3 ms·
> many of their dads scored low on a standard yardstick her > research team was using to evaluate the parent-child bond. > ... The children described rich,
by wodenokoto 11y ago
> many of their dads scored low on a standard yardstick her
> research team was using to evaluate the parent-child bond.
> ... The children described rich, warm relationships with
> their fathers ... “My dad gives me encouragement to do
> things,” or, “My dad tells me he thinks I can do well.”
What kind of yard stick are they traditionally using?
- bonaldi 11y agoIt says in the article (or in the linked article which covers the same ground). It's tests like the "unsafe situation": a baby is put in peril, and the mother has to reassure it. Babies that are quickly reassured typically do better overall, and this is seen as a sign of strong bond. But fathers traditionally score low on this test (as babies appear to prefer the mothering parent for such reassurance)
- jerf 11y agoFWIW, if you hear people complaining about how things are "feminized", this is the sort of thing they mean, rather than the images that probably immediately leap to mind... a social science discipline that (quite correctly!) has known about how important good mothering is for a long time, but is just recently (not quite 2015, research on this line has been ongoing, but not for that long either) getting around to discovering that the standard fathering is good too. And note that the reason that fathering's importance has been missed is basically that it's not mothering, and scored poorly on metrics that measure mothering, with significant casual assumptions built into the system that mothering === parenting. There's no changes in science or technology recently that would lead to this being any easier to discover or quantify now. From a strictly scientific perspective, it's actually quite shameful that only now is this being uncovered scientifically, and points to deep and systematic problems in the relevant disciplines. Consider than from an evo-psych perspective, even as questionable as it may be sometimes, the hypothesis that fathers are just generally not very good parents should be immediately suspect, not suspect decades later.
- Kluny 11y agoGod yes - it amazes me that anyone who has ever spent time with or dated a child of divorce doesn't instantly comprehend how important dads are, and how much their absence can fuck a kid up.
- crusso 11y agoThere were decades long trends in psychology that attempted to "undo the damage of male-dominated thinking and behaviors". It went too far and so now we're seeing lots of these combination "duh!"/"aha!" moments in the field. See also the research showing that schools have become heavily biased against the success of boys.
- fleitz 11y agoSchool might be but life generally is very favorable to traditionally masculine characteristics. Life favors thinking and creative problem solving, school favors regurgitation and submission to authority. As an example my son doesn't do to well in math, however, he's been multiplying/dividing since Kindergarten. My daughter at least appears weaker (I think she's hiding her skills) but does much better on math at school. Don't pay too much attention to statistics, bring your concerns to your administrators. They have a lot of work to do and don't need parents making complaints and creating extra work.
- marquis 11y ago>My daughter at least appears weaker (I think she's hiding her skills Note here (from a girl) remembering my childhood and maths: my interest in all things technical came to life when my father (figure) showed an interest in playing chess with me, and in building things like aerodynamically-interesting paper/card planes, rocket launchers and kites.
- fleitz 11y agoYup my daughter has recently started 'admitting' to being smart after we did an electronics kit and making minecraft mods, she also started hanging out with different friends who seem to appreciate intelligence more and are way less catty.
- cheald 11y agoI just wanted to chime in and say that your talking about your dad playing chess sparked a bunch of warm memories. Mine played with me, too, and never pulled his punches - the day that I finally beat him was a tremendous triumph. I thought we were just playing a game - he was teaching me how to analyze a problem, and how to anticipate and evaluate my actions and their outcomes. What a gift! I can't wait to teach my kids.
- swasheck 11y agoprobably the same kind that our schools are using to evaluate educational success. one that fits a narrow perspective of success.