4 ms·
This is a member of one marginalized population (transgender people) trying to exert pressure on a member of another marginalized (or quickly becoming so) popul
by kbenson 11y ago
This is a member of one marginalized population (transgender people) trying to exert pressure on a member of another marginalized (or quickly becoming so) population (transphobic people). It's sad that the irony of the situation is lost on the person requesting the removal of the core developer.
If the default response was not to try to punish and remove those with differing views, transgender people would most likely have a much different history.
- krainboltgreene 11y ago> It's sad that the irony of the situation is lost on the person requesting the removal of the core developer. Do you also think it would be a sad irony for a person of color to want a KKK member off the team? This comment is so bad and lacking so much empathy as to be harmful. Ugh.
- chazu 11y agoWhile I don't condone hateful remarks (I'm queer myself, fwiw) I don't think its correct to equate being a member of a terrorist organization like the KKK with making a few bigoted tweets. That being said I haven't looked into the nature of @elia 's comments, so maybe they're egregious.
- kbenson 11y ago> Do you also think it would be a sad irony for a person of color to want a KKK member off the team? Yes, for the exactly the same reasons I stated, as long as the KKK member just expressed views, and there weren't associated actions (maybe membership in the KKK is enough if there are dues and those go towards specific actions?) > This comment is so bad and lacking so much empathy as to be harmful. Ugh. I do empathize, but if we turn this around, and it was a transgender person under pressure to leave from a transphobic person, how is the argument different? Keep in mind that if your argument uses social norms, how would it play out 20 or 30 years ago? How would you defend the right of transgender people then? I submit that a safe default to protect marginalized people to some degree, independent of social norms so that it's less susceptible to current public opinion, is to default to leaving people's personal opinions out of other aspects of their lives. Sometimes it means letting people get away with bad behavior, such as transgender slander, but other times it allows for marginalized people that face extreme penalties from society for personal decisions to survive, and I think that's worthwhile. It's the concept of free speech, expanded. Though I may hate what you say,I will defend your right to say it, and protect you from excessive social punishment.
- rylee 11y agoAre you seriously implying that transphobic people deserve to be considered "oppressed" or "marginalized"? That they deserve our respect?
- kbenson 11y ago> Are you seriously implying that transphobic people deserve to be considered "oppressed" or "marginalized"? In the strictest sense, yes. The same way convicts can be truthfully said to be opressed or marginalized. That doesn't mean it's not deserved. > That they deserve our respect? Only in that a large basis for what we believe to be acceptable or not comes from cultural norms, which can change over time, so it's a good stand-by to treat personal opinions and choices as irrelevant for professional decisions where possible. There are of course points at which it's hard to argue that someone's personal choices and decisions are affecting other aspects of their life and the people around them. In other words, I don't respect all opinions, but I respect people's right to have an opinion I don't agree with.
- KingMob 11y agoTransphobes are not marginalized. They are the silent majority across much of the world, including America, and only now are we reaching a place where transphobes can face any criticism at all.
- kbenson 11y agoWhile they may be the silent majority, they are, at least in America, largely silent. Put another way, while being transphobic is not yet marginalized, publicly expressing transphobic views is quickly becoming marginalized (thankfully). The fact that there's a discussion about this issue is proof of this, in my eyes.
- DanBC 11y agoHow many transphobic people have been murdered for being transphobic? I get that the aggression is unhelpful, but your comment ignores the years of murder, rape, and beatings that trans people have been through.
- kbenson 11y agoI'm simply commenting that using some of the same behavior that is deemed unfair when use against a transgender person against a transphobic person does not immediately make it acceptable. I think the behavior itself if part of the problem, and I think it's sad that this is not seen the same way by many people. I understand the desires of the transgender community, and my desires align with theirs, I want to see vocally transphobic people punished in some manner. I accept that as my nature. I also believe we are all better off if we keep these desires in check, to a degree. It's too easy to feel justified when the situation is reversed.