to integration with the existing military radio systems. I think the P25 datastream however is a useful construct to build a larger radio system around however. They wanted it all, and got nothing, the usual ending when you try to build something around a "grand unified model" there is always an edge case.
- slr5555 11y agoArticle does not mention FlexRadio which is a SDR that gets great reviews from HAM operators. They have been around for a while.
- god_bless_texas 11y ago"Jitters" is just 2 years of bad memories
- jmnicolas 11y agoI'm not an aviation enthusiast but I heard the F35 (Joint Strike Fighter) is suffering the same problems as this radio project, and that it will probably never be usable in war conditions. It seems to me that we are reaching the limits of what can be done in big technological projects if we don't get rid of greed and internal politics. At the top you have big corpos that want to milk the government and at the bottom you have people that will make decisions that will advance their careers whatever the consequences for the project.
- hydrogen18 11y agoIt's a plane that still can't fire its gun while in flight. I'd say the F-35 is a failure. For the cost of the program, we could have just given the Marines full scale aircraft carriers.