5 ms·
Yay, tax code simplification. Oh crap, "flat tax." This is the fundamental problem. Everybody wants a simpler tax system. But nobody can agree on which parts
by mikeash 11y ago
Yay, tax code simplification.
Oh crap, "flat tax."
This is the fundamental problem. Everybody wants a simpler tax system. But nobody can agree on which parts to remove, or how to change it. The current system is close to what you get when everybody tries to get what they want. Even if you blew it up and started over, I think you'd get back to the current state pretty fast.
Edit: everybody can stop replying to my comment proposing your favorite simplified tax system and explaining why it's great. You're missing the point here. If you want to discuss your favorite tax system, make a top-level comment.
- Retra 11y agoThis is how I feel about anarchists. "Things would be better if we did away with the system." "But what about when things go wrong?" "Well, there would be agreements in place to handle that." "Yes, that's called a 'system of government.'" Or, "The government shouldn't tell me what to do." "The word 'govern' literally means 'to conduct the policy, actions, and affairs of people.' That is, in fact, the whole point of government: to tell you what to do."
- mikeash 11y agoI remember a comment on HN a little while ago which went something like, "Why does the government need to get involved? Why can't people just come together and figure out how to deal with it?" I replied pointing out that this is what government is.
- icebraining 11y agoThat's just playing with multiple definitions. When people say "government" they mean the government, that is, the representative bodies that form our current system, not the abstract concept of any system by which a state is governed. Governance is certainly necessary. Having "a government" is just one possible way of achieving it.
- dnautics 11y agoit is what government is, with guns and jails.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- slayed0 11y agohttps://youtu.be/fibDNwF8bjs https://youtu.be/fibDNwF8bjs Whitest Kids You Know illustrated this perfectly in a sketch routine
- 3pt14159 11y agoFlat tax + basic income is the only sane way forward. Most other systems lead to stupid incentives, unjust inequality, and over priced accountants. For example. Assume a household of two people. one earns $20k per year, the other earns $80k per year. With a 50% tax and a $10k (after tax) per year basic income you get the following: 2*$10k + 0.5 * ($20k + $80k) = $70k Now if each partner earned the same you would get: 2*$10k + 0.5 * ($50k + $50k) = $70k Which is exactly what you want. The problem with income splitting measure that try to replicate this is that they lead to a perverse disincentive to divorce. So in the first example, the person earning $80k would no longer be able to offload part of his income to the lower paying person, and the two persons effective income decreases just when their expenses double. Furthermore it discriminates against people that are single, which is politically expedient, but unjust. It also solves the welfare and old age security paperwork problem. There are some other problems: like having a higher tax rate to pay for all this basic income, but ultimately I think it would unleash more minds on problems that matter instead of setting up family trusts for the wealthy.
- mikeash 11y agoYour proposal sounds good, but I doubt it'll fly, because the people who like the idea of basic income and the people who like the idea of a flat tax have almost no overlap. My point is that everybody agrees on simplifying the tax code but nobody can agree on how, so it probably can't happen.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoActually, there's quite a lot of overlap. Milton Friedman, who is worshipped by much of the right, advocated a "negative income tax", which is basically the same thing.
- paulhauggis 11y ago"It also solves the welfare and old age security paperwork problem. There are some other problems: like having a higher tax rate to pay for all this basic income, but ultimately I think it would unleash more minds on problems that matter instead of setting up family trusts for the wealthy." A basic income is unsustainable. As more and more people become dependent on it, taxes will only increase over time and we will run out of tax dollars. In addition to this, there will be massive inflation. "instead of setting up family trusts for the wealthy." I see where this is going now: the wealthy need to be punished for earning more money than the rest of us. This has never really been a good strategy historically for creating a happy and free society. The ironic part is that the more rules you impose on the public in terms of taxes and money, the less mobility the lower and middle classes actually have. The rich can just leave the country and still make a killing with new laws in place like what you propose. The middle and lower class don't have the luxury making it that much more difficult to start and run a company (which is really the only way to have true economic freedom).