3 ms·
And after reading your post, words "trolling" and "easily offended for no reason" come to mind. H1-B visa clearly stipulates that no American workers can be dis
by gambiting 11y ago
And after reading your post, words "trolling" and "easily offended for no reason" come to mind. H1-B visa clearly stipulates that no American workers can be displaced in order to hire H1-B workers. That's the law. If a company breaks the law, an appropriate punishment would be to bar that company from hiring H1-B visa workers again, at least temporarily - just like you take away the driver licence of someone who is caught driving while drunk.
- maxlybbert 11y ago> H1-B visa clearly stipulates that no American workers can be displaced in order to hire H1-B workers. That's the law. I have no opinion on whether this requirement makes sense. However, I don't see how "that's the law" is a defense against "that requirement looks racist, or at least causes disparate impact" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact ). It's entirely possible for a law to harm particular groups of people more than others.
- tomjen3 11y agoI am not against preventing the company from hiring new workers if they misuse the H1-B visa. I am against forcing them to fire the current employees, who may have houses, friends, etc. You punish the drunk driver, you don't deport his employees. This entire problem would be moot if you, rather than not renewed their visa, upgraded it to a greencard. The entire HB-1 abuse would be pointless if the US had a reasonable system in place for legally acquiring visas. As it is now the only way to legally get in (other than a few specialities or people with US spouses) is the HB-1 visa.
- xjlin0 11y agoWill current law work? Disney won't be punished because it's just outsourcing some business. Tata won't be punished because Tata didn't displace American workers in Tata company (all from H-1 I guess?). So company avoid punishment anyway?